Vintage cakes are regularly a little strange by modern standards: Rations on things like eggs, butter, and coffee forced bakers to be creative, and resulted in cake recipes full of things like tomato soup, or made tender with vinegar, or full of mayonnaise. And in many cases, the "substitute" recipe, the one intended for filling the void during hard times, stuck—like this one, a Depression-era cake from The Short Stack Cookbook by Nick Fauchald, Kaitlyn Goalen, and the contributors of Short Stack Editions.
Shop the Story
You'll notice that it has no eggs, only 3/4 cup of brown sugar, 4 tablespoons of butter (in the icing only), and chicory instead of coffee. As the recipe's headnote says:
"Cooks got creative to make ersatz versions of their favorite dishes. Store-bought mayonnaise suddenly had newfound value in baking as a substitute for eggs. Although we no longer need to use mayonnaise as a placeholder, this cake is an instance in which the understudy outperforms the lead. Not only does mayonnaise add the richness and leavening, but the oil in its makeup also acts as the fat that brings the batter together. Chicory is another nod to the days of rationing; it was used as a substitute for coffee, except in New Orleans where, in many kitchens, it’s still preferred over coffee."
See what other Food52 readers are saying.