Shepherds Pie. Mine always falls. Comes out like a pile of mush. However very delicious mush. How can I make it more sturdy/solid?

I think it's all the potatoes fault!

  • Posted by: Tasha
  • December 2, 2014


Tasha December 8, 2014
Thanks everyone! Great and useful tips!!
Pegeen December 3, 2014
Jennifer, thanks, that's an interesting tip to know. I've never added a thickener before, so that's why I was wondering if the issue might be too much liquid (maybe broth?) added to the beef/lamb.
kimhw December 2, 2014
Are you pulling it out of the pan steaming hot? If so it will never "stand up". But the more important question, is it delicious? If so, who cares if it looks pretty. Shepard's pie is a lovely rustic family meal. Throw it in a big bowl, mix it all up together and enjoy!!!
Jennifer E. December 2, 2014
I always stir in, after I cook the meat and veggies, 1/3 of a cup of arrowroot starch. It will make it stick together, and offers no taste change. It works!
Pegeen December 2, 2014
Hey Jennifer, I am the first person to say that arrowroot is an awesome ingredient. But 1/3 cup (I assume you mean to dilute it in water) in a shepherd's pie seems like too much... it seems like something else is going wrong.
Jennifer E. December 2, 2014
Actually, I don't add water. I just stir it in. It just sets it. I learned this trick following a recipe by Paleo Mom called Tortier-Inspired Shepherds Pie.
Pegeen December 2, 2014
Also, I'm thinking be sure there isn't too much milk going in, or the potatoes will definitely be "softer" and collapse more.
Pegeen December 2, 2014
And! Be sure you're not crumbling your beef or lamb too much when you saute it. It shouldn't be ground up evenly into small bits, there should be some chunks.
Pegeen December 2, 2014
To make the ground beef or lamb base "sturdier," be sure you're not using too much liquid in it (such as broth, tomato sauce or water).
To help your mashed potatoes be their best, don't peel them before cubing and boiling - keeping the skin on while boiling helps prevent water absorption. It's very easy to peel off the skins after. Drain the potatoes, let cool, peel. Then return peeled potatoes to the drained pot over a very low flame, shaking the pot a few times to prevent sticking, just to dry them out a little more. Then pass potatoes through a food mill or potato ricer.
Always heat your milk (ideally whole milk) before adding to the mashed potatoes and use room temp butter.
By the way, I find a Tablespoon or two of A1 or HP Steak Sauce to the meat does wonders for boosting flavor. Just adds a lot of flavor it would be hard to replicate yourself.

Tasha December 2, 2014
I just mean it doesn't stand like it does in pictures. Like in a nice square. I'll try the egg :)
keg72 December 2, 2014
I'm not sure exactly what you mean by "falls," but if you suspect that it's the potatoes' fault, perhaps you are making them too wet. Also, the recipe I've used calls for the addition of an egg to the mashed potatoes which would help with the sturdiness.
Recommended by Food52