Palak Paneer
Author Notes: A North Indian entrée, palak paneer is made out spinach, paneer, and other delightful assortments like onion, tomatoes, garlic, ginger, and, of course, Indian spices. —Annada Rathi
Serves: 2 to 4
-
3
tablespoons vegetable oil, divided
-
8
ounces fresh spinach, washed
-
6 to 8
ounces paneer (Indian grocery stores generally sell paneer in 12- to 14-ounce slabs)
-
5 to 6
black peppercorns
-
1
cardamom
-
2
cloves
-
3/4
cup diced red onions, about 1/2-inch pieces
-
1
tablespoon ginger, peeled and grated
-
2
medium garlic cloves, peeled and crushed
-
1
Thai chile diced (optional)
-
1
cup diced tomatoes, about 1-inch pieces
-
1
pinch sugar
-
4
teaspoons tomato sauce
-
3/4 to 1
teaspoons salt
-
1
teaspoon garam masala
-
1/4
cup cream or 1/2 cup milk (optional)
- Pour 1 tablespoon oil in a thick-bottomed pan and turn the heat to medium. Pour the spinach into the pan. Within a few minutes, the spinach will wilt down. Sauté to avoid spinach sticking to the pan and turn the heat off after 10 minutes. Once the spinach cools down, transfer to a blender or food processor and blend to a purée.
- Boil 2 cups of water and once the water comes to a rolling boil, add paneer slabs. Turn the heat off after paneer has been in the boiling water for 5 minutes and cover the pot with a lid. Let paneer cool in the water, then cut it into 1- by 1/2-inch pieces and set aside.
- Roughly crush peppercorns, cardamom and cloves in a mortar and pestle and throw out the cardamom skin. If using a spice grinder, remove the cardamom skin and use only the seeds (save the cardamom skin for chai).
- Wipe the pan you used for spinach and heat remaining 2 tablespoons oil over medium heat. Add onions and stir till they get a brownish tinge, then add ginger, garlic, and, if using, Thai chile pepper. Sauté for 2 to 3 minutes. Pour chopped tomatoes followed by pinch of sugar. Once the tomatoes break down, add tomato sauce and spice mix of peppercorns, cardamom, and cloves. Stir till the liquid evaporates and the onion/tomato mixture starts turning dark, about 9 to 10 minutes.
- Pour in blended spinach purée. Add salt and 1/2 cup water to adjust consistency. You can add a little bit more if you find the sauce is getting pasty.
- Once the spinach mixture boils, gently drop in paneer pieces. Let the paneer soak in the flavors and spices of the spinach purée for about 10 minutes.
- Add garam masala. After 4 to 5 minutes, pour milk or cream. They're completely optional—their sole purpose is to enrich the dish.
- Eat with naan or take it for lunch next day layered over rice (feel free to thin it out with little bit of water the next day). Palak paneer can be made 2 days in advance for a party, too.
- This recipe is a Community Pick!
More Great Recipes:
Vegetable|Entree|Make Ahead|Vegetarian
Showing out of comments
I made this and we loved it! Quite the forgiving recipe. Very warm and pleasant spices with just the right amount of heat from 1 Thai chile.
I did fry the paneer so it would be firmer in the sauce. That was the only way I modified the recipe to our taste.
Thank you Tim. I'm very happy that you liked the recipe & the dish. Frying the paneer tastes great too, imparts a certain richness to the dish.
This recipe did not work for me, but I am glad others enjoyed it. The ginger overpowered all the other flavors, despite using more peppers than called for (I like things spicy!). I also found that I prefer this dish without the tomato. I like the vegetal taste of spinach and once cooked down and concentrated the tomatoes really competed with the spinach flavor. Between the ginger and the tomato all other flavors were lost for me. However, I made my own paneer for this recipe, and I am glad I did because now I know how to do it! I let mine sit overnight in the fridge before making this to firm up and instead of boiling it first I just added it to the pot and let simmer with the purée for about 15 minutes. It did not break up even with stirring.
I understand that you were more interested in pure spinach flavor. And I'm glad that your homemade paneer turned out great. The reason to boil the paneer (irrespective of homemade or store-bought) is to make it soft and spongy in the spinach. Thank you for your helpful tips, Kelli.
How much is "one cardamom"? I'm not familiar with anything other than dried. Can't wait to try the recipe!
Hi Amy,
Cardamom here means green cardamom, not brown, dry one. My apologies, I should have specified in the recipe. Have fun cooking!
This was definitely a bit slow going for a weeknight but it's delicious! Will make again.
Arrggh! My paneer fell apart. I wish I would have added the garam masala before I cooked the paneer because when I stirred the spice in at the end (very gently) the paneer broke apart. Still tasted good, though.
Sorry that your paneer fell apart, Lisa. By any chance, did you make the paneer at home? I have observed in my attempts over the years that generally paneer falls apart when it is too dry. That is, when it looses excess moisture in the process of tying it up in muslin cloth. Glad you liked the taste at the end though.
Deep fry the paneer. I have been doing it that way for 35 years when making both palak and mattar paneer.
Made this recipe twice tonight! First time without modification, second time learning from the first. Recipe calls for only 8oz spinach which is about enough for two people. I thought the clove spice was too strong so cut it to a single clove the second time I made it. If using fresh tomatoes, dice them fine - it will help them break down faster. I used three fresh thai chilis for the right amount of heat. Serranos will be much milder - but probably not as tasty. First time boiled the paneer as instructed. Second time boiled then flour and browned in butter. Browned looks nice but doesn't seem to add much for me. Some restaurant versions also have a cinnamon stick and bay leaf - might try that next time.
I have made this three times now with spinach, radish tops, kale, etc, and it is always so delicious! this recipe launched me full on into a quest for the best indian recipes. grateful for that.
Thank you Kelley. I'm super impressed that you tried this recipe with other greens and thrilled that it works.
This looks so good! Can't wait to try it.
Whoa... Just finished gobbling this down, unquestionably a success. Super delicious and super easy.
Thank you Rey! Very happy that you liked it.
Showing 16 out of 16 comments