What to CookPantry

Strange but Good: Mayo, Mayo Not

3 Save

If you like it, save it!

Save and organize all of the stuff you love in one place.

Got it!

If you like something…

Click the heart, it's called favoriting. Favorite the stuff you like.

Got it!

On this episode of Strange but Good, we investigate the weird, wonderful emulsification that is mayonnaise.


Potatoes, eggs, chicken, tuna, and coleslaw can all agree: Mayonnaise is a great uniter, bringing together otherwise disparate, possibly dry ingredients into something new and pleasantly mushy (and it also serves as a simple dip for everything from French fries to crudités). We asked the Hotline and our team: How are you eating (that is, what are you using as a vehicle for) mayonnaise?

  • Spoon it onto a baked potato. HalfPint adds black olives and pepperoncinis.
  • Moisten fish or meat with it like Susan W does: Just spread a thin layer on before grilling.
  • Or marinate your fish or meat in it for super moist grilled or baked meats. Adding spices to the mayo to make a sort of wet rub is highly recommended, as is a crispy nut or breadcrumb crust.
  • "Butter" your bread with it, especially when making a grilled cheese à la Gabrielle Hamilton.
  • Sub it for butter or oil in cakesNancy says it makes for a tender crumb.
  • Doctor it with ketchup, Sriracha, lemon juice, garlic, furikake, or paprika (or all of the above). Use it as a dip for vegetables like cv, roasted chicken like Hillary Reeves, or French fries like Riddley.
  • Spread a requisite layer onto BLTs. Or burgers. Or tomato sandwiches.
  • Eat it straight from the jar, like Hillary Reeves did as a kid. (Hey, don't knock it until you try it.)

How do you eat (or not eat) mayo? We're all ears.

Automagic Spring Menu Maker!
Automagic Spring Menu Maker!

Tags: Mayonnaise, Tips & Techniques, Food52 Life, Lists, Advice