This is the best thing I’ve ever eaten. It’s also the least healthy thing I’ve ever eaten. First, I made an intense smoked paprika mayo. Next, I cooked my bacon until perfectly crispy on a grill pan so as not to lose that flavorful grease. No paper towel in the micro routine. And here’s the kicker, the step that probably cost me a year of my life. I grilled the bread in the leftover bacon grease. Slathered the mayo on top of the grilled bread, layered on the bacon, topped with arugula and the cherry tomatoes, and showered the whole thing with smoked Maldon salt and freshly ground pepper.
My husband’s take: “I could eat seven of these and keel over and die with a smile on my face.” —Feed Me Dearly
For the mayo:
freshly-squeezed lemon juice (from half a lemon)
small garlic clove, minced, preferably with a microplane
For the sandwich:
slices thick cut smoked bacon (about 1 lb)
large, thick slices of chewy country bread such as sourdough or ciabatta
Stir the mayo ingredients together in a small bowl. Set aside.
In another bowl, toss the halved tomatoes in a bowl with the olive oil and a squeeze of lemon from the remaining lemon half.
Preheat a large grill pan to medium heat (or cook bacon as you normally would in a pan or in the oven, making sure to reserve the bacon grease).
When pan is hot, cook the bacon until crispy, turning frequently, about 6 minutes. When bacon is done, remove to plate lined with paper towels.
Place bread in grill pan (or collect the bacon grease from wherever you’ve cooked your bacon and place in a pan on medium heat) and fry the bread gently in the bacon grease for a minute or two on each side. The bread should turn a beautiful golden color.
When bread is done, remove to a plate, smear each slice with some of the smoked paprika mayo.
Top with bacon, layer on a handful of arugula, some of the cherry tomatoes, and season the whole thing to taste with the smoked salt and pepper.