Make Ahead

Olive Oil & Maple Granola From Nekisia Davis

October 11, 2022
4.7
184 Ratings
Photo by Julia Gartland
  • Prep time 10 minutes
  • Cook time 45 minutes
  • Makes About 7 cups
Author Notes

This recipe, adapted very slightly from Early Bird Foods' best-selling Farmhand's Choice Granola, is like muesli after a vampy makeover. Olive oil, maple, brown sugar, and coarse salt form a rich, shaggy crust on wholesome innards like oats, pecans, and coconut shards.

Helpful tools for this recipe:
- Five Two Wooden Spoons
- Food52 x Rosti Ultimate Melamine Mixing Bowl
- Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Baking Sheets


Genius Recipes

Test Kitchen Notes

Granola might be one of those snacks you tend to buy packaged, which is fine, of course, but once I started making my own granola—specifically, olive oil and maple syrup granola—it’s very hard to go back to the store-bought stuff. This Genius recipe from Nekisia Davis was actually inspired by a brand’s granola with a comparable ingredients list; however, when you make your own granola, there are a few major upsides.

First of all, you have more control over flavor: You can add an extra handful of your favorite nuts and seeds in the ingredients list, or if you want to swap in different nuts (almonds, walnuts, or hazelnuts would be amazing), no one’s going to stop you! Regardless, when you’re toasting your own nuts, the flavor is just always going to be better than the packaged alternative. Plus, if you feel like adding a bit of extra seasoning, like ground cinnamon or cardamom, or stirring in some dried fruit after baking, you’re only doing the granola a favor. And did you notice the yield here? Seven whole cups! Take that, 12-ounce bag of packaged granola.

But perhaps the best thing about homemade granola is that you ultimately control the price. While a box or bag of the stuff may run you over $10 a pop at the store, when you’re buying the ingredients, you can shop at the bulk bin for the individual components, which is nearly always the more affordable option at the store already. Plus, you probably already have at least a few of this recipe’s ingredients already in your kitchen. —The Editors

Continue After Advertisement
Watch This Recipe
Olive Oil & Maple Granola From Nekisia Davis
Ingredients
  • 3 cups old-fashioned rolled oats
  • 1 1/4 cups raw pecans, left whole or coarsely chopped
  • 1 cup hulled raw pumpkin seeds
  • 1 cup hulled raw sunflower seeds
  • 1 cup unsweetened coconut chips
  • 3/4 cup pure maple syrup
  • 1/2 cup extra-virgin olive oil
  • 1/2 cup packed light brown sugar
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt, plus more to taste
Directions
  1. Heat the oven to 300°F. In a large bowl, mix the oats, pecans, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, coconut, syrup, oil, brown sugar, and 1 teaspoon of the salt until well combined.
  2. Spread the mixture in an even layer on a rimmed baking sheet. Bake, stirring every 10 to 15 minutes, for about 45 minutes total, until the granola is toasted.
  3. Remove the granola from the oven; season with salt to taste. Let cool completely before serving.
  4. Do Ahead: The granola can be made 1 month ahead. Transfer to an airtight container and store at room temperature.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

Recipe by: Genius Recipes

310 Reviews

VC December 17, 2024
I'm back with an update to the all time best granola recipe -
I've played around with the oils, and have been using coconut oil lately. Subtle but nice change.
Also, maple syrups can really pop up the flavors - runamok has some AMAZING choices, and recently I found maple syrups that are smoky and even spicy!! YUMMMMM.
I also add orange zest, cardamon, cinnamon, flax, chia seeds (extra nutrition!) and that secret umami ingredient, fennel pollen. Chopped up crystallized ginger also continues to get raves and on the regular list of adds...
Its a great recipe to adapt to your or your lucky recipients taste! ;)
Jill R. December 17, 2024
VC - I love some of your suggestions - the spicy maple syrups, orange zest, chia seeds, fennel pollen and most especially the crystallized ginger and orange zest! Where might one purchase fennel pollen or chia seeds (a health food store?)Or the spicy maple syrup (although I guess all one really has to do is to add a pinch of cayenne flakes or ground flakes). Thanks for posting. I'm going to use some of your ideas!
VC December 17, 2024
I buy fennel pollen in a larger size from the Pollen Ranch online. Its quite good in many things, very subtle add esp in cookies. Chia should be at Whole Foods or Trader Joes (I get mine at a natural health grocery store). The spicy maple syrup was from Ghetto Gastro from Martie.com as a close out, but I do see their online store.
VC December 17, 2024
I also wonder about using Honey as a substitute - must try next time with a "hot" honey which is widely available as well!! LOVE LOVE LOVE this recipe!
Jill R. December 17, 2024
Thanks, VC! I'll check it out. Wishing you happy holidays. All the best. Jill
Maura December 17, 2024
My favorite for years, I always gift it at the holidays!
Amy V. November 23, 2024
Can I use toasted nuts and seeds. How would I adjust the baking time?
Nancy C. November 24, 2024
I wait to add any of that sort of thing until after the oats are toasted -- because I always have toasted nuts and seeds available.
Andrea M. November 22, 2024
Move over store bought granola! This recipe will make sure you never buy vanilla again. It’s a perfectly balanced combination of salty and sweet. I followed the recipe exactly and it was wonderful. I’m going to make another batch and give it away for the holidays. 10/10 recommend!
Cccb September 22, 2024
Thanks to this recipe I haven’t bought store bought granola in years. The whole family loves this and I feel good about the ingredients. It’s easily adapted to your likes or based on what you have on hand. I’ve cut back on the sugar at times or swapped the brown sugar for date sugar and it’s the same result. I typically prefer to add more cinnamon as well or in the fall pumpkin spice. Can’t go wrong with this one and it whips up so easily.
holly D. August 1, 2024
I used two sheet pants for this. It seemed like I wasn't sure how it would actually get crispy with so much in one pan. Of course I'm not a professional Baker I do not have a whole few pan I have a half sheet pan for a home oven so maybe this was made for an actual whole sheet pan? I don't know but my granola was crispy. Speaking of crispy I wish I had used parchment paper because this really sticks to the pan. When it's hot it's easy to stir around but once it cools it's sticking to my pan. Unfortunately I didn't realize that my oats were getting a little bit stale so mine doesn't taste as good as it should but I can still tell this is a really good recipe!
holly D. August 1, 2024
*sheet pans. Of course not sheet pants!
Gail July 31, 2024
I’ve been making it for years now! I double or more the recipe, make it in a big roasting pan, cut the maple syrup and brown sugar by 3/4, and it’s delicious!
Arnell July 31, 2024
This is a great granola recipe easy and popular.
Susan July 19, 2024
I am guessing most granola recipes are similar. The restaurant 11 Madison Park Avenue have an almost identical recipe which adds dried tart cherries after cooking! I make it with water ever seeds I have on hand and of course 3 cups of oats. I like others reduce the sugar content and use avacado oil!
ustabahippie June 23, 2024
3/4 cup maple syrup and also brown sugar!! Waaay too much imo.
Hunter June 23, 2024
I’ve been making this for years. Makes a great gift! I omit the extra sugar, it’s plenty sweet with just Maple Syrup. Sometimes I bake it a little longer, depending o the color of the granola. Also stirring is key. Be sure and let it sit for an hour or two after pulling from the oven. I also like to sprinkle some Maldon flake salt on it as soon as it’s out of the oven.
Nancy C. June 8, 2024
A very nice recipe. I've been making granola for a while, and decided to try this one today. I cut down on the oil and sweeteners, (as I always do!) and still found it a bit too sweet. I stirred and flipped it every 15 minutes, and then let it bake a little bit longer--you don't want to burn it-- but wanted to make sure it was not soggy. My husband likes dried fruit in his granola which adds sweetness, so next time I will cut it more.
Little P. June 2, 2024
Actually, I would like some input. My granola never crisped up. I made no changes to the recipe and made sure the granola was toasted brown before removing it from the oven. It was still chewy when completely cooled. Later, I tried to toast it up again, but, the same thing happened. IT was soft and chewy when cool. While I love the flavor, I am missing that granola crunch. Any suggestions or advice?
Deborah J. June 2, 2024
Did you stir it periodically while it was baking? If not, then that is why it remained chewy. I usually stir mine like every 10 minutes as I like my granola crunchy. People who like more of a chewy granola would probably have not while baking, allowing it to remain chewy when it cools.
Little P. June 2, 2024
Hi, thanks for your response! I did stir it, but more like every 15/20 minutes. I'm in Seattle and it's wet and humid here now. Maybe that's a factor?
Deborah J. June 3, 2024
I'm in Lacey, WA so I would say no to humidity being the cause as it is quite humid here, too. What quality of maple syrup did you use? I know that the lower qualities tend to have more water in it and that could possibly be a factor. Unfortunately, the lower quality of maple syrups don't list the water factor in their product so it is difficult to check on that. I only use the maple syrups from Trader Joe's so you may want to give that a try. Also, increase the amount of stirring of your granola to help it get crispier. Now I'm going to have to make a batch as you've got me hungry for it, lol!
Little P. June 4, 2024
Hi, thanks for the input. Maybe it's the stirring more frequently that I need to try next time. I also used TJ's maple syrup (:
N.S. June 14, 2024
You may want to get an oven thermometer and check your oven temperature. I noticed my oven was off by 25 degrees so I've been having to change the temp. setting. It really made a difference with the browning and cook time.
Little P. June 23, 2024
Thanks! I realized mine is also 25 degrees off, but higher in heat rather than lower. I have to set oven at 325 if I want 350. oy.
Little P. June 1, 2024
Very yummy!! I would reduce the sweetener next time, but, this is a keeper for sure.
NYCtoCAtransplant April 23, 2024
I have been making this recipe on repeat for over a year now - it’s super forgiving on proportions (i often use less syrup or brown sugar and swap out all kinds of nuts). My extended family keep asking me to make more and my kids devour it, as do I. Such a delicious recipe.
Debra G. March 28, 2024
I have been making this granola for years. I 2X the recipe so we have enough for a few months
C.Nielsen March 28, 2024
Probably use this more than any other recipe on this site!
Irene S. March 22, 2024
I was inspired to play with the ingredients a bit. I used a lemon olive oil from Sciabica's, and for the nuts, a very generous amount of raw macadamai nuts that I kept saving in my freezer from a trip to Hawaii for a worthy project - toasted before mixing, and raw sunflower seeds+raw sliced almonds. I also used unsweetened, shredded coconut. after the end of the baking, I added 1 cup mixed dry tart cherries and red currants. scrummy delicious results and helped reset my Aloha spirit (I seem to always appreciate the local granola from Anahola Granola when on island but this can make up for it at home).
Tamar K. November 8, 2023
This is the best granola recipe. I do cut down on the maple syrup and don’t add the sugar, because I prefer my granola a little less sweet. But it is by far the best granola - no need to buy any once you use this recipe.
Cheryl August 31, 2023
I'm never buying granola again. This is so good. Sometimes I've added chopped dates to this and sometimes dried cranberries or cherries to it. All good. I've given this as gifts to people and when I do, everyone wants the recipe. Thanks Food 52!