What is a good vegetable substitute for fennel?

I realize this answer is coming a little late, but I'm just now finding your question because I have the same question. I found a recipe also in Bon Appetit that calls for raw fennel, and I am not particularly fond of raw fennel. So, I am going to experiment with shaved asparagus, shaved bok choy, or possibly shaved radishes. I may well do a combination of all of them. I do know the shaved asparagus has a pretty neutral favor but a nice little crunch to it. I have used the shaved asparagus many times in salads, and it tastes great.

If your family doesn't like fennel, why not find another recipe. No other veggie will duplicate the anisy flavor.

My family says they do not like fennel. When I roast it first they enjoy the recipe. Don't know what your recipe is calling for and I agree with Merrile re. celery having similar texture and crunch if you are serving fennel raw.

It depends on the recipe, but if you're looking for a similar texture and crunch, celery could be a good alternative.