I purchased the Modern Toilet Paper Holder (in black) and was thrilled with it. Functional as well as good looking, plus it fit a tight space. I liked it so much that I bought a white one for our other bathroom. The white one, although equally functional and the same size, is much flimsier. When I stood the two side-by-side, the black metal one is more substantial. The white metal is thinner. If I'd purchased the white one first I would not have bought another one. The white wobbles and leans somewhat to the side. The black is solid.

I purchased the black holder - it works great and is solid. I liked it so much I bought a white one for our other bathroom. The white one is of a less-substantial metal, it's flimsy and leans to the side. It's quite wobbly. I would definitely recommend the black Modern Toilet Paper Stand, but not the white.

This one is also a loser like the coasters. It is flimsy and my I iPhone plus doesn't fit in the tray. It'll do. I can't be bothered to return it an pay for the shipping.