is philadeliphia cream cheese sold in the tub (not whipped) the same as the kind in the bar? my supermarket only has the tub, and the label says "cream cheese spread"? can i use for cream cheese frosting or is this dodgy?
Great question! They are not actually the same thing. The cream cheese sold in the tub has a much softer consistency, suitable for easily spreading on a bagel or sandwich. The much thicker bar-style cream cheese is what is typically called for in cream cheese frosting. You can use the cream cheese in the tub, but you will have to alter the quantities of the other ingredients. When I lived in London, where I could only find the tub cream cheese, I would reduce the amount of liquid (usually milk) in the frosting recipe, or eliminate it entirely. I also would sometimes reduce the amount of butter in the recipe as well, especially if I was planning on leaving the frosting or frosted cake out at room temperature for a while, since at room temperature, butter is very soft and would cause the frosting made with tub cream cheese to slide off the cake or wilt on cupcakes. I preferred to reduce the butter and liquid, rather than increase the amount of confectioner's sugar (which would have the same stiffening effect on the frosting), because I do not like it when cream cheese frosting is very sweet. If you can only find tub cream cheese, I suggest you experiment to figure out what ratio of ingredients you prefer, based on how thick and sweet you like your frosting. Best of luck!
Please enter a valid email address.
Well played. You deserve a cookie.
Dan Saltzstein reviews Samarkand and Golden
Piglet Day 3—See the Latest Winner!
Will Gordon Ramsay Roast Us on Twitter?
By Food52: Bee's Wrap, Baking Chocolate & More!
Pork Recipes for Weeknights & Weekends
Bright Ways to Organize Your Kitchen
prevented successful signup:
We'll never post anything without your permission.
prevented successful login:
Thanks for signing up!
Connect with us to get more Food52!
Get the recipes and features that have us talking, plus first dibs on events and limited-batch products.
(Oh, and $10 off your order of $50 or more in the Food52 Shop, too.)