what would be a good cheese substitute for the feta in the recipe? Not a fan of that particular cheese

  • Posted by: Ruchi
  • March 31, 2016


paseo April 2, 2016
With all due respect, real feta is from sheep's milk. If feta is too strong, soak in half milk and half water. Or perhaps a ricotta salata or manouri instead.
Susan W. April 2, 2016
Actually, traditionally, it's made with a mixture of both, but can be made with either.
aargersi April 1, 2016
I actually make a cheese from Le Pigeon cookbook for that platter, it's basically a very lemony queso fresco, and it's always a hit. I would think any sort of soft mild cheese would work, really whatever YOU like. I would make sure it's spreadable
AntoniaJames April 1, 2016
Whoa, Abbie, that sounds delicious. On my "must try" list. ;o)
Ruchi March 31, 2016
thanks for your thoughts
i love taleggio, queso fresco not a bad idea either!
i don't love feta because of the vinegary-ness for lack of a better term. but was hoping to find something with a similar texture. I thought about paneer but i think too bland almost..
my husband hates all goat cheeses - i trick him into eating the hard ones without issue but he won't do anything soft that goaty
Susan W. March 31, 2016
According to my Greek grandfather, the best feta is made with sheep's milk, not goat. Have you tried it? There used to be a commonly found version from France that is very mild and creamy tasting. Or...have you tried Halloumi? Very mild, but with that good crumbly texture. It's made with goat and sheep's milk, so you may or may not be able to trick your husband. Very fresh ricotta may be a good choice. Full fat and made in small batches. My store sells it in small crocks. It's made locally here in Portland.
Ruchi March 31, 2016
halloumi is a great idea!! i usually pan fry it with herbs but this would be a great place to use it as well
AntoniaJames March 31, 2016
Have you ever tried Valbreso French feta, made from sheep's milk? It's delicious - a bit creamier and less tart than your classic Greek feta.

I get it at one of the desi stores nearby (wonderful place that provides excellent meat for my goat roasts). ;o)
Susan W. March 31, 2016
AJ, that's the one I was referring to. I love it, but haven't seen it at my local grocery stores. Glad to hear it's still around!
Susan W. March 31, 2016
I love Saganaki made with halloumi!
Ruchi March 31, 2016
thank you all so much! i think I'm gonna try this with halloumi or sheeps milk feta (ill see if i can sample a taste before buying)
Susan W. April 1, 2016
I think I'm reversing the Halloumi suggestion. I didn't read the recipe closely. I thought the cheese was pan fried after the herbs were pressed in it. I think the fresh ricotta or French feta are your best best. Let us know what you go with and how it turns out.
pierino March 31, 2016
Feta is a goat's milk cheese. You might try Humbolt Fog, which is not as strong, or a perhaps a Stilton which is an English cheddar. Taleggio also a cow's milk cheese might work. What is it that you don't like about Feta?
Regine March 31, 2016
See link regarding queso fresco. I usually found it in aisle of sour cream, cream cheese, etc.

Regine March 31, 2016
Best substitute for me is the Mexican cheese called Queso Fresco. I love its ultra mild flavor.
LouLou March 31, 2016
Did you try goat cheese?
Recommended by Food52