Cookbooks
A Palestinian Pomegranate Cake to Celebrate Life
In 'Zaitoun,' Yasmin Khan tells stories from the kitchens of Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza.
Photo by Matt Russell
Popular on Food52
25 Comments
Rosalind P.
December 1, 2019
Could I use oil instead of butter for a non-dairy cake? Don't mind if it would make the cake more dense.
Barak M.
February 17, 2019
Cooking is about getting people together and bringing a feel-good atmosphere to the world. I was therefore quite surprised to see that EK and YK (and Food 52) chose to introduce a controversial politics into this otherwise a great piece. YK is talking about "your ability to access [Tel Aviv] is dependent on your ethnicity" and EK is responding by "It's cruel and inhumane". Not only are they both ignorants on the subject, or worth - purposefully dissing Israel, the whole paragraph has no place in food writing and in fact, managed to hurt the feelings of many Jews and Israelis who read those words. I'd really appreciate hearing from Food52 that A) they regret introducing controversial politics into their writings and will do more to avoid it inn the future and B) they Food52 will ask EK to write a few words of apology to those whose feelings might have been truly hurt by seeing their country being described as "cruel and inhumane" in such a biased fashion and C) I'd like to see Food52 banning YK from their site for spreading fake news and hare instead of great cooking and love. This was not a mistake that she made. She knows it and everyone who knows her, knows it. The way to keep Food52 a happy place is to stay away from politics. Editorial failed this time.
Eric K.
February 17, 2019
Hi Barak, thanks for voicing your concern. Though I disagree with your stance that food and politics don’t belong together (for me, they’re intertwined), I have trimmed the section to address the bias you and Valerie have voiced. That’s certainly not something I intended. With that said, I stand by Yasmin’s personal experiences, which she has every right to share.
Diane
February 17, 2019
When someone says politics is not part of (name the topic), you will in fact find the politics in silencing the voice and diminishing the experience of another. Barak and Valerie were allowed to voice their “politics” and denying the experiences and empathy of others. To demand silence is an attempt to exercise power, a political act, by the threat of withdrawing support and the attempt to condemn the author and subject.
I applaud you EK for your thoughtful piece. I am new to Food 52 and you have earned a follower for honest and insightful reporting. Readers are open to agree, disagree, or consider...that is a happy place...to be treated intelligently.
I applaud you EK for your thoughtful piece. I am new to Food 52 and you have earned a follower for honest and insightful reporting. Readers are open to agree, disagree, or consider...that is a happy place...to be treated intelligently.
Mariuccia
February 17, 2019
I am so uncomfortable that loud voices insist on censoring other voices. On a food site, no less. YK gave an account of an experience she had in her own words. She should be allowed to give voice to her own experiences in her own words. She should be allowed to speak freely even though there are those that disagree with her.
Mike S.
February 18, 2019
I am thrilled to see Yasmin Khan featured here on Food52. Her Palestinian recipes are some of the best we have ever seen, and to try to silence her or erase her would be a horribly shameful act. Erasing Palestinian voices is a crime. Erasing Palestinian recipes is a crime. And for Barak to come on here to slander her and try to wipe her experience and narrative from this website should be enough to prove to everyone else that we must all play a part in making sure that Yasmin is heard. As a Jew, I am ashamed and saddened by Barak's comments; and as a Jew, I will do whatever I can to make sure that people like him do not silence or erase Palestinian voices.
Barak M.
February 18, 2019
Eric
Thanks for taking out the shameful inaccuracies that were hurtful and unjust. Yasmin has every right to her feelings but it’s just that - her feelings, uncorraborated and possibly biased. I am sure no one comes to Food52 to be thrown into the Middle East conflict. We come here to read about food and get some rest from fake news and hateful politics. So thanks again.
Thanks for taking out the shameful inaccuracies that were hurtful and unjust. Yasmin has every right to her feelings but it’s just that - her feelings, uncorraborated and possibly biased. I am sure no one comes to Food52 to be thrown into the Middle East conflict. We come here to read about food and get some rest from fake news and hateful politics. So thanks again.
Barak M.
February 18, 2019
Indeed. And same rights to express my feelings should be given to me no doubt. Do you agree, Mariuccia? In my opinion it’s best to check controversial politics at the gate and only enjoy good food and nice people here. It is as you say a food site after all.
Mariuccia
February 21, 2019
Sorry Barak, I am not steeped in the Israeli politics. What I see made me uncomfortable is you asking to censor Yasmin Khan's words. I am fine with you expressing your feelings, educating people about your point of view and why you think that Yasmin's words are not accurate, adding what her words leave out. 100% fine with that. I am not fine or comfortable with having
her words be eliminated.
her words be eliminated.
Jt
April 9, 2019
I am ever so weary of Israel trying to squash criticism of its actions, in every venue everywhere. Ad nauseum. There was nothing in this piece that needed an apology. Access to anything in Israel is dependent on whether or not you are Palestinian, and everyone who's ever been there knows that.
valerie J.
February 17, 2019
I have subscribed to Food 52 since 2012, so I am shocked to encounter biased political comments on this website.
The implication that the author of the cookbook discussed in this article was refused entry to Tel Aviv because of her colour is disgusting and only serves to illustrate the ignorance of Eric Kim in believing this. Half of Tel Aviv is coloured. Why does the article not explain the real reason this lady was detained at the airport there? With a Palestinian father and an Iranian mother, and having spent much of her life in lengthy visits to Iran, together with a constant anti-Israeli stance throughout her writings – facts not mentioned in the article – Israel has no choice but to see her as a possible security risk. Many Food 52 readers are totally unaware of the situation over there. Iran threatens to destroy Israel every other day and now has troops on its northern border. So of course security with regard to anything Iranian, particularly someone known for her anti-Israel views, is going to be very tight as this lady well knows. She is fortunate they let her into the country at all. With such views about the country she wanted to enter as hers, no other Middle Eastern country would have let her in and she would not have dared to even try. The prisons in the West Bank and Gaza are full of political dissidents, put there by the Palestinian Authority.
Why is Food 52 mentioning Israel adversely in an article about Palestinian food? Why is it mentioning Israel at all? Middle East politics are complicated by any standards and no food site should be going anywhere near them. For example, the title of this article, stressing Palestinians celebration of life, could also be called political given that the Palestinians, both in the West Bank and Gaza, are encouraging children from an early age to be martyrs, both in childrens’ television programmes and by actively training them. The leaders brag about the fact that their culture celebrates death while the Israeli culture celebrates life and say that that is how they will defeat the Israelis. This has been said by them many times as anyone living in the Middle East knows. Other Arab countries deplore what they call this ‘death cult’ and I’m very sure many Palestinians do themselves, and without the politics, the idea of making a Palestinian cake that celebrates life was lovely. But shame on Food 52 for bringing in biased political comments as it did.
I have been subscribing to Food 52 since 2011 but if there is no apology forthcoming for the bias in this piece, I shall unsubscribe, and I will not be the only one.
The implication that the author of the cookbook discussed in this article was refused entry to Tel Aviv because of her colour is disgusting and only serves to illustrate the ignorance of Eric Kim in believing this. Half of Tel Aviv is coloured. Why does the article not explain the real reason this lady was detained at the airport there? With a Palestinian father and an Iranian mother, and having spent much of her life in lengthy visits to Iran, together with a constant anti-Israeli stance throughout her writings – facts not mentioned in the article – Israel has no choice but to see her as a possible security risk. Many Food 52 readers are totally unaware of the situation over there. Iran threatens to destroy Israel every other day and now has troops on its northern border. So of course security with regard to anything Iranian, particularly someone known for her anti-Israel views, is going to be very tight as this lady well knows. She is fortunate they let her into the country at all. With such views about the country she wanted to enter as hers, no other Middle Eastern country would have let her in and she would not have dared to even try. The prisons in the West Bank and Gaza are full of political dissidents, put there by the Palestinian Authority.
Why is Food 52 mentioning Israel adversely in an article about Palestinian food? Why is it mentioning Israel at all? Middle East politics are complicated by any standards and no food site should be going anywhere near them. For example, the title of this article, stressing Palestinians celebration of life, could also be called political given that the Palestinians, both in the West Bank and Gaza, are encouraging children from an early age to be martyrs, both in childrens’ television programmes and by actively training them. The leaders brag about the fact that their culture celebrates death while the Israeli culture celebrates life and say that that is how they will defeat the Israelis. This has been said by them many times as anyone living in the Middle East knows. Other Arab countries deplore what they call this ‘death cult’ and I’m very sure many Palestinians do themselves, and without the politics, the idea of making a Palestinian cake that celebrates life was lovely. But shame on Food 52 for bringing in biased political comments as it did.
I have been subscribing to Food 52 since 2011 but if there is no apology forthcoming for the bias in this piece, I shall unsubscribe, and I will not be the only one.
Mariuccia
February 17, 2019
sorry, I did't mean to hit helpful, and couldn't undo it. I enjoyed the article as written and don't understand the umbrage expressed here or in the other comment above, so certainly didn't want to endorse it as it is not my view.
Snow
February 16, 2019
I just realized why I'm disappointed by author interviews-it's nothing new.
THIS is the interview I've expected but never found. I have a sense of the PERSON, the passion that drove the spark of an idea into something tangible and I'm left wanting to know more-about Yazmin through her writing, about Palestinian food and culture.
I feel like my world just got a little bigger. Thanks so much!
THIS is the interview I've expected but never found. I have a sense of the PERSON, the passion that drove the spark of an idea into something tangible and I'm left wanting to know more-about Yazmin through her writing, about Palestinian food and culture.
I feel like my world just got a little bigger. Thanks so much!
paseo
February 17, 2019
As a Jew I really appreciated this interview and am tired of conflating dislike of what goes on in Israel these days with anti Semitism. One can be critical of Israel (like me) and NOT an anti Semite. I also have her book, enjoy it immensely, and appreciate it even more after reading. Thanks Eric K..
Barak M.
February 18, 2019
I looked carefully and did not find any reference to antisemitism. I found reference to people’s feeling hurt when their country is called Inhumane by a food blogger or references to leaving controversial politics out of an otherwise delightful food blog. Can you point me to the bit that got you upset?
Molli D.
February 16, 2019
Where was this recipe last fall when I harvested, and shared, the bounty from our fourteen pomegranate trees? I spent days lugging them to friends, making juice, making jelly and now I can try a fantastic sounding cake. And best of all thank you Yasmin for sharing your story!
Joan S.
February 15, 2019
I enjoy learning about foods from different and far away places. One never hears about Palestinian food.
Barak M.
February 15, 2019
Great interview, amazing cake. I’m fascinated by the serving platter. Is there a chance to find out how/where to buy one?
Thanks
Thanks
Jennifer
February 15, 2019
I have been reading Food52 for years. This is my favorite piece, ever. It reminds me of the good food I have eaten in Jerusalem and Ramallah and Bethlehem, in Nazareth and Jericho and Hebron, and about the friends with whom I have broken bread in those places. Thank you for this...
See what other Food52 readers are saying.