Your Caprese Is 2 Ingredients Away from Being the King of Them All

August 22, 2016

A week after every new employee starts at Food52, they answer a series of ice-breaking questions at our company meeting, including "What food did you used to not like that you have learned to enjoy?" 

While the question game was not in place when I started many moons ago, (44 moons ago to be exact), if I were to answer it, I'd have to say mayonnaise. 

No mayo here. Photo by Linda Xiao

I hated mayonnaise growing up. H.A.T.E.D. If I'd see a babysitter putting it in a casserole, I'd refuse to eat when it arrived on my plate hours later. Sandwich breads had to be spread with mustard to not be rejected. Coleslaw? No way. 

Shop the Story

In my third decade, I can finally say my dislike has waned. I love a good tuna melt or mayo-coated grilled cheese. I am mayo sandwich-friendly, in all cases but one: the lobster roll.

Lobster is so sweet and tender—I'll never understand hiding it behind mayo and cold temperatures. I'll take a Connecticut style lobster roll over New England's "dragged through the garden" roll (who needs herbs?) or a Maine lobster roll any day. The warm, butter laden, mayo-free lobster roll is perfect to me.

And it was this type of roll, plus Amanda Hesser's Brown Butter Tomatoes, that got me thinking after I recently ordered the Lobster Caprese Salad at the Inlet restaurant in Montauk, New York: What if I were to combine the brown butter with the cooked lobster, so that when they're both poured over the tomato and mozzarella they all cooked a little? 

I tried it, and loved it. And hope you will too!

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Merrill Stubbs
    Merrill Stubbs
  • Jane Katz
    Jane Katz
  • laurenlocally
Local food lover and VP @ Food52 (my dream job!)


Merrill S. August 22, 2016
So, mozzarella and lobster together, eh?
laurenlocally August 22, 2016
Jane K. August 22, 2016