Wine

The Chardonnay That Will Convince Chardonnay Haters

A crisp glass of white wine sans buttery, oaky notes? Sign me up.

January 13, 2022
Photo by Rocky Luten

I can’t remember the first time I tried Chardonnay, which I’m sure is due, in part, to the fact that it was so bad I blocked the tasting experience from my memory. Chardonnay is one of the white wine varietals that’s pretty ubiquitous. It’s guaranteed to be one of two, maybe three reliable white wines available at a wedding. It’s a variety that, in a sea of intimidating wine lingo on an extensive drinks menu, is familiar and approachable. At a liquor store three blocks from your college campus, you’ll be hard-pressed to find Sancerre or Txakoli (not a problem for the 19-year-old with a fake I.D. that hasn't heard of Txakoli), but you’ll have your pick of Chardonnays under $15.

All of this is to say that Chardonnay and I have taken more than a few walks around the block and we never got along. It was easy for me to write off Chardonnay entirely. That is, until I was introduced to unoaked Chardonnay.

The characteristics that I dislike in a glass of Chardonnay—those buttery, oaky, rich vanilla notes—are polarizing. You either love ’em or you hate ’em. If you’re in the anti-buttery camp allow me to offer you a good time with unoaked Chardonnay.

Unoaked vs. Unoaked Chardonnay

If Chardonnay is the popular sorority girl who everyone knows, unoaked Chardonnay is its artsy sister. But what’s the difference between them? Oaked Chardonnay is aged in oak barrels, whereas unoaked Chardonnay is aged in neutral oak barrels or stainless-steel tanks; the type of vessels affects the final flavor. Neutral oak barrels have generally been used three to four times previously, which means the most pronounced oaky flavor is absent, allowing for a leaner tasting wine. “Chardonnay is such a neutral grape, you can pretty much do anything to it to develop the characteristics that you like to drink,” explains Elise Cordell, brand ambassador for Perrier-Jouet.

What this means is that the type of barrel will ultimately determine what the wine will taste like. “Oaked Chardonnays tend to have rich, buttered popcorn flavors, while unoaked Chardonnays tend to be more fruit-forward with flavors of green apple and citrus,” explains Lexi Jones, director of imports for Argaux & Amlière Imports.

Wine Regions

As a rule of thumb, expect that Chardonnay from the Russian River Valley and Napa Valley in California, and Burgundy in France will be aged in oak barrels. The northern coast of California, including wine-producing cities like Mendocino, as well as the Champagne and Chablis wine regions of France, tend to favor aging chardonnay in neutral oak or unoaked chardonnay. The latter is a clean, neutral palette, which results in a crisper, fruiter wine, sans “oakiness.” “Chablis, in France, is a great example of a region that typically resorts to stainless steel for aging their Chardonnay. Outside of France, Western Australia also tends to produce great value stainless steel Chardonnays,” says Jones.

Shopping for Unoaked Chardonnay

Cordell says that U.S.-based wine producers tend to be more transparent when it comes to labeling. You’re more likely to find a California Chardonnay clearly noted as “unoaked” compared to other regions like France. For example, Joel Gott produces a California chardonnay that is unoaked and the label leaves no room for guessing; the description reads “Our Chardonnay is unoaked with tropical fruit flavors, a round mouthfeel, and crisp minerality on the finish.”

“Learn the language of what it is that you prefer,” says Cordell. Descriptors like vanilla, pineapple, baking spice, and butter are clear indications that the wine is oaked; on the other hand, phrases like crisp, citrus fruit and white flowers are likely used to describe unoaked Chardonnay.

My favorite unoaked Chardonnay is Louis Jadot Macon Villages ($14) from Burgandy—”This fresh, brilliant pale-gold Chardonnay shows delicate varietal aromas with flavors of apple and melon offset by citrus notes and a crisp acidic balance ending in a clean, lively finish." Jones loves the 2019 Domaine De Oliveira Lecestre AC Chablis ($35), which she pairs with Italian Wedding Soup, or the 2019 Vignerons Ardéchois ‘Les Classiques’ Chardonnay ($20) to pair with pad thai

Do you prefer oaked or unoaked chardonnay? What’s your go-to chardonnay? Let us know in the comments below!
Listen Now

On our new weekly podcast, two friends separated by the Atlantic take questions and compare notes on everything from charcuterie trends to scone etiquette.

Listen Now

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Pamela Losey
    Pamela Losey
  • Kay Newby
    Kay Newby
  • AntoniaJames
    AntoniaJames
  • Kelly Vaughan
    Kelly Vaughan

6 Comments

Pamela L. January 28, 2022
Here's an easy way to remove the guesswork and stay away from heavy oak ... Old World vs New World. The new world wines (US and Australia largely) are oaken. Never met a European Chard I didn't like ...
 
Kay N. January 18, 2022
Also, I haven't had a Lioco White Wine in several years but here's one that landed in my inbox this morning. I might be into it. They're calling it, "Rock Juice1"

2019 Estero, Russian River Valley

If you like Chardonnay that smells like crushed up river stones & preserved lemons, that tastes like wild fennel, just-ripe golden apples, & rock salt...we have a wine for you. Estero is "...not your father's Oldsmobile." It a Chardonnay for the Chardonnay-doubters. A wine that calls to mind the restrained California wines of a bygone era...like the wines that went to the famous Paris Tasting of 1976. It resembles in many ways the wines that inspired it--the wines from those famous golden slopes in Burgundy. But it is decidedly, unabashedly Californian. These clusters, while harvested early to preserve natural acidity, reveal their special relationship with our Mediterranean sun. "Ripe acidity" is what we are talking about here. The kind you find a late spring Meyer lemon. The aging in used 500L puncheon barrels did nothing but focus the wine's innate energy. No oakiness, no butter. Just a chiseled, mouthwatering, Russian River white wine.

 
Kay N. January 16, 2022
Hello, Thank you for this article. I spend a lot of time with my customers who claim they are "ABC" wine drinkers (anything but Chardonnay) until I introduce them to the concept of "Unoaked" Chardonnay with a crunchy acidity. -K
 
Kelly V. January 18, 2022
Thanks for introducing more people to the wonderful world of unoaked chardonnay!
 
AntoniaJames January 14, 2022
Louis Jadot is quite reliable - it's been my go-to when a chardonnay is needed in cooking. Louis Jadot has been in US supermarkets for many decades.

For something a little brighter, we like Husch chardonnay, which we first heard about when my mother-in-law toured CA vineyards north of Santa Rosa back in the 80's. Husch's vines are in the Anderson Valley, in Mendocino County - a lovely destination for wine lovers. I generally don't care much for chardonnays, for many of the reasons mentioned in the article, but this one is quite nice. ;o)
 
Kelly V. January 18, 2022
Yes, I love how accessible Louis Jadot is! I'll have to give Husch Chardonnay a try.