substitute for Cilantro?

I would like to make the Cilantro-Scallion Bread from the new Bon Appetit, http://www.bonappetit.com..., but I am not a fan of Cilantro! Any opinions on a substitute. I am thinking parsley...

  • 2719 views
  • 8 Comments

8 Comments

Lucia F. June 26, 2011
Thank you for all the great suggestions. I went with parsley! My husband tried one and love it.
This was a great recipe. The dough is wonderful to work with.
Can't wait to try one myself.
Answer image
 
Panfusine June 26, 2011
technically you could substitute most herbs.. (my choice for substitutions would be dill), but you will get a different end result..
 
Verdigris June 25, 2011
Oh, I think I read it on another foodpickle response, but if the soapy taste is what bothers you about cilantro, try just using the stems and roots. Apparently the leaves of cilantro give off the flavor many don't like.
 
the P. June 25, 2011
seconding pierino: parsley and mint when using it fresh in a salad or salsa. but if you're baking, oregano seems like a better choice.
 
pierino June 25, 2011
Try a combination of parsley and mint chopped together. I sympathize with the people who can't taste the background flavor of cilantro because it really is good, but unfortunately not an "acquired taste."
 
Lucia F. June 25, 2011
My husband loves oregano! Thanks for the suggestion!
 
sexyLAMBCHOPx June 25, 2011
I confess that I detest cilantro. I often swap out for parsley but if its an herb that needs to shine in a recipe like the one you mentioned perhaps thyme, tarragon or dill?
 
phyllis June 25, 2011
There really isn't a substitute for the taste of cilantro. I don't have the 'bad' gene, but have friends who do, and for them I usually substitute parsley and/or oregano/marjoram.
 
Recommended by Food52