Thai "thin soy sauce" aka "white soy sauce" is my preferred vegetarian fish sauce replacement. Dragonfly brand is by far the best I've tried. Many Asian food markets stock it, but here it is online: http://www.bangkokmarketusa.com/sauces/202-dragonfly-thin-soy-sauce-19-oz-.html
The fish sauce would have provided both salt and umami.
Think of substitutes which have those notes, including those mentioned so far.
Also/Or:
• fermented mushroom sauce
• pickle brine
• wine vinegar
• walnut ketchup
I think this recipe would taste good without the fish sauce too, just looking at the ingredients. But I can also see Smaug's point. It won't have the same funk as fish sauce, but miso paste would add some umami flavor place of the fish sauce.
I don't think you can just ignore fish sauce; it makes itself felt. Soy sauce is probably the best you can do; maybe something with one of those Chinese fermented bean concoctions, but I know little about them.
8 Comments
Think of substitutes which have those notes, including those mentioned so far.
Also/Or:
• fermented mushroom sauce
• pickle brine
• wine vinegar
• walnut ketchup