Pickle & Preserve
Buckwheat Thumbprint Cookies with Cherry Preserves
Popular on Food52
19 Reviews
Dominika U.
December 13, 2020
I followed this recipe *exactly* but the cookies spread a lot in the oven. I chilled the dough for at least 24 hrs. I'm an experienced baker. I used a scale to weigh everything. Not sure why the dough spread so much. The flavor of this dough is truly *awesome*. Really nutty and special and nuanced, not too sweet. Which is why I'd like to make these work. I'm tempted to add AP flour to help stiffen the dough a bit. I was unable to fill them with jam because they didn't have the right spherical shape for me. 😕
RWen
December 21, 2021
I agree that there's something missing here. Perhaps different brands of flours impact the overall success.
Andrea B.
April 1, 2020
These are amazing! Buckwheat, rice flour and oat flour is a winning combo. We baked and reviewed these in Episode 170 of our Preheated Baking Podcast.
Evan
June 3, 2017
These are excellent. I made them without the powdered sugar because they were already plenty sweet to my taste, but everything else I followed to a T. I found that they spread slightly more than I'd like and they're lighter and a little less dense than my favorite shortbreads/butter cookies, not sure if there's a difference in how I baked them that could have influenced that (I noticed the ones on the bottom of the oven and the darker cookie sheet spread less and browned more on the bottom, which was nice) but this is a recipe I hope to perfect through many more rounds of practice over the years. Thanks!
Alissa
May 25, 2016
These are delicious! Added some chopped apricots, a splash of brandy, and some cardamom to the cherry preserves. Turned out beautifully.
Losi P.
May 8, 2016
I just baked these off and they are perfect, I followed the updated recipe. Made them for mother's day....very toothsome cookie, I would make these again! Perfect with a cup of tea.
Laura415
December 24, 2015
It's a shame that this was printed incorrectly. I am currently in love with buckwheat flour. I make gnocchi with the buckwheat groats and flour and they are to die for. Alice Medrich is a genius with alternative flours. I've got to get her book. I don't have any cherry preserves so the first batch will have to have apricot. Don't be soured on this recipe or this author. She is brilliant! I guess if the cookies spread too much I would chill the dough after shaping. I would also use a silpat or parchment paper to help with dark bottoms. Good luck everyone.
Jen
December 22, 2015
I followed the recipe to the exact gram and my cookie spread, the edges burnt, the middles were undercooked they and crumbled apart. The crumbs taste good, but I can't serve these to even my closest friends. I'm bummed! These ingredients are not cheap and I'm also out a GF alternative for Christmas Eve.
This is written only as a warning to the fellow baker. Unfortunately, I did not read the other reviews before baking.
This is written only as a warning to the fellow baker. Unfortunately, I did not read the other reviews before baking.
Betsy
December 17, 2015
I made these and found them delicious but mine spread out more than expected rather than staying in balls. Any ideas what went wrong? I believe I followed the recipe quite carefully, including weighing the ingredients.
mainecook61
December 11, 2014
So.....a buckwheat cookie. Does it taste like buckwheat even with all the butter, cream cheese, pecans and oat flour? Yep. Are the baking instructions good? Yes, except that they browned more quickly than I expected and I lost a few to dark bottoms. Double sheets a good idea here. Also, even if you adore buckwheat in a cookie, the cherry jam is the way to go here. Powdered sugar alone will just remind you that these are a VERY distant relative of the "iconic Russian tea cake." Did I like them? Nope. They got very very lonely on the holiday cookie plate.
mjochums
December 5, 2014
I made these cookies with the 6 T butter and 1/8 teaspoon baking powder, and they are delicious! Curious to try them the correct way...
Linda M.
December 4, 2014
I think whomever runs this site needs an editor. How can we rely on your recipes without concern that we've wasted ingredients on nonsense?
Kristen M.
December 4, 2014
This was an oversight, which I'm sorry about. We have a dedicated team of editors who respond as quickly as they can when issues like this come up -- we appreciate your patience, and we want mistakes fixed as much as you do!
durun99
December 4, 2014
Thanks for the clarifications, Kristen. I've found many great recipes on this site (especially in your Genius Recipes column) and don't mind the occasional oversight. This is a great service you all provide to many dedicated readers.
durun99
December 1, 2014
These look good. Two questions: (1) the ingredients list baking powder, the instructions say baking soda---which one should be used? (2) the ingredients call for 6 tablespoons of butter, which is 85 grams, or half the weight listed--should it be 12 tablespoons or 85 grams of butter? Thanks.
devendra
December 3, 2014
Looks like the butter measurement has been fixed. But good question about the soda. Soda or powder?
Kristen M.
December 4, 2014
durun99 and devandra, thank you for your patience. I've just clarified both in the recipe -- it should be 1/8 teaspoon baking soda and 12 tablespoons (170 grams) butter.
See what other Food52ers are saying.