On Black & Highly Flavored, co-hosts Derek Kirk and Tamara Celeste shine a light on the need-to-know movers and shakers of our food & beverage industry.
Listen NowPopular on Food52
7 Comments
dgk
August 20, 2016
@Lisa, it's not the writing that's the problem -- it's your interpretation. What is wrong with a dim sum restaurant full of happy Chinese people talking loudly? That's the restaurant I want to go to -- and have gone to repeatedly -- as someone who's Chinese. And I'm also not presumptuous enough to suggest that Chinese people are the only ones who can speak knowledgeably about dim sum.
Fred R.
August 17, 2016
That was one of the great things about passing through Hong Kong (or any foreign city/local food scene for that matter) for many, many years...all the big dim sum joints were filled with happy, loud, smiling Chinese. Just enjoy and don't overthink the experience.
Lisa
August 16, 2016
"Go to places that are filled with loud tables full of happy Chinese people."? Really? Would you ever say "Go to a Mexican restaurant filled with loud happy Mexican people."??? Please consider the way your writing comes off next time around. Why are you not promoting dim sum books written by actual Chinese Americans who grew up with dim sum? Seems like they would be a lot more knowledgeable and authentic about the culture.
Ali W.
August 16, 2016
As a Mexican, I have to say that yeah, for sure I would walk into a Mexican restaurant only if it's full of Mexicans, and the happier and louder they are, the better! If I saw a Mexican joint with only a couple of tables occupied by anyone who isn't Mexican, I'm pretty sure the food is not authentic Mexican
TT
August 17, 2016
Hey - that advice is totally legit. Unless you're looking for Americanized / fusion food. Then, by all means, go to the Chinese restaurant without Chinese people in it.
HalfPint
August 17, 2016
@Lisa, I have often advised people to go find a restaurant/food truck that have a lot of loud, happy,[insert any ethnic group]. It's good advice because who else but these native-eaters would know the good from the mediocre. Especially those elderly aunties :)
To your second question, The Dim Sum Field Guide will be released on August 30, 2016. That's why this book and its author are being promoted in this article. From a quick skim of Amazon, the last time a dim sum book from a Chinese American author (if going by the author name) was released was 2014. I'm sure that if there is a dim sum book by a person of Chinese heritage , we would be reading about that book. I thought this article was fun (it's pretty spot on) and will be informative for those new to dim sum. Authenticity and knowledge are not necessarily genetic. I know plenty of Asian Americans who don't know food beyond pasta, pizza, and burgers. Just because Carolyn Phillips is white does not negate her knowledge of dim sum. I mean, the woman speaks Mandarin well enough to be an interpreter in Federal and State court!
To your second question, The Dim Sum Field Guide will be released on August 30, 2016. That's why this book and its author are being promoted in this article. From a quick skim of Amazon, the last time a dim sum book from a Chinese American author (if going by the author name) was released was 2014. I'm sure that if there is a dim sum book by a person of Chinese heritage , we would be reading about that book. I thought this article was fun (it's pretty spot on) and will be informative for those new to dim sum. Authenticity and knowledge are not necessarily genetic. I know plenty of Asian Americans who don't know food beyond pasta, pizza, and burgers. Just because Carolyn Phillips is white does not negate her knowledge of dim sum. I mean, the woman speaks Mandarin well enough to be an interpreter in Federal and State court!
See what other Food52 readers are saying.