What are the best cookies to ship?

I'm gearing up to make some goodies for my holiday swap partner, and since I've never mailed cookies/homemade treats before, I'd love some recommendations on ones that will stand up to the USPS (beyond biscotti, though that's on my list to consider).

What are your go-to edible gifts that transport well? I am going to stay away from anything that is dipped/delicate sandwich cookies per this article: https://food52.com/blog... and will use this one for when I'm ready to ship: https://food52.com/hotline....

Thanks in advance for the tips!

Nicole Davis
  • 689 views
  • 9 Comments

9 Comments

HalfPint December 4, 2023
Like everyone has noted: any drop cookies, unfrosted/glazed (this is especially important in warmer weather) preferably. It really comes down to how they are packed for shipment.

From my experience, I have found that rolled sugar cookies, shortbread-type cookies, and bar cookies also ship well. If they are packed snug but not tight, with little chance to move about in the shipping container.

I like self-sealing cellophane bags which helps to contain mess and breakage to one or 2 bags and not the entire shipment. I also like aluminum foil to packaging since it keeps cookies fresh longer and the wrapped cookies are cocooned so they don't shift around too much.
 
Nicole D. December 4, 2023
Thank you for these tips, Halfpint!
 
Lori T. November 30, 2023
When I was stationed overseas- my favorite cookie box always contained crispy peanut butter cookies, Anzac biscuits, Speculaas and springerle. Since I wasn't a fan of anise, my grandmother would make them with orange oil or vanilla sugar, but traditional types would also make the trek well.
 
Nicole D. December 4, 2023
Thank you, Lori! I had to look up Anzac biscuits, I wasn't familiar, and saw that apparently they were made for Australian men serving in WWI because they stay fresh so long: https://food52.com/recipes/36557-chewy-anzac-biscuits
 
Miss_Karen November 30, 2023
Gingerbread. The flavors actually get better with time. Shortbread.
Unfrosted or un glazed.
Oatmeal cookies. Most types of drop cookies...
I put my cookies into Ziplock bags & make sure to squish out as much of the air as possible.
 
Nicole D. December 4, 2023
Thank you for the recs, Miss_Karen!
 
702551 November 29, 2023
Basically any classic cookie (i.e., 19th century or earlier) is going to work because they were created in an era without refrigeration.

Biscotti isn't a single cookie, it's really a generic Italian name for a family of cookies made similarly (twice baked, hence "biscotti"). Let's remember that Pliny the Elder wrote about baked goods using the twice-baked method (circa 110 CE). Every Italian region has their own biscotti (cantuccini in one popular Tuscan version) with different names and varying ingredients.

There are a bunch of good old Italian cookies that fall into this category, just look for "lunga conservazione" or "long conservation" in old cookbooks. Most of these old cookies don't have much in the way of fat (less to go rancid), especially butter.

With modern shipping speeds and generally cool weather in the Northern Hemisphere, I don't think it matters that much, as long as the cookie itself is durable enough to survive being tossed around by a common carrier (UPS, FedEx, USPS).

Think twice about shipping fragile cookies, ones with lots of butter (or fresh dairy), and deep fried items.

I will call out lebkuchen, the classic German gingerbread as a cookie suitable for shipping, again providing that any decorations are sturdy enough. The cookie itself can last months.

There are also classic cakes (English style fruitcakes, the Sienese panforte, etc.). Many of these date to the Middle Ages (or earlier).
 
Nancy November 30, 2023
Nice historical note 😊
 
Nicole D. December 4, 2023
Thank you 702551—great tips and fascinating baking history!
 
Recommended by Food52