Nigella Lawson's Linguine With Lemon, Garlic & Thyme Mushrooms

i made this tonight and it was pretty darn good. Actually, is was quite delightful and also quite versatile as it can be a hot pasta, a cold pasta salad or anywhere in between plus you can riff on it a bit by adding complementary ingredients (asparagus was mentioned at the table as was our home-canned albacore belly) and still keep the dish quite true.
Pasta like this is a bit out of my wheelhouse so I bucked tradition and actually followed the recipe except used gemelli, as the only strands that I had were capellini and the rotary cheese grater still had pecorino romano loaded in it so i went with that flow. I think i used more than 8 oz crimini mushrooms but i sliced them very thin so that they would at least reach an elevated temp when mixed with the pasta- i think the dish could benefit from more mushrooms if you are slicing very thin (not shaved, but pretty thin- certainly no thicker than the ones in the picture). I think it could take more cheese as well. I've never had a good grasp of measuring grated cheese by volume (a target weight would be really nice for the times i actually try and make a recipe as written). I use a rotary drum grater made for parm and romano that makes very thin curls of cheese when the cheese is of cut-from-the-wheel moisture. i put in about a 1/3 cup of this cheese (lightly pressed into the cup) and i think it could use more.

Ironically, Ovo/lacto pescetarian daughter was the only one in the family that didn't find the recipe to her liking- "too lemony". Boohoo, next time i'll use sausage instead of lemon (joking). She was the reason that I prepared the dish in the first place.

p.s. i also put in more black pepper than "a pinch"- probably 20 twists from a peugeot set on middle setting- 3/8 tsp - scant 1/2 tsp.

Made this exactly as written. Excellent - love that you don't have to cook anything except the pasta. Will make again and again!

Thank you Nigella for this perfect dish. It has become part of the rotation in our household. Fast and homemade. Perfect as is or adapted. I like to add fresh herbs, greens, veggies or sometimes chicken.

I'm not a fan of raw mushrooms, but I make this pretty much as written and I think it is perfect. Made it last night for a dinner party and people wanted the recipe.

I made this today. I did cook the mushrooms some because I'm sensitive to raw nightshade. I added some asparagus too because I needed to use it up. And extra cheese because I can. Loved this and I'm sure it tastes just as good with raw mushrooms and no asparagus.

OBSESSED with this pasta. The only thing we did really differently was to slightly heat the cremini mushrooms in a skillet to get the raw taste out. Don't overcook, just heat them enough so they don't all look dry and raw (no oil necessary in the pan). Add to the bowl, mix everything up with hot pasta noodles and then toss with a lot of good quality freshly grated Parmesan cheese. Made this 3 times in the last month. Sooooooooo good.

I am addicted to this delicious but so simple to prepare pasta. Use Cremini mushrooms for more pronounced flavor. I’ve never had the parsley on hand to make it and still loved it.

Love, love, love this. I added some sliced grilled chicken because we had unexpected guests and i needed to stretch it. It’s really good either way.

Just made this again, and it's so delicious and easy. Just the thing for when you're feeling in a bit of a rut with food/cooking. I usually make adjustments to the ingredients based on what I have on hand, and it always comes out well. But anyone who is cooking the mushrooms is sort of missing the point.

I made this for dinner the other night, substituting thyme for fresh basil. It was a huge hit, especially with my mother. I think next time I won't add parsley though, because I don't like the texture. I absolutely recommend this recipe!

halved this, and it worked great. i also used baby bellas--i sauteed them with the garlic in the oil, then mixed them with the lemon juice, zest and oregano before adding the pasta. i also transferred the pasta to the bowl with tongs to make sure i got some pasta water in there--with the oil it made a lovely sauce. next time i'll try it with the mushrooms raw, but it seems like it will be delicious either way.

Don't change a thing when you make this! It's perfect as is and the flavors are simple and clean. Thanks Nigella!

A modest dish where the ingredients blend exceptionally well. Aroma from the herbs fills my mouth and lingers after finishing. The garlic gives a little sparkling spiciness to it. As with other Food52er here, I put the mushroom in the pan with olive oil to cook it a little first before tossing.

I love how people say how great the recipe is "after" they change it completely...

I have never had mushrooms this way and read all the comments and figured I would try it. This was SUCH a winner with my family which I honestly didn't expect for the amount of effort it took! I need 4-5 other meals like this :)

I followed the recipe. Delicious. Not too lemony at all. I might add some toasted pine nuts next time.

I made this a couple of weeks ago and used soba noodles since I served it as soon as it was done so it was room temperature. Making it again tonight!

Followed the recipe exactly and it was perfect. I see others chose to cook the mushrooms first, but to me, the "genius" of the recipe is that you don't have to cook them. It was delicious! I'll be making this again.

The pasta in the pic looks epic!

Cheryl - It was great I made it for my daughters boyfriend he loves mushrooms my daughter doesn't then I added Caribbean style Adobo it contains toasted onion, garlic, sea salt, Mexican oregano, black pepper, and chiles. All those ingredients come in a savory package, Then topped with a little Havarti cheese for a butter taste. Cheryl