Why are eggs in US stores refrigerated?
Just out of curiosity...I was surprised on moving to France to discover that eggs are kept on an uncooled grocery store shelf. Also, I know people who raise chickens keep the eggs in a bowl on the counter. Are eggs in the US really old by the time they get to the store? Or is this a weird health regulation? Is it actually necessary to keep eggs in the refrigerator?
Recommended by Food52
16 Comments
In the US we are required to "wash" eggs in order to sell to the US market. In so doing, we wash off a protective coating which otherwise protects the eggs. When washed, the shell is porous and "may" allow bacteria to enter if contaminated AFTER leaving the plant's sanitation process, so we refrigerate them. European countries don't fuss over the "pure white" look of an egg (as we do here) so they do not wash them as throughly as we do.
Eggs here are fresh, they arrive within a day or two of being laid. Eggs pick up debris and some faecal matter when being laid; free range eggs may actually be worse from a bacterial contamination point of view, as they are laid "anywhere" on the floor (with bird drippings, etc) whereas caged eggs are retained in the cage and roll out onto a conveyor; faecal matter falls through the cage onto a waste belt for mechanical transport and disposal.
Salmonella contamination from within a bird's reproductive system is another problem, but here, the bacteria are in the egg prior to the shell being laid down and hardened, most of these birds need to be sacrificed to stop the spread.
You're absolutely correct, there are indeed viral causes of GI distress. Roughly half of food poisoning in the U.S. is caused by Norovirus.
Discussing the issue in detail is complicated because Norovirus can be transmitted directly from human to human just like the common cold and refrigeration is ineffective in controlling it. And there are dozens of other similar viruses that can be transmitted either by food or by other means.
The major problem with the term "stomach flu" isn't that it's incorrect (influenza is a respiratory illness), it's that people use it to write off food poisoning either naively believing the situation was out of their control or not wanting to accept they actually poisoned their family and friends.
Please, pick away. It's all good.
My personal experience agrees with yours, eggs usually appear clean when they're laid. Usually, and visibly. Food safety experts tell us that, under a microscope, it's an entirely different story. Thus the regulations and procedures.
The CDC says 1 out of every 6 Americans will get sick this year from foodborne illness. Most will write the experience off as "stomach flu" (not understanding there is no such thing) but 128,000 will end up in the hospital and will 3,000 die. Everyone (except professionals) is free to roll the dice as they wish. I am only trying to convey the science as we understand it so that we can all make informed decisions.
I prefer the term "understanding and respect" to the word "fear".
Unlike humans, chickens have a single posterior orifice through which they lay their eggs and defecate. Eggs and poop -- same hole. See the problem?
The natural protective coating blocks bacteria from entering the egg but pick up an egg and your hands become contaminated. Crack an egg and the contents come in contact with the outer surface of the shell. (This is the reason you're supposed to crack eggs on a flat surface instead of on the edge of a bowl, to minimize the amount of contamination.)
So, yes, eggs should be washed before cracking. And your hands afterward.
But this only covers the issue of external contamination. Contaminated feed (from chicken poop, flies, rodents, etc.) can infect the egg internally before it is laid. At room temperature, bacteria can multiply rapidly. Under optimal conditions, they can double in quantity every 20 minutes. It doesn't take long for a contaminated egg to become extremely dangerous.
( I was told by friends who raise their own chickens not to wash the eggs until right before cracking them so that the protective coating would remain and they would stay fresh on the counter)
All USDA-graded eggs are required to be washed and sanitized to remove bacteria from the shell. Doing so removes the natural coating that helps protect the egg, but it is then replaced with an edible oil coating, restoring the protection. If this sounds unnecessary, consider the pathway the egg takes on its way out of the chicken's butt.
But the shell isn't the only pathway bacteria can take. The reproductive track of an infected chicken (who aren't affected by salmonella) can transfer bacteria directly to the contents, usually the yolk but the white is also at risk. This is why refrigeration is a requirement.
More than you ever wanted to know about eggs:
http://www.ams.usda.gov/AMSv1.0/getfile?dDocName=STELDEV3004502
Voted the Best Reply!
Certainly when I moved to the USA, I was surprised by the need to refrigerate them.
I think Americas Test Kitchen did a piece on this.
Eggs in the U.S. are often only a few days old by the time they reach the store. You can check the three-digit pack date to confirm their age.
As stated above, eggs keep longer under refrigeration. Just as important, salmonella growth is retarded by refrigeration.