No-Cook
Nancy's Chopped Salad
Popular on Food52
28 Reviews
Wilsedw
October 11, 2023
I’d second the suggestion in another comment to use Smitten Kitchen’s dressing recipe.
Ignore the comment about the salad taking over two hours to make. I’m not sure how on earth a simple recipe like this could take that long, but I put the whole thing together in less than half an hour, and that’s with splitting my time between making appetizers.
Another comment mentioned the salad got very soggy. To avoid that, be sure you drain EVERY ingredient well and blot them dry with a paper towel. Do not use a salad spinner, and don’t let them drip dry. I also keep the lettuces separate from the other add-ins and dressing until I’m ready to serve it. As this recipe does make a huge amount, doing it this way ensures it stays fresh and crisp enough to enjoy as leftovers for the next day or two.
Follow the above tips and you’ll have people asking you for the recipe each time you serve this salad.
Ignore the comment about the salad taking over two hours to make. I’m not sure how on earth a simple recipe like this could take that long, but I put the whole thing together in less than half an hour, and that’s with splitting my time between making appetizers.
Another comment mentioned the salad got very soggy. To avoid that, be sure you drain EVERY ingredient well and blot them dry with a paper towel. Do not use a salad spinner, and don’t let them drip dry. I also keep the lettuces separate from the other add-ins and dressing until I’m ready to serve it. As this recipe does make a huge amount, doing it this way ensures it stays fresh and crisp enough to enjoy as leftovers for the next day or two.
Follow the above tips and you’ll have people asking you for the recipe each time you serve this salad.
Kelly4yr
July 11, 2023
I know this salad is the darling of the internet but I want to speak some truths about it to save people the agony. The recipe states that it takes about 30 minutes to prepare. I'm a seasoned cook and between the dressing and the salad, it took me over two hours to make! Another issue is the waste involved. The recipe for some reason has you waste 1.5 cups of olive oil (that's a lot of expensive oil!) only to have you use 8 TB of the dressing on the salad. The recipe then states about the dressing that you end up with: "The yield is a generous 1 1/2 cups; you'll use up to 1/2 cup for this salad, and the remainder can be refrigerated for another use (up to 3 days)." Why not just reduce the amounts to make a moderate amount of dressing? Such a waste! And what else are you going to use all of that dressing on within three days? You're not going to make another salad to use it with because this recipe makes enough salad for a small army! The salad was also overly bitter to me with all of the radicchio. I'd never make this one again.
Shirley
August 12, 2023
Thanks Kelly for your input. We cannot afford to waste food. Seems a proof reader would be helpful before recipes are printed. I think Nancy would agree.
OrangeTang
August 2, 2022
Ewww! How can you in good conscience promote a racist???
Her racist tropes of African Americans and Asians (by her own words in the LA Times) should cause you to pause before supporting her. Additionally, her cooking is just plain mediocre (yes, I’ve had her cooking). Just one more reason to avoid your business.
Her racist tropes of African Americans and Asians (by her own words in the LA Times) should cause you to pause before supporting her. Additionally, her cooking is just plain mediocre (yes, I’ve had her cooking). Just one more reason to avoid your business.
EllieinArecibo
September 27, 2021
I absolutely love the flavors of this salad--it's like an Italian hoagie in a salad!--but this recipe surely has a significant error in it. There's no way that one should be using 1.5 cups of olive oil for only 3.5 T (or 4.5, if you count the juice that can be added separately) of acid. When I read the recipe through I thought, I'll start with one cup and see how it tastes. But even with that ratio, I was very regretful that I didn't start with only 1/2 cup of oil and add from there if needed. Even one cup of oil completely drowns out any other flavor in the dressing. I used it anyway because I had guests arriving and was too busy cooking the main course to redo it, but I really think this has to be an error!
Also, I'll note that I tried to make this about an hour and a half ahead of time and it was so soggy, which even further diluted what should've been a salad with nice, punchy flavors throughout. I combined the lettuces, tomatoes (drained, no less), and onion ahead of time and that mixture alone was so soggy within about 5 minutes of tossing them together. I don't have anything against iceberg overall but would recommend something hardier for this instead--maybe romaine or even finely chopped and massaged kale. Sadly, this salad felt like a fair amount of effort with great individual ingredients for a bland and soggy final result. With some tweaks I think it could be amazing.
Also, I'll note that I tried to make this about an hour and a half ahead of time and it was so soggy, which even further diluted what should've been a salad with nice, punchy flavors throughout. I combined the lettuces, tomatoes (drained, no less), and onion ahead of time and that mixture alone was so soggy within about 5 minutes of tossing them together. I don't have anything against iceberg overall but would recommend something hardier for this instead--maybe romaine or even finely chopped and massaged kale. Sadly, this salad felt like a fair amount of effort with great individual ingredients for a bland and soggy final result. With some tweaks I think it could be amazing.
phalagen
April 24, 2022
I agree. The ratio is off. I looked the salad/dressing up on the Smitten Kitchen website and here's what it said:
4 cloves garlic
1 to 2 tablespoons dried oregano (Nancy recommends 2; I got nervous and used 1, but might not have minded more)
2 teaspoons kosher salt
Freshly ground black pepper
2 tablespoons lemon juice, or juice of 1 lemon
1/4 cup red wine vinegar
1/4 cup olive oil, ideally extra-virgin
4 cloves garlic
1 to 2 tablespoons dried oregano (Nancy recommends 2; I got nervous and used 1, but might not have minded more)
2 teaspoons kosher salt
Freshly ground black pepper
2 tablespoons lemon juice, or juice of 1 lemon
1/4 cup red wine vinegar
1/4 cup olive oil, ideally extra-virgin
Cie
May 4, 2023
The recipe only calls for you to use 1/2 cup of the vinaigrette and to reserve the rest for another time.
EllieinArecibo
May 4, 2023
I'm not sure you read these comments carefully--the issue is not with the total amount of vinaigrette that one puts on the salad, it is with the RATIO of oil/vinegar that the original recipe calls for, which appears to be significantly off. Phalagen's comment seems to have a recipe with an O/V ratio that would yield a much better result.
Separately, my comment was noting that the choice of lettuce specified in the recipe--iceberg--can result in a soggy salad unless you eat the salad immediately after you put it together.
Separately, my comment was noting that the choice of lettuce specified in the recipe--iceberg--can result in a soggy salad unless you eat the salad immediately after you put it together.
TiredCook
June 29, 2024
The recipe here exactly matches the oregano vinaigrette recipe in the Mozza cookbook. I suspect there may be a misprint in the cookbook because it says it "makes a little over 1 cup."
However, I also think Nancy meant for the dressing to be oil-heavy; with a standard vinaigrette I expect it to keep more than three days. The Smitten Kitchen one is too acidic for me. I tried topping the other ingredients up to 3/4 - 1 cup with the oil and it was fine.
However, I also think Nancy meant for the dressing to be oil-heavy; with a standard vinaigrette I expect it to keep more than three days. The Smitten Kitchen one is too acidic for me. I tried topping the other ingredients up to 3/4 - 1 cup with the oil and it was fine.
Debra F.
March 18, 2021
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.thedailymeal.com/recipes/forge-chopped-salad-recipe%3famp
I will try it if you can pry me away from this one. But I will try this one and I will share the one I have. I hope that’s OK
I will try it if you can pry me away from this one. But I will try this one and I will share the one I have. I hope that’s OK
Hmoshman
January 8, 2021
I did not find soaking the finely sliced onion in ice water to be enough to reduce the pungent taste. I prefer to macerate in vinegar--much better. Then add that vinegar instead of the lemon juice. Omitted chickpeas. Used red cabbage instead of radicchio. Good. Will make again.
Karla S.
October 29, 2020
Love this! I have always called it my Big Italian Salad. Never thought to add ChiChi beans! YUM
Regine
October 22, 2020
Did anyone try to veganize this?
Melanie M.
October 30, 2021
I have. I add vegan seitan pepperoni and buffalo mozzarella I make homemade. Heaven!
Judi
December 31, 2019
This isn't for me. I dislike both radicchio and iceberg lettuce but went ahead and made it anyway. Husband liked it. I didn't care for it at all and thought it was a lot of effort.
Angelag83
November 3, 2019
Absolutely wonderful! I waited till I had a crowd large enough to polish it off...it’s a lot of salad. Rustic and perfect EXACTLY like per the recipe. I would not change a single thing. Thank you!
Stacey
November 1, 2019
I made this last night for a large group (doubled the recipe) and it was the hit of the party! We ended up with fewer guests so I had a full bowl extra and can't tell you how happy I am to have extra! Everything about this works - the flavors are the perfect match for each other - nothing stands out in particular (which is a good thing in my opinion) but it all works together beautifully.
Grant M.
October 26, 2019
I'm absolutely obsessed with this salad. Changing anything about would be blasphemous. IT'S PERFECT. Do yourself a favor and make this salad tonight. You'll be so glad you did.
See what other Food52ers are saying.