Presale! 2 new cookbooks from Food52. Claim your signed copies »
🔕 🔔

My Basket ()

All questions

Incomplete bar cookie recipe--should be an easy win for regular bakers

I have a recipe for bar Hermits calling for 1c. oil, 1 c. milk, 2 c. sugar, and 3 c. flour. There are a few other ingredients as well--I don't know what size pan, though the recipe says bake at 350 for 30-40 minutes. Bonus: what is the role of milk in cookie recipes? It's rare to see so much liquid involved, but I guess this will be more of a spreadable batter. Can I substitute something else--juice, water? Milk is somewhat of a commodity in my house.

asked by Raquelita over 4 years ago
4 answers 1790 views
23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar
added over 4 years ago

Sounds like a 13" x 9" to me - they would be too thick in a square 8x8 pan. For flavor and texture I wouldn't sub water for the milk, though you could reconstitute some nonfat dry milk powder in water and use that. The milk to flour/sugar ratio sounds about right, but the oil seems like a lot...let us know how they turn out!

Wholefoods user icon
added over 4 years ago

Why not use almond, soy or coconut milk, unsweetened variety if you don't want the extra sugar? I love to use these milks in baking. They even curdle with apple cider vinegar - just like cow's milk - to use in place of buttermilk.

0236a64a 6089 48f7 8ce6 5b790ad33fd9  0605111238
added over 4 years ago

Thanks for your help everyone--I changed up the recipe a lot and ended up with something more like a cake. It was definitely too much oil, and i ended up using melted butter and olive oil. Here's the recipe (written with just butter, and using buttermilk instead of milk and vinegar as the original recipe called for):

3a63c30b f172 4d69 8ba7 6fc11dc5c3cd  0508122008a

0236a64a 6089 48f7 8ce6 5b790ad33fd9  0605111238
added over 4 years ago

Just to clarify, I reflected the change in oil/fat amount in the recipe--i started with half and worked up to the right amount.

Join Our Email List!

Inbox Inspiration:

Our newsletter is brimming with recipes and features that have us talking—dive in!

A Joyful Home:

Sign up to get $10 off a first purchase of $50 or more in our shop full of tools & treasures.

Come On In:

Join our humming community and get dibs on events, peeks at new cookbooks, and a surprise or two.

Please enter a valid email address.