The Unexpected Pickle Recipes That Wowed our Cofounders in London

October 11, 2016

We kinda thought pickles had crested and begun their descent. But it turns out we were wrong—at least outside of the U.S.: During a 48-hour stopover in London recently, we were delighted by two separate (and unexpected) pickle variations, at two different restaurants.

Upon returning home, we did our research: Merrill dug up the recipe for the pickle she'd tried, while Amanda attempted to recreate hers at home. Here's what we found:

Rawduck's Lime Pickles, served with sharp cheddar on a crumpet (or here, an English muffin!) Photo by James Ransom

Merrill, on a curious breakfast pickle:

Our first pickle encounter was at Rawduck, a hip, casual spot in Hackney that struck us as a more scruffy and slightly brasher transatlantic cousin of LA's Sqirl. Pickles and ferments dominate the first two sections of the menu, and as we were led to our seats we walked past a long bar littered with large jars of drinking vinegars, kombucha and various pickled things.

Shop the Story

We were there for brunch, so we ordered large platters of eggs. I got an almond milk cappuccino and Amanda went for a blackberry kefir water. We only hesitated briefly before tacking on a dish described as "hot crumpets, westcombe cheddar & lime pickle." I imagined the lime pickle as a riff on Branston pickle, a sticky-sweet and tangy foil for the sharp and salty cheese, but what arrived was this:

Crum-diddly-umpets with sharp cheddar and lime pickle @raw_duck. Toss-up between this and the harissa eggs. #f52abroad

A photo posted by Merrill Stubbs Dorman (@merrillstubbs) on

Little doubt where we got our styling inspiration. (Thanks, Rawduck!)

The lime pickle evoked preserved lemons far more than the chutney-like condiment I'd been anticipating. The limes were unpeeled and sliced lengthwise into quarters, fragrant with mustard, and fenugreek, and tinged saffron with turmeric. There was a hint of sugar, but they were more savory than sweet, with a cayenne-induced blush of heat.

Join The Conversation

Top Comment:
“And it implies several other options of milk and carbs...) I want to try it with goat cheese and sourdough bagels now.”
— Natalie R.

Instead of the oafish, unsophisticated third wheel that Branston pickle can be when it's paired with bread and cheese, the lime pickle managed to outshine the homemade crumpets (perfectly squishy) and cheddar (bracing and crumbly).

In their new book, the Ducksoup Cookbook: The Wisdom of Simple Cooking (due out in the US next spring), Rawduck owners Claire Lattin and Tom Hill aptly describe the pickle as "a good little number to get your taste buds into gear." Here's the recipe:

Amanda, on the classic burger sidekick with a twist:

We came upon our second pickle at Lyle's, a restaurant in Shoreditch that changes its menu every night—so if you go there, you probably won't find this pickle on your plates. Served with grilled aged beef, it was charred on the edges as if it had dropped into the coals and been salvaged in the nick of time. We never would have thought to grill a pickle, but a light char adds character and edginess. I was given the taxing assignment of testing and developing this recipe. Here goes:

  • Heat your broiler.
  • Remove a thin pickle from a jar. (I used a mini dill pickle.)
  • Pat it dry with a paper towel.
  • Put the pickle on a sizzle pan or other sturdy, oven-safe dish.
  • Set the pan under the broiler and don't touch it until the pickle chars. Mine took about 5 minutes. I turned it once.

You will feel weird and like a fraud, until you taste it. Enjoy with steak, sausages, and chops of all kind.

Love pickles? Hate them? Tell us in the comments below!

Order now

A New Way to Dinner, co-authored by Food52's founders Amanda Hesser and Merrill Stubbs, is an indispensable playbook for stress-free meal-planning (hint: cook foundational dishes on the weekend and mix and match ‘em through the week).

Order now

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Natalie R.
    Natalie R.
  • Sophia Henkel
    Sophia Henkel
  • Prathima
  • kath1
  • Ali Slagle
    Ali Slagle
Food52 (we cook 52 weeks a year, get it?) is a food and home brand, here to help you eat thoughtfully and live joyfully.


Natalie R. October 11, 2016
My teammate (from Southern India) and I were talking about these today, oddly enough. My mom makes them with diced lemons and a neutral oil, while my teammate grew up with them. I was told that the typical way to eat them is with yogurt and rice. Cheddar and English Muffins are other takes on the same thing, wouldn't you say? I didn't think of the combination either, but it makes sense! (And it implies several other options of milk and carbs...) I want to try it with goat cheese and sourdough bagels now.
Sophia H. October 11, 2016
I thought mustard oil was illegal in the us, as it is considered poisonous, (insert eyeroll) do you have a source?
Ali S. October 11, 2016
Hi Sophia: You can find mustard oil on Amazon and likely in South Asian stores. Stores can sell if it they label it "for external use only." See more about that here:

We also made the pickle with olive oil and it worked on just fine, considering that there are a lot of spices that keep the pickle quite exciting. Hope this helps.
Prathima October 11, 2016
Hmm, yeah, this is a pretty typical (southern?) Indian pickle. I never thought of having it with cheddar and English muffins! Love the spin!
kath1 October 11, 2016
Lime pickle Patak brand is in UK supermarkets. I like it on toast but have never thought of making it.