What is your traditional Christmas Cookie Favorites

Every year I make Kolache apricot cookies and Zebra ( chocolate and vanilla shortbread dough).love both would like to add one more to the traditional two. What's your traditional Christmas Cookie?🎄

BerryBaby
  • 239 views
  • 8 Comments

8 Comments

Emily W. November 8, 2024
Ricciarelli (https://fearlessfresh.com/ricciarelli-italian-almond-christmas-cookies/) delicious and naturally gluten free!
 
Nancy November 7, 2024
No favorite to name, but an interesting article on origin and evolution of cookies associated with Christmas, with a list later in the article of some popular varieties.

https://culturallyours.com/2019/12/04/history-and-culture-of-christmas-cookies/
 
Nancy November 7, 2024
PS
Berrybaby - good to see you back.
 
BerryBaby November 9, 2024
I was wondering if that was you! Nice to be back. You've been a member for a long time. Hope you are doing well.
 
matthewmiless November 5, 2024
If you want something unique, try Pfeffernüsse, a spiced German cookie with cloves, nutmeg, and cinnamon—it’s soft, slightly chewy, and perfect for the season. Happy baking! 🎄 https://thatsnotmy-neighbor.io
 
luvcookbooks November 5, 2024
https://food52.com/recipes/25631-cinnamon-stars
My late mil’s recipe for Cinnamon Stars.
 
702551 November 4, 2024
I heavily favor very traditional cookies from Italy, ones whose origins are centuries old.

What Americans call "biscotti" are typically the Tuscan cantucci which is centuries old. (These are also known as a "biscotti di Prato"). It's worth noting that double-baking technique has been recorded since Roman times (Pliny the Elder was one who mentioned this). Cantucci were originally Christmas cookies although now they are just more or less generic biscotti served anytime, anyplace with zero context in the USA.

Perhaps my all time favorite Christmas cookie is Ricciarelli di Siena. These date back at least to the medieval era. These days I have bake these all year long but they are traditionally a Christmas cookie. Cavallucci is another old Tuscan Christmas specialty.

All of the traditionally Catholic countries have excellent Christmas cookies. I'm very fond of lebkuchen (most famous from Nuremberg) even if I don't bake them myself these days.

All of the Italian regions have traditional local Christmas specialties, it's not just a handful of cookies with red and green sprinkles for the entire country (which didn't form until the late 19th century).

I am also a panettone enthusiast which is another Christmas delicacy that I don't bake myself.
 
BerryBaby November 9, 2024
Every Christmas, our aunt Kate would give us a box of Italian cookies that she baked. We'd get so excited when she arrived with a shoebox in hand. I can't tell you what a favorite one was because they were so good. I've tried to replicate them. Still good but not the same.
 
Recommended by Food52