Popular on Food52
33 Comments
Lisa
September 17, 2018
I don't even understand Oklahoma. Hamburger meat!? That's not even a recipe. UGH. We eat well here, I promise.
Kathleen D.
July 13, 2018
Would have been appreciated if a recipe accompanied each state's dish . . those that are dishes. I'm from Michigan, love Goulash and have yet to find a decent recipe. Just saying . . .
Medora V.
July 13, 2018
I would have thought that everyone in Maine already knew how to make apple pie ;)
Smaug
July 13, 2018
One of the many flaws with this "study"- if a dish is actually a local favorite, people will have their own recipes, or family recipes, or recipes from a friend. Recipes from popular local restaurants- authentic or not- will circulate. Newspapers and bloggers will print numerous recipes, particularly if it's something seasonal. All in all, people will have far better recipe sources than Google.
Janet K.
July 13, 2018
At least it lists the District of Columbia. I just saw a list of the best hotels in the 50 states on the CN Traveler web site and DC was not listed. But why make crab cakes when they are so ubiquitous in DC?
Joel S.
July 13, 2018
Doesn’t this list become kind of self-fulfilling? I know once I saw it, I googled chicken adobo, even though I really had no interest in making it. (I am gonna try it though, after having seen the recipes. It looks simple and delicious!)
W B.
July 12, 2018
This is surely a joke.... NC with snowcream, really? From the east to the west, barbecue rules. This peron or person who made this list must have been made it after a couple of snorts of some of NC's white lightnin'!!
Scomfort
July 12, 2018
What? It very rarely snows in most of NC and then only a few inches. I am seriously confused by this. Where is BBQ?
Joel S.
July 13, 2018
I would imagine that folks in NC already KNOW how to barbecue. No need to google it!
Aisha
July 13, 2018
I live in NC and snow cream makes perfect sense for the past year. It rarely snows but when it does and actually sticks and pikes up excitement ensues because who knows when it will return. Many local friends posted about snow cream. I even shared my pina colada snow cream recipe. Though my family is from the New England area so the snow out here is nothing in comparison.
Eric S.
July 12, 2018
As someone who lived in Alaska, and enjoyed a halibut charter now and again, I am not surprised by the result.
Liz P.
July 12, 2018
Dear Food52,
You note, in your write up, that Idaho searched for zucchini bread. Alas, when i looked below and the research results, I found that you confused us with Utah, that is the state to the south of Idaho. In Idaho we were searching for crepes. Crepes Suzette is often served after we churn the butter from our cows, chop the firewood and work from dawn to dusk in our fields. Bon appetite !
You note, in your write up, that Idaho searched for zucchini bread. Alas, when i looked below and the research results, I found that you confused us with Utah, that is the state to the south of Idaho. In Idaho we were searching for crepes. Crepes Suzette is often served after we churn the butter from our cows, chop the firewood and work from dawn to dusk in our fields. Bon appetite !
Eric K.
July 13, 2018
Those crepes sound delicious and well-earned! And thank you, Liz, for catching zucchini bread; this has been fixed.
Traveler
July 12, 2018
Were we supposed to be able to click on/access the recipes? If so, it didn't work for me and I used two different browsers to access the site. The title is "The Most Popular Recipe in Every State, According to Google."
Traveler
July 12, 2018
Ooops! I just realized we were supposed to look each one of them up on Google. Hard to do since the map is so small and it is hard to access the smaller states.
Smaug
July 12, 2018
I think you were intended to be able to reach "most popular" recipes through this site, but I doubt you're missing much. The methodology is going more towards things people are just curious about- for instance, California is full of people who've been told they must eat quinoa and are wondering what the #%&$ to do with the stuff. Most popular on Google is apt to mean what's at the top of the page; if you search for "cookies" on Google you get 15 million entries, and few people go through them all. This whole article is based on an extremely undependable methodology and a lot of unwarranted conclusions, things that plague so much of the "science" surrounding food.
BerryBaby
July 7, 2018
Valerio’s question at the end is, “How does your favorite dish match up with your states?”
Answering his question , not complaining.
Answering his question , not complaining.
Maximus_Matthias
July 7, 2018
It says most popular recipe...not most popular main dish!!! Stop complaining and red the title correctly.
Smaug
July 7, 2018
Perhaps you red the article so fast that you blue right by all the references to favorite dishes.
BerryBaby
July 6, 2018
Teriyaki sauce? That’s not a dish! I’m in Oregon and I would think crab cakes, halibut, anything with strawberries that are in season. Not a valid accounting IMO.
Ttrockwood
July 8, 2018
My thought is that these are dishes the people searching *need a recipe for* , therefore what is most common people already have a favorite preparation/recipe and are not going to need help for those.
Smaug
July 6, 2018
Perhaps mindlessly counting computer clicks is not the most accurate way of assembling data. In this case, it seems to be more a matter of which dish, or ingredient, has the most people baffled. Quinoa? Pizza Dough? These aren't even dishes.
BerryBaby
July 6, 2018
I agree . Ours (Oregon) was teriyaki sauce. It GOES with something , it’s not a dish.
Smaug
July 6, 2018
I seem to recall reading one of these a while back- something like "favorite Memorial Day dishes in every state"- that came up with chili in New Hampshire and yoghurt dip in New Mexico. People have come to place blind faith in any numbers they're presented with, without bothering to know where they actually came from.
See what other Food52 readers are saying.