Weird ketchup combinations?

What's the weirdest thing you eat with ketchup?

Sarah Jampel


Crazy K. October 21, 2023
Ok you all about to go on a ride with me bc I'm not called the Ketchup Queen for nothing! Pizza with ketchup, fruit by the foot with ketchup, rice crispy treat with ketchup, ice cream with ketchup, carrots with ketchup, beef sticks with ketchup, strawberries with ketchup, bread with ketchup, cheese with ketchup (has to be a specific kind of cheese), paper with ketchup (don't question me for being weird), children bones with ketchup :D, etc. (Also last one was joke but I have other combinations I just can't think of)
Jessika March 25, 2022
Ketchup + sour cream and onion chips, one of my favorite combos of all time
wierddiver01 February 26, 2020
Banana + Ketchup (really good, I would recommend this). Grapes + Ketchup, and finally Peppers + Ketchup.
Leslie S. June 10, 2015
Ketchup + cottage cheese 4ever and always #noregrets
C April 14, 2015
one of my best friends in childhood used to dip her slices of plain cheese (or pepperoni) pizza in ketchup
Crazy K. October 21, 2023
I also do that :]
Tony S. April 14, 2015
I no longer eat it but my favorite sandwich when I was a kid goes like this- white bread, american cheese, bologna, ketchup, and mayonnaise.

I just lost my appetite while typing...
luvcookbooks April 14, 2015
My older brother used to eat ketchup sandwiches w saltine crackers instead of bread. He had theater group after school and that was his supper on the fly!
Kristen W. April 14, 2015
Eggs, eggs, eggs, eggs, eggs!
keg72 April 13, 2015
I love dipping potato chips, grilled cheese and pickles (separately!) into ketchup. And the ketchup must be Heinz.
ChefJune April 13, 2015
My sister used to stir ketchup into her cottage cheese when we were kids.
PieceOfLayerCake April 13, 2015
Can I be "that guy" and say that ketchup is violently disgusting? If not, I'll keep it to myself.
amysarah April 13, 2015
Not necessarily weird, but both my mother's recipes for meatloaf and brisket (pot roast) include a couple of good glugs of ketchup, mixed in during cooking. Just not the same without.
creamtea April 13, 2015
Scrambled eggs and ketchup; and what Stephanie said: mac and cheese with just a little ketchup mixed in.
Stephanie April 13, 2015
Oh and I just remembered that my sister and I loved to put ketchup on our mac and cheese when we were little. I shudder to think about that flavor now.
Stephanie April 13, 2015
Ok, it's not actually eaten with the ketchup but blended into it. So, I don't know if it technically counts but...Banana peppers! A local food truck does tots served with banana pepper ketchup and it's awesome. Just the right amount of acid and a subtle warmth.
TobiT April 13, 2015
By the way: KETCHUP or CATSUP?
TobiT April 13, 2015
Cottage cheese. And scrambled eggs. And though I've never tried it before, I now have a hankering for potato chips with ketchup!
aargersi April 13, 2015
I love me some ketchup! Of COURSE I dip my grilled cheese in it, and it goes on scrambled eggs and fried egg sammiches, and Ivan Ramen introduced me to fried rice with ketchup draped in egg and squirted with MORE ketchup. Secret Sauce for Animal Style burgers:

I no longer put it on my cream of wheat or oatmeal, for that I switched to Louisiana Hot Sauce ... though MIXING and adding them would be awesome ...
QueenSashy April 13, 2015
Greek yogurt
JulieS April 13, 2015
My Dad used to put ketchup on everything including in his pea soup.

Voted the Best Reply!

boulangere April 13, 2015
Potato chips.
inpatskitchen April 13, 2015
GiGi26 and I spent hours in her basement listening to 60s music (LPs) and eating potato chips and ketchup!
boulangere April 13, 2015
Great story, Pat. I thought I was the only one. Glad to have some company.
Panfusine April 13, 2015
Ketchup sandwich was a childhood favorite of mine, made with 3 or 4 slices of white bread layered with the thick spoonable version of the condiment with the crust cut off to reveal the beautiful red lines!.
My son likes it with Dosai (South indian style lentil crepes)
Recommended by Food52