This Strawberry Shortcake is Made of Grilled Doughnuts

July 15, 2016

Smoke has always been a signal of impending disaster in the sweet kitchen. The smell might trigger images of burnt cookies, dark and crispy cakes, and brownies turned to ash. I’ll be honest, the battery in my kitchen’s smoke detector died a long time ago and I haven’t fixed it—because I burn a lot of things.

Very-much-on-purpose grilled doughnuts. Photo by Sarah Coates

And some of time it’s on purpose. It turns out that smoke and sweet are actually natural partners. Savory cooks know this, of course: sweet and smoky ribs, chicken, brisket, pulled pork, charred vegetables, you name it. The bitterness of wood smoke is absolutely delicious when paired with something sweet.

The combination has been creeping in under the radar in the pastry kitchen for generations. The term "brûlée" means burnt, and the contrast between the bitter-burnt caramel and the creamy-sweet custard of a classic crème brûlée is the apotheosis of smoky-sweet desserts—and that recipe is from the 1600s. Similarly, the smoky undertones of whiskey, a product of the way that barley is dried over a peat fire, enhances its sweetness. The same is true of Indian black cardamom and Lapsang Souchong tea, both of which are also dried over fire.

But the most simple desserts of summer often feature the scent of smoke, too. Think burnt marshmallows smushed between two graham crackers and eaten by the fire. Or the char of a peach cooked on the grill and served with a melting scoop of vanilla ice cream. It's the campfire or grill that are the most familiar sources of that smoky-sweet combo, and that’s why the flavor can inspire such nostalgia. And I'd say that it's the general trend towards nostalgia in desserts—towards reinventing classic childhood favorites in the dessert kitchen—that has led to the use of smoke as a flavor accent more and more frequently.

Shop the Story

Smoked vanilla ice cream was a favorite with the judges on a recent episode on Australian MasterChef. In her book Simply Nigella, Ms. Lawson herself features a smoky caramel sauce, which she drizzles over a five-spice ginger Bundt cake. Portland ice cream geniuses Salt and Straw scoop a smoked cherry and bone marrow ice cream, and one of the most classic flavors from Jeni’s Splendid ice creams is "Gravel Road," a combination of salted caramel and smoked almonds. Aussie chef Gregory Llewellyn shares his recipe for smoked maple syrup, served at the famous Sydney institution Hartsyard, in his book Fried Chicken and Friends.

Truly this is a trans-Pacific trend.

A very good reason to buy an extra doughnut or three. Photo by Sarah Coates

To take advantage of the bitter-but-rounded notes that only smoke can bring and the abundance of beautiful fresh fruit that is available at this time of year (strawberries are a winter crop here in Queensland, Australia), I did the logical thing and threw a doughnut on the grill.

The results? Unmitigated success.

The doughnuts take on a crisp, brûléed shell of burnt sugar, and even these two-day-old specimens were brought back to stunning life. Add to that some bursting sweet strawberries tossed with a little sugar and a dollop of rich, unsweetened whipped cream and with as little effort as that, sweet-smokiness is yours to savor.

Order Now

Any Night Grilling is your guide to becoming a charcoal champion (or getting in your grill-pan groove), any night of the week. With over 60 ways to fire up dinner—no long marinades or low-and-slow cook times in sight—this book is your go-to for freshly grilled meals in a flash.

Order Now

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

Sarah is the author and photographer behind The Sugar Hit, a blog solely devoted to the joys of eating. She is a typical 21st century creative type, totally obsessed with food, writing, design, photography and styling. She lives in Brisbane, Australia and regularly eats mountains of crudités in a misguided attempt to offset the staggering amounts of butter she consumes daily.

1 Comment

Antonia A. July 28, 2016
This recipe reminds me of college—when we'd split, butter and broil stale donuts (especially cake-style donuts) in the world's smallest toaster oven and slather them with strawberry jam. (Try it! It still is a comfort food hit in my house.)