Making gnocchi for the first time today -- 2 questions
Ok, Hazan and Bittman say no egg, many others add egg or yolks. To egg or not to egg? Second, should I boil or bake the potatoes? Again, Hazan and Bittman say boil, but others recommend baking so they don't get waterlogged. I'm not one to question the experts, but am tempted to bake. Also, I'd like to make them a few hours before folks get here and then boil and sauce them when folks arrive. Are there any problems with that? Thoughts for a first timer? Help!
Recommended by Food52
14 Comments
ps. I ended up following Hazan's recommendation and not using an egg. Next time I'll think I'll add one to compare. Then I'm going to try to reproduce the carrot gnocchi that a favorite local restaurant makes. I'm a gnocchi addict!
As for boiling v. baking your potatoes, I like boiling mine best because baked potatoes are sometimes a little too dry in my experience. You do want to be careful not to over-boil them, or you'll lose potato as they disintegrate into the water. Always use russet potatoes; red or white will be too starchy and give you gluey gnocchi. Always mash/rice your potatoes very well, so there are no lumps. I'll second that recommendation to NOT blend them in a food processor as a short-cut!
I make my gnocchi in huge batches, then freeze them on waxed paper before transferring them to bags or containers for long-term freezing. They keep very well for about 6 months this way and you can boil them directly from the freezer. Setting them aside fresh and boiling them when people get there will work just fine. I do recommend covering them with plastic wrap so they don't dry out or get crusty just sitting exposed to the air.
Here's a link to my recipe for butternut squash gnocchi, if it helps (it's gluten-free and uses non-traditional flour). You can use the same amount of russet potatoes in place of the butternut squash for a potato gnocchi.
http://beyondcelery.blogspot.com/2010/11/butter-em-up.html
The egg makes for a more forgiving dough, so I always add one or two depending on how much potato and flour you are using.