Bake
Crispy Cheesy Pan Pizza Recipe From King Arthur Flour
Popular on Food52
277 Reviews
Margaret D.
May 9, 2024
This recipe is 100% genius. What I’ve learned: weigh the flour! It makes a huge difference. When I really want to impress someone or spoil my adult kids, this is my go to. Thank you so much for making me look like an awesome chef.
CindyB
February 7, 2024
This. Is. So. GOOD! We make it in our cast iron skillet. Again, if you haven't tried this recipe, you really, really, really need to. :)
Regine
February 3, 2024
Such a wonderful recipe. I doubled it and used one 10 inch and one 11-12 inch cast iron pan. Baked each for 18 minutes at 450. I left dough in refrigerator for 3 days.
Marlahrd
May 14, 2023
Way too much dough for a Chicago deep dish pizza. I prefer the NYT modified version. I was embarrassed st the quality when serving this version.
Smaug
May 14, 2023
???? This isn't a Chicago deep dish pizza. It's a Detroit pizza. Entirely different thing.
Jo
February 7, 2024
It was King Arthur’s recipe of the year and one of its most popular. It’s not necessarily the recipes fault if you don’t like what you cook/bake. I speak from experience.
jcinnb
April 23, 2023
This recipe is GREAT. I have an outdoor pizza oven and until recently struggled mightily with dough. I have now found the holy grail of dough recipes. So . . .I was hesitant to try this, since it involved a different dough recipe, but I did.
Results were perfect.
I let the dough rise for 48 hrs +. When it came time to put the dough in the skillet, I took a deep breath, and . . . it worked. Dough spread just right. Cooked the pizza at 450 for 19 minutes. Looked good. Lifted (easily and no mess) off the skillet to take a peek and bottom was perfect. Then proceeded to lift the pizza out, using two spatulas, and it came out in one piece! Skillet was near spotless, too.
The crust was thick, soft, and excellent. Perhaps for the first time, ever, the crust was more than just something to hold the ingredients. It tasted as good as it looked.
This recipe takes little time, but it was 100% worth it. I encourage anyone trying this to PLAN AHEAD and let dough rise for at least 8 hours. Good luck!
Results were perfect.
I let the dough rise for 48 hrs +. When it came time to put the dough in the skillet, I took a deep breath, and . . . it worked. Dough spread just right. Cooked the pizza at 450 for 19 minutes. Looked good. Lifted (easily and no mess) off the skillet to take a peek and bottom was perfect. Then proceeded to lift the pizza out, using two spatulas, and it came out in one piece! Skillet was near spotless, too.
The crust was thick, soft, and excellent. Perhaps for the first time, ever, the crust was more than just something to hold the ingredients. It tasted as good as it looked.
This recipe takes little time, but it was 100% worth it. I encourage anyone trying this to PLAN AHEAD and let dough rise for at least 8 hours. Good luck!
mbobden
April 23, 2023
what kind of skillet/pan did you use and did you oil it first? I've had sticking issues with my cast lodge cast iron pan and other comments have had sticking issues while others have had results like yours! I love this recipe, just have to improve my sticking problem!
Smaug
April 23, 2023
Most serious pizza makers do give their dough (for whatever style) a good refrigerator rest. Overnight is most common, but the folks at Serious Eats did some tests and came to the conclusion that a longer rest gave the best results. I think they came up with something like 3 or 4 days as optimum. I do sometimes wait 2 or 3 days- results are pretty subjective and side by side comparisons difficult, but I do feel like it helps some.
jcinnb
April 23, 2023
An ancient, but well seasoned Lodge cast iron skillet. I did oil the skillet before cooking, wiped dry, then when dough was ready, followed recipe. I was astounded at how easy it turned out to get pizza out of skillet.
cookbabycook
January 6, 2023
Definite keeper! I've made this many times, in a cast iron le Creuset pan and in brownie pans when multiplying the recipe. I used a little pre-cooked/drained Italian sausage and Pastorelli pizza sauce. The cheese crust was fabulous!
Charles
May 2, 2022
I've made this before, following the recipe, as written (except we add other toppings in addition to cheese and sauce), with very good results. This morning, we decided we wanted pizza tonight - not enough time to refrigerate the dough 12 to 72 hours. Several reviewers described their "shortcut" versions and I decided to try it. So, when I reached the step where the dough is to be refrigerated, I covered the bowl and put it back in my unheated oven (my "proofing safe") for about 6½ hours. I also used my 12 inch cast iron skillet instead of the 10-incher like others reported having done successfully. The usual assorted toppings - baked for 18 minutes on the bottom shelf - and we had a terrific pizza! Thinner than the real deep dish the recipe (and 10 inch skillet) make; this what I would describe as a thick pan pizza. So now we have two ways to approach this recipe - both good.
gollygwhiz
March 17, 2022
This recipe is so good, I have to make it almost every week. I don't have a 10 inch skillet, but my 12 inch cast iron skillet does work with the recipe as written. The crust may be a bit thinner, but it's still substantial and delicious.
Smaug
April 6, 2022
To get it in proportion, you could increase the recipe by 50% (44% if you're fond of arithmetic).
JCrys
January 5, 2022
Finally tried this pizza and it is now my favorite! I have tried many different dough recipes and this one is so easy (though you do need to plan ahead). I loved the crispy bottom, soft middle, and crispy cheese edges. One word of caution though, give it time to cool down after coming out of the oven, otherwise you will burn your mouth with molten sauce.
Jackie
November 12, 2021
Oh I love this recipe! I use different cheeses(grate my own) and different toppings all the time. Always comes out great. I sometimes leave the dough in the refrigerator for up to three days, and all is good. I also love Kristen’s videos at her apartment with her hubby and sweet daughter at her side. I am a big food 52 fan! Thanks for all you guys do for us and share with us!
jessf
September 24, 2021
I have some fresh mozzarella that I need to use. I think I will do the low moisture mozz on the bottom layer but then do some fresh mozz on top. Has anyone tried this? I know there’s a sog risk, I’m thinking I will try to drain the fresh mozz as much as possible on paper towels before putting in the pizza. Any thoughts or suggestions?
HalfPint
October 19, 2021
I think if you pat dry the fresh mozzarella, there should not be much sogginess. From personal experience, fresh mozzarella gets rubbery when cooked. I am told that if the mozzarella is very fresh, this isn't an issue. How fresh? I just don't know.
rosecedar
March 12, 2021
I have made this many times over the past year and it's become one of my favorite recipes of all time. I agree with others that it's very different from Neapolitan pizza and New York style pizza. But it's very much like a street food pizza found all over Rome, which is made in large slabs and sold by the slice for takeaway ("porta la via").
For those who have problems with sticking to the pan, try lightly greasing with Earth Balance or butter the bottom and halfway up the sides of your pan, and putting a small (about half the diameter) parchment circle on the bottom of the pan. Also, make sure when smooshing out the dough that you don't squish all the oil to the sides or over the top of the dough. When I do these things, my pizza slips out effortlessly.
For those who have problems with sticking to the pan, try lightly greasing with Earth Balance or butter the bottom and halfway up the sides of your pan, and putting a small (about half the diameter) parchment circle on the bottom of the pan. Also, make sure when smooshing out the dough that you don't squish all the oil to the sides or over the top of the dough. When I do these things, my pizza slips out effortlessly.
Smaug
March 12, 2021
The pizza you refer to is known as Pizza al Taglio (roughly pizza by the slice)- there was recently a recipe by Mauritzio Leo on this site for a sourdough version (sorry, it's early and that's apparently the best sentence I can come up with). This pizza (Detroit style) is apparently a fad now, with restaurants popping up etc.
Nira E.
February 14, 2021
Hey looks great. I'd love to try it out. I loved the clip :-) I don't have this pan you are using ,and no King Arthur here , but I guess white plain flour will do. Thanks.
Smaug
February 14, 2021
If possible you should probably use bread flour- King Arthur's all purpose flour is really very similar to a bread flour, with a high gluten content and malted barley flour included.
Deb
February 4, 2021
My dough never got really soft and pillowy prior to baking it almost had a slight hard crust on top. It still tasted great and cooked well but just wondering if anyone has any thoughts and why this happened?
Sandy C.
February 12, 2021
The first time I made the dough this was the case, but I read in the comments that I needed to add a little more water. It tasted great though when baked. I made the dough again tonight and it was better, but I added a few more drops of water anyway and it was soft and pillowy.
Lauren
January 30, 2021
Does anyone have a good sauce recipe for this particular pan pizza? I used my usual go-to, Jim Lahey’s no-cook tomato sauce, but it just wasn’t right here.
PG T.
January 30, 2021
Jarred Rao's tomato sauce is what I use. I think it works great with this recipe.
Smaug
January 30, 2021
I can report that it needs to be pretty thin. I tried it with my usual pizza sauce, which is quite thick (I don't like soggy crusts) and it pretty much stayed where I put it rather than spreading around.
Rebecca K.
February 13, 2021
I use this one; I just plop maybe 5 spoonfuls around the pizza after the first layer of cheese, then top with the rest. Any leftovers freeze great for the next time. https://joyfoodsunshine.com/easy-homemade-pizza-sauce-recipe/#wprm-recipe-container-8674
rosecedar
March 11, 2021
I sometimes use Rao's jarred sauce and sometimes the pizza sauce from the refrigerator section at Trader Joe's. Both delicious!
cookbabycook
January 6, 2023
Absolutely - use Pastorelli's pizza sauce. I've used it for 30 years. It's made locally in Chicago and tastes great, tomatoey and a bit tangy - and we're picky about pizza here in Chicago! I just use a little less on this (excellent!) King Arthur recipe than I do when making thin crust. You can but it in most grocery stores here, even on Amazon, or directly from Pastorelli: https://pastorelli.com/product/italian-chef-pizza-sauce-14oz-jars/
Lauren
January 30, 2021
Does anyone have a good sauce recipe for this particular pan pizza? I used my usual go-to, Jim Lahey’s no-cook tomato sauce, but it just wasn’t right here.
Smaug
January 23, 2021
I tried the cast iron method with the dough from Mauritzio Leo's "Sourdough Pizza Romano" dough from this site (1/2 recipe for a 10" skillet) and my own baking method (parbake 12 min. on lowest shelf for 12 min., add toppings and cook 4-5 min. until cheese is mostly browned, 1 min under broiler). I don't know what you'd call the result, but it was really good.
Smaug
January 23, 2021
Tried the cast iron method with Mauritzio Leo's "Sour Pizza Romano" dough recipe from this site (1/2 recipe for 10" skillet) and my own baking method (parbake 12 min. on bottom shelf at 500 deg., add toppings and cook+ 4/5 minutes until the cheese is mostly brown, then 1 min under the broiler.) Don't know exactly what you'd call the result, but it was really good.
danute
January 17, 2021
1. The pizza was delicious ,even though though the crust had gotten hard in the fridge overnight. (see my comment 1/12).
2. Has anyone tried making breadsticks with the dough. I think they would be delicious. Going to do that next.
2. Has anyone tried making breadsticks with the dough. I think they would be delicious. Going to do that next.
See what other Food52ers are saying.