I found some rib eye steaks on sale at our local market, so I decided to try pan-searing and oven-roasting them. I thought I had gone completely crazy when I said to myself that I wasn't going to grill a rib eye. However, the final result was a very tender, moist, juicy and flavor-filled steak. So good, I would even dare say it rivaled a grilled steak. Yes, I said it. —Chris Hunnicutt
Watch This Recipe
Oven Rib Eye Steak
2 hours 20 minutes
rib eye steaks
kosher salt for initial seasoning of steaks, 1/2 tablespoon for spice mix, plus more for mushrooms, plus 1 teaspoon for cream sauce
black pepper, plus more for mushrooms, plus 1 teaspoon for cream sauce
Whole mushrooms, as many as you'd like to serve
Olive oil, for drizzling on mushrooms
In This Recipe
Take the steaks out a couple of hours before cooking and sprinkle about 1 teaspoon of kosher salt on them, and wrap them in parchment paper. Place them in the fridge for about 2 hours. This will pull excess moisture from the meat.
Take the steaks out of the fridge and remove paper. Pat dry. Mix all dry spices and 1/2 tablespoon salt together. Sprinkle lightly on each side of steaks (use only about half of dry mixture in total here). Let sit at room temperature for 20 minutes.
While you are waiting, take some whole mushrooms, sprinkle with olive oil and place in a toaster oven for those 20 minutes. On minute 10, season with salt and pepper, just a light sprinkle.
Heat your oven to 375°F and meanwhile, heat up your cast iron skillet on the stovetop, on medium-high heat. Sprinkle remaining dry seasonings on steaks evenly. Sear each side of the steaks in the skillet for 2 minutes per side. Place skillet in the oven. Let cook in oven for 2 minutes, then turn oven off. Let steaks cook another 6 to 8 minutes.
Take steaks out and let rest. While they are resting, take the skillet you seared the steaks in and place it over the stovetop on medium heat. Add heavy cream, salt, pepper, lemon juice, and mozzarella cheese. Stir. When all incorporated, add butter and turn heat off. Mix until butter has melted.
Plate steak and place mushrooms on top, then top with cream sauce. Serve with veggies.