Does anyone have a CHEWY Peanut Butter cookie?

Is it so much to ask to want a truly *Chewy all the way through pb cookie- not crumbly or tender, not your average fork imprint cookie but more reminiscent of a thin craggly bakery sugar cookie, one you can really sink your teeth into? Many Ive tried claim to be chewy but are more tender and crumbly, or soft in the middle. If anyone has a recipe that fits this description I will be eternally grateful!:)

Jennifer W
  • 2146 views
  • 3 Comments

3 Comments

drbabs
drbabs June 9, 2023
I am neither dairy nor gluten-free, but I LOVE these, and they are chewy. https://oven.ly/blogs/recipes/salted-peanut-butter-cookies
 
Nicole D.
Nicole D. June 7, 2023
I think we can help Jennifer! Ella Quittner worked her magic to create three perfect, chewy cookies — sugar, chocolate chip, and peanut butter: https://food52.com/blog/26670-how-to-make-chewy-cookies. One of the tricks is swapping out half the butter for vegetable oil. You can see all her experiments and the chewy peanut butter recipe at the end of the story. —Nicole Davis, Community Editor
 
Jennifer W.
Jennifer W. June 7, 2023
Oooh yay! Thank you so much I will try this next!
 
Recommended by Food52

Popular on Food52