Make Ahead
Charred Broccoli and Lentil Salad
Popular on Food52
47 Reviews
Andi C.
September 26, 2021
I've made this numerous times and love it. I add diced onions, chopped pecans and dried cranberries to the salad. For the dressing, include a chopped chiptle, in adobo, pepper with the seeds removed and smoked paprika. This is so versatile.
Andi C.
September 26, 2021
Oops! Those ingredients are in the recipe. I mistakenly thought that I had added them. So sorry! This may be my last review ever.
Jestei
February 8, 2021
This is delicious. Did not have a bell pepper oh well I hate them. Used date syrup instead of PM because it was open. Recommend salt and pepper to finish. I added a 7 minute egg for each bowl. HUGE HIT WE LOVE.
EmilyC
February 9, 2021
Yes to a 7 minute egg on top! So glad you tried and liked this, Jestei. Thanks for your note!
Jestei
February 8, 2021
This is delicious. Did not have a bell pepper oh well I hate them. Used date syrup instead of PM because it was open. Recommend salt and pepper to finish. I added a 7 minute egg for each bowl. HUGE HIT WE LOVE
Kathy H.
July 17, 2020
My family raved about the salad. I kept the components separate, so everyone can customize their salad. We had it room temp. Will try it warm next time. Very different and filling. Thanks !
Melissa Y.
October 1, 2019
As other reviewers have mentioned, do yourself a favor and make double the sauce. This might be the best new recipe I've made all year. It keeps forever (not that it will last) and I never tired of eating it. Plus, reheated over greens with a fried egg on top -- best reheated lunch ever!
EmilyC
October 1, 2019
Oh your comment just made my day, melissa! Thank you so much for trying this and your nice note.
riverkitchen
August 5, 2017
Oh, deep, sincere apologies--actually this recipe was NOT in the cookbook I mentioned but in Food52's equally great cookbook of salads. It is truly wonderful and correctly attributed!
riverkitchen
August 5, 2017
I love this recipe, have made it, but am completely confused about whose it was originally. This week I found it, almost ingredient for ingredient and word for word, in a great new cookbook, Simple, by the British writer Diane Henry. As a writer and editor myself, I wish that recipes were given more precise attribution.
kaleandsalt
May 6, 2016
The dressing for this salad is absolutely wonderful. It came together really quickly and was a really delicious change from my vinaigrette rut - smoky, rich, and slightly sweet. I also appreciated the technique of mixing shredded carrots into the lentils, I'll definitely be doing that in the future to sneak a bit more veggies into my lentil salads. That said, I thought the combination of ingredients in this salad was just a little bit off and didn't really like it as a whole. The broccoli overpowered the other ingredients, and it all turned into a brown mush that felt very heavy for such a healthy dish. I think I might stick to my vinaigrette-based lentil salad (but keep the carrots!) and just serve the delicious, crispy broccoli on the side.
Transcendancing
October 6, 2015
Wow, this is my new favourite salad! I plan to eat it all summer long (I'm in Australia and our weather is just heating up). Such gorgeous flavours and worth the effort in the dressing definitely.
EmilyC
October 6, 2015
Thank you for your nice note! So glad you like the salad. This dressing is one of my favorites, so I'm glad you found it worth the effort!
Food O.
May 24, 2015
Substitute for tahini? Can you recommend another type of dressing?
EmilyC
May 25, 2015
I recently made the dressing with a 1/4 cup of toasted almonds that I blitzed in the food processor (in place of the tahini), and it was delicious. If you go this direction, start with a lesser amount of water and add more to get the right consistency.
Melirose
February 12, 2015
I adore this recipe! Great main course. My normally meat loving 14 yo daughter can usually only be coaxed to have a vegetarian meal if its pasta or tofu, so it's great to have her eat lentils now. About to make for second time. I used prepared Tahini sauce from Trader Joes instead of pure tahini (only way I didn't have to buy a huge container). It is just Tahini, lemon, water, garlic salt, so I just adjusted quality of your sauce ingredients to taste and it worked fine. LOVE IT.
gingerroot
December 29, 2014
Hi Emily! I made this for Christmas brunch and our gathering of family and friends loved it. This is going into my regular rotation. Thank you for such a fabulous recipe! Hope you and your family had a wonderful Christmas holiday. Wishing you all the best in 2015!
EmilyC
December 29, 2014
Thanks so much Jenny! I'm so happy that this salad made it onto your holiday table! Wishing you and yours all the best in the New Year as well! xoxo
luvcookbooks
October 26, 2014
Made this for dinner tonight, and it's up there with Arielleclementine's Roasted Broccoli https://food52.com/recipes/2625-roasted-broccoli-with-smoked-paprika-vinaigrette-and-marcona-almonds I have never seen broiled broccoli in a recipe before and the little broccoli cross sections were delicious and very pretty. I predict this will be a future Genius Recipe- thank you for sharing it!
EmilyC
October 27, 2014
Meg -- I'm flattered that you like this so much and put it in the same category as arielleclementine's roasted broccoli, one of my all-time favorites! The broiling technique really does work well (and so much quicker than roasting). Thanks so much for trying this and circling back!
cookinginvictoria
October 9, 2014
Yay, Emily -- congrats on being selected as a finalist!! I was fortunate enough to test this recipe and we all loved it. In fact, I have made it twice since you posted it. As I told the editors, this is "an inventive, wildly delicious salad that somehow feels both original and new . . . It is one of the most delicious recipes that I have ever made from food52, and I have made quite a few!" So glad that this recipe is getting some food52 love. :)
AntoniaJames
October 9, 2014
cookinginvictoria, do you have an ideas on what substitutions could be made for the peppers and paprika in the sauce? I realize that it's hard to get the smoky taste without the smoked paprika or a smoked chile or other pepper, but I cannot eat either of them . . . . ;o)
cookinginvictoria
October 9, 2014
Hi AJ, that is a tough one because the smokiness is so much a part of the flavor of this dish. I am wondering if maybe a sprinkling of smoked salt on the plated salad or even adding a small amount of ground looseleaf Lapsang Souchong tea to the dressing might deliver some smokiness if one were unable to use peppers or paprika. EmilyC, what do you think?
EmilyC
October 9, 2014
Thanks, cookinginvictoria, for your lovely feedback on my salad! Really means a lot coming from you. Thanks so much for taking the time to test it!
EmilyC
October 9, 2014
Funny you ask about substitutions, because I debated back and forth between this dressing, with its spicy, smoky character, and a lemon tahini one. I like cookinginvictoria's suggestions for trying to replicate the smoky aspect and you could try charred roma tomato (or maybe even sun-dried tomatoes) in place of the piquillo. Or -- you could take the salad in a completely different direction with a lemony dressing. I'm thinking lemon, tahini, garlic, olive oil, and some freshly ground cumin and/or coriander would be nice. Please let us know what you try!
AntoniaJames
October 9, 2014
These are great ideas. I've got some really smoky charred eggplant in my freezer that I'll blend up with a touch of toasted cumin, and substitute lemon juice for the vinegar. I'll report back, soon. (I just *happen* to have a pint of French green lentils, cooked with bay leaves and garlic, waiting in the fridge for the right opportunity, which this quite obviously is.) Stay tuned. ;o)
See what other Food52ers are saying.