Hanukkah
Brisket with Saba, Apricots, and Figs
Popular on Food52
4 Reviews
Alexandra H.
April 9, 2023
I am certainly not a newbie at making brisket, nor at cooking in general, and was a bit concerned about cooking the meat for 3 hours, uncovered, but I thought "what do I know?!" and followed the steps to the letter. The smell in my kitchen was divine (I even special ordered a bottle of Saba and was so happy I did) but what resulted was a beautifully flavored piece of shoe leather. Truly it was nearly inedible - thank goodness for sharp steak knives, plenty of other dishes to fill up on, and forgiving relatives. Perhaps there is something that I was supposed to do differently, e.g. perhaps "large roasting pan" really should have read "a large roasting pan but not one so large that the liquid doesn't at least very nearly cover the meat"...? But I am finding that this is the issue with Food52 recipes in general: there is not enough direction to assist the home cook with avoiding some of the potential pitfalls of the process, nor answers to the myriad questions that inevitably come up while cooking that one must simply guess the answers to (sometimes with disastrous consequences), e.g. how would one know more broth was needed during the cooking process? At what level would I have needed to see it reduced to to need to add more (or not add it)?? - I added it anyway, more liquid is not bed when cooking such cuts of meat, OR when you marinade the meat: should the veggies be under the meat? surrounding it? What about the onions herbs and orange peel? If I chose to add the onions on top, is it okay that they are soaked in Saba or do you really just want to coat the meat in Saba? Does it matter? To me, a solid recipe contains such answers, notes, and tips (I simply don't have the time - as most home cooks don't these days I think- to test recipes in my own kitchen again and again until I can produce the same perfect result as what I assume the writer of said recipe expects you to produce) and the lack of which is the reason I will be steering clear of Food52 recipes in general - this is not the first time I have been burned. If you want an absolutely fool proof method for making brisket - head over to Smitten Kitchen (I have no affiliation with the site or author, FYI) - it's perfect, every time.
Tasha
December 20, 2017
I just happened to re-read the recipe and see that it's been re-ordered to describe searing the meat before adding the marinade to the pan. Thanks for the update!
Tasha
December 13, 2017
Thanks for this intriguing recipe. I'd like to try it out, but have a question about the searing step. My understanding of searing is that it's usually done in an only slightly moist environment (typically with oil). In this case, you're adding two cups of red wine first, and the veggies appear to stay put in the pot as well. Is the wine supposed to reduce to the point where the meat and veggies actually sear? Or, is everything braising in the wine? Sorry for my confusion. I have just enough cooking experience to be dangerous. Any clarification appreciated!
See what other Food52ers are saying.