Long Reads
The Surprisingly Little-Known History of White Rice in Korea
How Japan had everything to do with the most important ingredient in Korean cuisine today.
Photo by Bobbi Lin
Join The Sandwich Universe co-hosts (and longtime BFFs) Molly Baz and Declan Bond as they dive deep into beloved, iconic sandwiches.
Listen NowPopular on Food52
59 Comments
Lee D.
May 2, 2024
In 1997 I worked for EPIK in Cheongsong as an assistant English teacher during the IMF crisis; at that time because the super-highway was not built it took 1.5 hours to reach town from Andong, and thus it was rather isolated especially in the winter. There was a wooden rice mill in town that worked, creating a huge racket, but one could buy fine white rice at the local bank rice store. My relationship with rice, having come from California was not unknowing yet after living in Korea then, and later in 2009-2012 I grew to relish the legacy of the Japanese influence on agriculture, though little else about that period from 1910 to 1945 that few Americans know about unless they have contact with Koreans who emigrated here. In any case, I appreciated your paen to rice, especially Korean rice. In the Sacramento Valley, in Woodland, there is a Japanese-Korean variety of long-grain sticky rice that is quite nice milled by the Bunge Mills.
Dakini R.
March 29, 2019
Thank you for this beautiful article. Food culture is such a big part of our lives. It's important we learn this kind of history. It is sad but it heals.
Susan M.
March 24, 2019
Loved your article- The Surprisingly Little-Known History of White Rice in Korea
Made me appreciate many things and really brought to my attention how traditions are so important to feel connected in life.
Brought fond memories to me as I read- Today, years after my grandmother has passed, I pop open my own rice cooker, a Zojirushi-brand Japanese model, and fluff the steaming white kernels. Once the meal is done, I look down at my bowl and see a few stragglers, clinging to leftover sauce, and pour a bit of water in.- and I was born on a farm in Michigan, USA!
Truly got so much out of your article on sooooo many levels!
Thank you again!
Made me appreciate many things and really brought to my attention how traditions are so important to feel connected in life.
Brought fond memories to me as I read- Today, years after my grandmother has passed, I pop open my own rice cooker, a Zojirushi-brand Japanese model, and fluff the steaming white kernels. Once the meal is done, I look down at my bowl and see a few stragglers, clinging to leftover sauce, and pour a bit of water in.- and I was born on a farm in Michigan, USA!
Truly got so much out of your article on sooooo many levels!
Thank you again!
Jennie L.
March 24, 2019
Fascinating article on one of our most treasured food staples. One error in the article is the use of the term genetic engineering to describe hybridization. The correct term would be genetic modification as the former implies the use of biotechnology.
Eric F.
March 24, 2019
Hybridization is as old as agriculture. Genetic modification is new, and it is dangerous -- usually done these days to turn a crop into a pesticide, or to make ti withstand the application of a pesticide.
william
March 21, 2019
Enjoyed reading your article, well written, informative and makes me want to be more discriminating on selection of rice... keep up the good work and don't mind the cerebral feedback about genetic engineering - it's rice.
Eph
March 21, 2019
I am happy for the author that he has stated very simple facts that are inherent to any Korean family to the great approbation of those unaware of its culture or the fact that you can boil rice stuck on a bowl to create a specifically named tea instead of scouring or scrubbing it. However, if you are going to mention rice as a symbol of the changes in democracy and movements within Korea, you might have to consider not only the ways in which Korea phased from a very difficult transitional context, to a model of parliamentary democracy, "administrative" democracy, nationalism to democratically challenged results to the current finally situation, which is still of various regional unanimities. This is different from how Japan lifted its structure from Western political structure minus its political philosophy.
I am concerned about framing the issue of mixed-rice initiatives, which reputably extreme ethnosupremacists among Koreans will take to try to promote a level of Chosun to dictatorial-era cultural isolationism and justify its many abuses towards the foreign nationals working for the country. In reality, the no-rice days were implemented in part against his dissidents from a ground level (the hometowns of the dictatorial presidents actually suffered the cruelest atrocities) and in part due to the fact that he wore sunglasses to meetings with L.B. Johnson and H. Wilson. The Taegu (Daegu) uprisings were merely against foreign influence, but a number of conceptual polarizations are reoccurring in the Korean peninsula among "liberals" who are still relatively extremely conservative, as well as the ever-present regionalities and superficial values. I have noticed from the inside that many Korean "academics" on the highest levels drill the unanimous notion that foreigners (and of course, more specifically, the US) caused the war, without any understanding of the ideological (in the worst sense) issues and the ways they affected the needs and desires of the region. This is accompanied by a lack of respect for disciplines within the humanities in general, outside of, among the youth (as we all know), an overly idealized worshipping of anything and anyone Western or "Western," or "class," often to an extreme level.
Unconditional nationalism, supremacism, and ethnocentric supremacism is in all its forms is not in reality or constructive application, true patriotism nor cultural pride. In the same way, idealized worshipping of Western influences does not prevent the persecution of people for their diversity and this has already been cases of serious international ethical concern. Not to mention, the promulgation of cultural isolationism contributed directly to the Japanese Invasion, as well as many other fascist presidents within the nation unmentioned in the above article. Also, the actual capitalist president was Lee Myung Bak and we're all glad he has not agreed to mix bovine encepalopathy into your meal (despite the well-known legend that Korean beef soup was made by a king who tried to feed his town with one cow). The article also neglects to mention individuals such as Chang Myon, the president who was backed by students who went on widespread movements and extreme hunger strikes for liberal changes.
By the way, many Asian elderly have ㄱ-backs from malnutrition due to overly obsessive adherence to notions of "traditions" or otherwise externally imposed brainwash, which are not healthy to them. For instance, although having been a victim of famine as much as Korea, Irish people know not to eat potatoes and only potatoes and nothing else, although Korea was not even allowed to eat kimchi or anything native to its culture. Let's not talk about what happened to the native Korean curly haired sheepdog or how there are some harebrained notions that curly haired people are cruelly minded. It is also probably not a great idea to consider the actions one performed in one's greatest levels of hunger and desperation a point of pride or "culture (for instance, to the point of dog meat becoming a delicacy of "special health benefits" and considering dog owners touched by insanity, btw, let's not talk about Puritanical witch trials, the religious cults in the country, or the color black, cats and how Asians view them, how the black plague was not spread by rats, but people... meanwhile congratulations that Disney made sure everyone thinks the world's best archers are Irish ~lol~)." It is a sign of Asian class to be blind in some ways but the misapplication of classist obsessions and fascist tendencies have generally turned Koreans to tend towards superficiality, unanimity, and ignorance,... Although they are were traditionally the white garbed people, unduly innocent, perseverent, etc.
The greater danger of those who find it a sport and a strength to f- with people abusing and becoming very rich off a prison of manipulativeness, ires and greed, of which is often society anyhow. Oh, there is also the history of how tech companies actually became what they are, and no I do not admire the terrible people who gained by gleaning others' work and ideas (and it is a logical fallacy to say that one stereotype or person represents all businesspeople or those with money, status, or power), and am worried about the Damien Hirst - towards - Stuckist salon problem happening to the place I am in now, or towards myself...
Although at the end of the day, anything does with the best of intentions often ends up with nothing but hopefully your motherlike ability to be loving enough of people to be happy with others benefitting in ways you never had, the sneering crumbs of everything you have made tossed at you because in the process, those who use you have convinced themselves that they deserved to or had done more harder work than you and the question of what constitutes work is a serious issue and technically why Asia always had problems with innovation despite their biggest efforts, same reason why all the efforts and monies of the Kpop industry can never win a Grammy good job guys. And I have always fought to my great disadvantage just to see the same thing happening again and again and again with no one ever seeing or believing the real problems with what they are doing) and kicked out of the structures created by your work, by those who had never gone through what you had gone through serially unable to understand what you had gone through, with the combination psychological hindsight effect and situational difference making them unable to understand why they are prejudiced.
I have no need to clarify that I have actually understood all of the points and insinuations and concerns within this very well-written and well researched article, which are all elaborated upon and otherwise by the rest of the comments.
I do not have many grandparents left either, for very different reasons.
I am concerned about framing the issue of mixed-rice initiatives, which reputably extreme ethnosupremacists among Koreans will take to try to promote a level of Chosun to dictatorial-era cultural isolationism and justify its many abuses towards the foreign nationals working for the country. In reality, the no-rice days were implemented in part against his dissidents from a ground level (the hometowns of the dictatorial presidents actually suffered the cruelest atrocities) and in part due to the fact that he wore sunglasses to meetings with L.B. Johnson and H. Wilson. The Taegu (Daegu) uprisings were merely against foreign influence, but a number of conceptual polarizations are reoccurring in the Korean peninsula among "liberals" who are still relatively extremely conservative, as well as the ever-present regionalities and superficial values. I have noticed from the inside that many Korean "academics" on the highest levels drill the unanimous notion that foreigners (and of course, more specifically, the US) caused the war, without any understanding of the ideological (in the worst sense) issues and the ways they affected the needs and desires of the region. This is accompanied by a lack of respect for disciplines within the humanities in general, outside of, among the youth (as we all know), an overly idealized worshipping of anything and anyone Western or "Western," or "class," often to an extreme level.
Unconditional nationalism, supremacism, and ethnocentric supremacism is in all its forms is not in reality or constructive application, true patriotism nor cultural pride. In the same way, idealized worshipping of Western influences does not prevent the persecution of people for their diversity and this has already been cases of serious international ethical concern. Not to mention, the promulgation of cultural isolationism contributed directly to the Japanese Invasion, as well as many other fascist presidents within the nation unmentioned in the above article. Also, the actual capitalist president was Lee Myung Bak and we're all glad he has not agreed to mix bovine encepalopathy into your meal (despite the well-known legend that Korean beef soup was made by a king who tried to feed his town with one cow). The article also neglects to mention individuals such as Chang Myon, the president who was backed by students who went on widespread movements and extreme hunger strikes for liberal changes.
By the way, many Asian elderly have ㄱ-backs from malnutrition due to overly obsessive adherence to notions of "traditions" or otherwise externally imposed brainwash, which are not healthy to them. For instance, although having been a victim of famine as much as Korea, Irish people know not to eat potatoes and only potatoes and nothing else, although Korea was not even allowed to eat kimchi or anything native to its culture. Let's not talk about what happened to the native Korean curly haired sheepdog or how there are some harebrained notions that curly haired people are cruelly minded. It is also probably not a great idea to consider the actions one performed in one's greatest levels of hunger and desperation a point of pride or "culture (for instance, to the point of dog meat becoming a delicacy of "special health benefits" and considering dog owners touched by insanity, btw, let's not talk about Puritanical witch trials, the religious cults in the country, or the color black, cats and how Asians view them, how the black plague was not spread by rats, but people... meanwhile congratulations that Disney made sure everyone thinks the world's best archers are Irish ~lol~)." It is a sign of Asian class to be blind in some ways but the misapplication of classist obsessions and fascist tendencies have generally turned Koreans to tend towards superficiality, unanimity, and ignorance,... Although they are were traditionally the white garbed people, unduly innocent, perseverent, etc.
The greater danger of those who find it a sport and a strength to f- with people abusing and becoming very rich off a prison of manipulativeness, ires and greed, of which is often society anyhow. Oh, there is also the history of how tech companies actually became what they are, and no I do not admire the terrible people who gained by gleaning others' work and ideas (and it is a logical fallacy to say that one stereotype or person represents all businesspeople or those with money, status, or power), and am worried about the Damien Hirst - towards - Stuckist salon problem happening to the place I am in now, or towards myself...
Although at the end of the day, anything does with the best of intentions often ends up with nothing but hopefully your motherlike ability to be loving enough of people to be happy with others benefitting in ways you never had, the sneering crumbs of everything you have made tossed at you because in the process, those who use you have convinced themselves that they deserved to or had done more harder work than you and the question of what constitutes work is a serious issue and technically why Asia always had problems with innovation despite their biggest efforts, same reason why all the efforts and monies of the Kpop industry can never win a Grammy good job guys. And I have always fought to my great disadvantage just to see the same thing happening again and again and again with no one ever seeing or believing the real problems with what they are doing) and kicked out of the structures created by your work, by those who had never gone through what you had gone through serially unable to understand what you had gone through, with the combination psychological hindsight effect and situational difference making them unable to understand why they are prejudiced.
I have no need to clarify that I have actually understood all of the points and insinuations and concerns within this very well-written and well researched article, which are all elaborated upon and otherwise by the rest of the comments.
I do not have many grandparents left either, for very different reasons.
Eph
March 21, 2019
Let's not also mention the logically unsound thinking combined with completely unanimous beliefs such as the institutionalization of blood type discrimination and typecasting, connecting foreigners or those of other races with diseases (which happens here in a different way towards Asians wow congrats), homophobia to a beyond ignorant level, intra-Asian bigotries, superficialities again, extraordinary amounts of sexism, misogyny with no real value from both genders, mass media that is at best disturbingly propagandistic and at worst complete shameless lies, more that I I'm not mentioning, the silencing of any viewpoints external to a specific agenda of dubious validity and at the end of the day, not being able to create genuine value for their own race outside of externally ascribed values, usually for these same reasons. I respect this article for the fact that it is fighting an issue, but then there is the way Japanese businesses "gave back" makgeolli that was ethnically Korean because they could not mass market makgeolli and luckily the real formula for it wasn't given to them or the fact that the main individual who sacked many of Korean historical sites was actually a teacher... And yes, everyone amongst the top knows that Park Chung Hee was particularly interested in history, which some have before and likely will erroneously again act viciously upon, in a leap of incredible illogicity shared by many people of any nation pointing to my knowledge of history as a sign of fascism when ... wow.
And no, I do not think it is an admirable or native trait for an Asian to find the little excuse within a potential big excuse for self justification.
I am not mentioning any of these things for myself. What I and the best members of our ethnicity have had to deal with for the combination with fascist or otherwise ignorant impositions of other ethnicities is beyond horrifying. It is not mere traits usually contextual or forcibly created or machinated in context that make a person insane, it is the inability to think in an ethnically/morally sound way, or lacking the ability for free thought, love, or understanding the many types of love that exist. Meanwhile, people there believe the intellectual laziness of what is said as excuses or loopholes (e.g. chalking every violent situation up to "insanity" when many criminals have extremely straight patterns of behavior to even forcibly sterilize or euthanize people who are at worst only harmful to themselves)... On top of that, for instance, vilifying or otherwise ostracizing left-handedness as a disability or sign of evil, or some notion of "bad luck" towards even forcing left handed people to be right handed, when genetic variability is one of the greatest future assets. And admire Trump, actually believing his Tweets to be truth, or in absence of that, fanatically believe people who do not care about them or their well being and I do not mean that other rampant "Well-Being" obsession. On the other hand, the dark hilarity of everyone agreeing with Zizek as he made a lecture at some point rampantly saying fascist things to every level and no one realizing that he was criticizing them. The Banality of Evil is a serious issue, and others still have 1980's and previous levels of knowledge, and act upon them. Meanwhile, we should all be on each other's sides and even those who believe in that have extremely serious problems of lacking either reason, understanding, or the ability to see outside their own perspectives...
Asian Americans are generally very different. I could mention everything that Asians invented on top of this, or everything that women invented on top of that, and on top of this. There is the other type of worse situation that my mere physical existence and voice is a daily battle against. Every day is End Racial Discrimination Day for most of us. Most, including myself, do not have the luxuries to be recognized for our actual abilities or be in a position within which to apply them constructively.
I do not enjoy having to clarify that the more people who can contribute to each others' survival on this doomed rock the better, or having to quote S. Hawking: "Without 'imperfections,' we would not exist."
And no, I do not think it is an admirable or native trait for an Asian to find the little excuse within a potential big excuse for self justification.
I am not mentioning any of these things for myself. What I and the best members of our ethnicity have had to deal with for the combination with fascist or otherwise ignorant impositions of other ethnicities is beyond horrifying. It is not mere traits usually contextual or forcibly created or machinated in context that make a person insane, it is the inability to think in an ethnically/morally sound way, or lacking the ability for free thought, love, or understanding the many types of love that exist. Meanwhile, people there believe the intellectual laziness of what is said as excuses or loopholes (e.g. chalking every violent situation up to "insanity" when many criminals have extremely straight patterns of behavior to even forcibly sterilize or euthanize people who are at worst only harmful to themselves)... On top of that, for instance, vilifying or otherwise ostracizing left-handedness as a disability or sign of evil, or some notion of "bad luck" towards even forcing left handed people to be right handed, when genetic variability is one of the greatest future assets. And admire Trump, actually believing his Tweets to be truth, or in absence of that, fanatically believe people who do not care about them or their well being and I do not mean that other rampant "Well-Being" obsession. On the other hand, the dark hilarity of everyone agreeing with Zizek as he made a lecture at some point rampantly saying fascist things to every level and no one realizing that he was criticizing them. The Banality of Evil is a serious issue, and others still have 1980's and previous levels of knowledge, and act upon them. Meanwhile, we should all be on each other's sides and even those who believe in that have extremely serious problems of lacking either reason, understanding, or the ability to see outside their own perspectives...
Asian Americans are generally very different. I could mention everything that Asians invented on top of this, or everything that women invented on top of that, and on top of this. There is the other type of worse situation that my mere physical existence and voice is a daily battle against. Every day is End Racial Discrimination Day for most of us. Most, including myself, do not have the luxuries to be recognized for our actual abilities or be in a position within which to apply them constructively.
I do not enjoy having to clarify that the more people who can contribute to each others' survival on this doomed rock the better, or having to quote S. Hawking: "Without 'imperfections,' we would not exist."
JCoss
March 21, 2019
Wow, that is very elaborate explanation that has nothing to do with the author's writings. The author of this article only spoke about rice, RICE.. Are you serious right now? This is FOOD52 not a soap box.
Eph
March 23, 2019
I can usually smell unnecessarily paranoid ethnosupremacism when I see it. I might be slightly damaged from having had a long span of the worst experiences of my life in that nation, and of having to deal with frankly terrible classists who do not even know class back in that country. As Sun Tzu said, appear strong when one is weak; appear weak when one is strong. Korea is a strong enough country in childhood education, let's not mention the problems with Ulsan although it is the second biggest shipbuilding economic powerhouse in the world, of course there is the former biggest flight path in the world between Seoul and Jeju, someone else would have a field day listing these wonderful facts about a lovely tiny at best perhaps comparable to a kind of Luxembourg of Asia.
One should probably also note that it was an upper class tradition to give rice to poor people in the 1960's pre-democratic era of Korea. The real class was to not be classist, nationalist, or categorize people but to even welcome the homeless and the poor, and the working people, and sometimes even work with them. Of course, giving rice to people whom despise you and poison your dog and worse.
Honestly, I gave incredible amounts to that stupid country. I was fully employed, worked very hard and was an activist, educator, and generally very well loved by certain circles, of course whom even delighted in www.freerice.com which everyone knows. However, I cannot tell you how many classists not even labor party people, have not only directly called me a prostitute, liar, cheat, criminal, homosexual, all of which are untrue beyond all reasonable to unreasonable doubt, but acted upon their imbecilic assumptions without even knowing anything about me. There is a world of good about the place as well of course it is Bad to say anything non-blindly affirming about the Greatest Country in the World so they never progress. So for instance, they create clothing that only looks good but is not genuinely warm, but you cannot say that it is not warm and that there is better technology because the Greatness of all products from that country says that you must not criticize any product from there. They also value, for instance, the act of husking piles of garlic on the street (you can microwave, tap, machine, there is every method of peeling garlic that doesn't require painstakingly hand-husking it), over the power of ideas, creativity, knowledge, or the pursuit of knowledge that is not, at best, a dry as possible rote situation (and I love to read, and have even taught speed reading). The service industry by and large are built in extremely expensive establishments that look glitzy and glamorous clearly has never even heard of electric glass washers so they wash dishes by hand with a rag that would fail any proper sanitation regulation. Let's not even talk about the sociological horror of the housing situation. If you look up "communist housing" and then look at a landscape photo of many regions of South Korea, you might notice they look not only extremely similar, but the distribution of wealth and so-called "taste" makes it so that people are paying upwards of four to twelve million dollars equivalent for an equally stupid communist-unit sized apartment with terrible, uncomfortable, insensible facilities of mere superficial glitz, but of course these kinds of places are "better" and the apex of luxury because they are called, for instance (verbatim) Richensia. You cannot even actually borrow books from any library, if you can even find a library over the sickening amount of plastic surgery clinics, meanwhile I have not had plastic surgery and get lambasted for having had it because of the precedent of my own race. I dislike the way many places are shameless copies of each other; for instance Cafe Alaska and Cafe Le Alaska or something of the sort. I am saying this in hopes that they can make things better, but then again, better in my view is very different from others' notions of happiness.
Of course no one wants to read this of course I have not harped upon the wonderful world of the community, communal talking, the language, how everyone loves to help each other out, often go way, entirely, horrifically, inappropriately, too far in their either incredible liking or extreme dislike of you, let's not talk about the horrors of fanclubs and rampant brainwash susceptibilities again, variously free spirited artists, the internal conflicts often stoked by those who cannot tell intelligence from mere pedantic snobbery, true culture, architecture, touristy issues, the sociological wonder of how stores can be clustered in one giant megaplex of identical shops without competition or any other small joys and the things that should be hidden etc. How locations in the center of the city can be built and change extremely quickly, to the point where one space is a convenience store, restaurant, beauty store, restaurant, convenience store again within one month. There seems little documentation of these. I cannot commit any heresies by divulging more secret wonders of Korean cuisine so everyone overseas knows Korea for bulgogi, Korean people running sushi restaurants (but why not, who doesn't love sushi), and David Chang who started with the tradition of Ssam before Momofuku, and Ssam is something you wrap and give to your parents traditionally etc.
One should probably also note that it was an upper class tradition to give rice to poor people in the 1960's pre-democratic era of Korea. The real class was to not be classist, nationalist, or categorize people but to even welcome the homeless and the poor, and the working people, and sometimes even work with them. Of course, giving rice to people whom despise you and poison your dog and worse.
Honestly, I gave incredible amounts to that stupid country. I was fully employed, worked very hard and was an activist, educator, and generally very well loved by certain circles, of course whom even delighted in www.freerice.com which everyone knows. However, I cannot tell you how many classists not even labor party people, have not only directly called me a prostitute, liar, cheat, criminal, homosexual, all of which are untrue beyond all reasonable to unreasonable doubt, but acted upon their imbecilic assumptions without even knowing anything about me. There is a world of good about the place as well of course it is Bad to say anything non-blindly affirming about the Greatest Country in the World so they never progress. So for instance, they create clothing that only looks good but is not genuinely warm, but you cannot say that it is not warm and that there is better technology because the Greatness of all products from that country says that you must not criticize any product from there. They also value, for instance, the act of husking piles of garlic on the street (you can microwave, tap, machine, there is every method of peeling garlic that doesn't require painstakingly hand-husking it), over the power of ideas, creativity, knowledge, or the pursuit of knowledge that is not, at best, a dry as possible rote situation (and I love to read, and have even taught speed reading). The service industry by and large are built in extremely expensive establishments that look glitzy and glamorous clearly has never even heard of electric glass washers so they wash dishes by hand with a rag that would fail any proper sanitation regulation. Let's not even talk about the sociological horror of the housing situation. If you look up "communist housing" and then look at a landscape photo of many regions of South Korea, you might notice they look not only extremely similar, but the distribution of wealth and so-called "taste" makes it so that people are paying upwards of four to twelve million dollars equivalent for an equally stupid communist-unit sized apartment with terrible, uncomfortable, insensible facilities of mere superficial glitz, but of course these kinds of places are "better" and the apex of luxury because they are called, for instance (verbatim) Richensia. You cannot even actually borrow books from any library, if you can even find a library over the sickening amount of plastic surgery clinics, meanwhile I have not had plastic surgery and get lambasted for having had it because of the precedent of my own race. I dislike the way many places are shameless copies of each other; for instance Cafe Alaska and Cafe Le Alaska or something of the sort. I am saying this in hopes that they can make things better, but then again, better in my view is very different from others' notions of happiness.
Of course no one wants to read this of course I have not harped upon the wonderful world of the community, communal talking, the language, how everyone loves to help each other out, often go way, entirely, horrifically, inappropriately, too far in their either incredible liking or extreme dislike of you, let's not talk about the horrors of fanclubs and rampant brainwash susceptibilities again, variously free spirited artists, the internal conflicts often stoked by those who cannot tell intelligence from mere pedantic snobbery, true culture, architecture, touristy issues, the sociological wonder of how stores can be clustered in one giant megaplex of identical shops without competition or any other small joys and the things that should be hidden etc. How locations in the center of the city can be built and change extremely quickly, to the point where one space is a convenience store, restaurant, beauty store, restaurant, convenience store again within one month. There seems little documentation of these. I cannot commit any heresies by divulging more secret wonders of Korean cuisine so everyone overseas knows Korea for bulgogi, Korean people running sushi restaurants (but why not, who doesn't love sushi), and David Chang who started with the tradition of Ssam before Momofuku, and Ssam is something you wrap and give to your parents traditionally etc.
Eph
March 23, 2019
I am saying this out of love, not actual hatred. I could just not care, be quiet, nod and agree, blink and smile, and let them doom themselves.
Eph
March 23, 2019
Btw, there are true thinktank analyses that they've gleaned off me, while the biggest extant problem is that, outside of the dictator and the amount of horrors that would have to happen for his regime to fall, as well as the dangers of brainwashed individuals, and the fact that the people in both sides of the country are actually societally, and mentally unprepared for the reality of a reunification. I'm not going to rehash a hard-worked lackadaisical history of Korean reunification policies.
Raining rice on the country is not going to work where there are fully autonomous weaponry systems (a very serious international human rights issue circa at least a few years ago), nor is the journalistic error that caused the fall of the Berlin Wall.
Raining rice on the country is not going to work where there are fully autonomous weaponry systems (a very serious international human rights issue circa at least a few years ago), nor is the journalistic error that caused the fall of the Berlin Wall.
Jo G.
March 21, 2019
I just finished reading the book "Island of the Sea Women" By Lisa See , it was an excellent book about Korea during WWII and it told about how much white rice meant to them.
Irene Y.
March 22, 2019
I was just talking to someone about this book last night! This is going next on my reading list for sure, thank you!
TheMason
March 20, 2019
P.S. I was fascinated and gratefully educated about rice by your article. Thank you.
TheMason
March 20, 2019
I don’t claim to be right or wrong in this, I’m just sharing my thoughts on genetic engineering/hybridization as a complete “lay person.” My background is in marketing (left brain) and when working with right brainers (science/math) they benefited and appreciated my ability to give them insight they found nearly impossible to comprehend. For instance, they could design/build the perfectly engineered mousetrap. When I’d tell them it’s iron weight and $300 cost made it useless, they’d get understandably defensive. When they’d reject adding pinstripes and flashing colour-changing LEDs, I’d get understandably defensive. Notice my use of understandability. That word didn’t appear at the start of all this though, until compromising did. Hopefully you get my point.
To me, (left brainer) I think of “genetic engineering” as a catch-all term meaning an item of nature (plant) was altered with human action. So if a human took 1/2 of rice A and glued it to 1/2 of rice B, it’s genetically engineered. The rice didn’t West Side Story and glue themselves together as rebels. Eventually? Inconclusive, but maybe, but humans hit fast forward. Deep breaths right brainers, I actually can now see the genes weren’t manipulated in scenario 1, but that’s trivial (to me) GE is a catch phrase I like and easier to say then hybridization and less chuckle-producing as plant breeding (yes, my mind goes there - and I’m 54yrs young!) So it’s compromise-time. This is a sensitive and passionate topic, obviously and deserves equally strong efforts to resolve. GO!
To me, (left brainer) I think of “genetic engineering” as a catch-all term meaning an item of nature (plant) was altered with human action. So if a human took 1/2 of rice A and glued it to 1/2 of rice B, it’s genetically engineered. The rice didn’t West Side Story and glue themselves together as rebels. Eventually? Inconclusive, but maybe, but humans hit fast forward. Deep breaths right brainers, I actually can now see the genes weren’t manipulated in scenario 1, but that’s trivial (to me) GE is a catch phrase I like and easier to say then hybridization and less chuckle-producing as plant breeding (yes, my mind goes there - and I’m 54yrs young!) So it’s compromise-time. This is a sensitive and passionate topic, obviously and deserves equally strong efforts to resolve. GO!
Steve S.
March 21, 2019
Total waste of time. I'll claim: you're wrong. GMO <> breeding, period. I'll not waste any more time on this pedantic nonsense.
Karen L.
March 22, 2019
I think the author meant, hybridization, which describes splicing two genes from different varieties from the SAME species - genes from two different rice - which occurs in nature all the time. However, Genetic Engineering (GE) or Genetically Modified Organism (GMO) is taking genes from two different SPECIES and this rarely occurs in nature and is almost always a lab controlled human experiment. So the two terms can be confusing. But this is a moot point for this article. The historical facts about rice in Korea are really fascinating nevertheless.
Nancy K.
March 20, 2019
Even growing up in the US, I grew up eating Kokuho Rice that we bought from our local Korean supermarket. I'm glad that there are more options now even with brands of rice cookers (especially enjoy having the Korean ones that plays a little tune and tells me in Korean that my rice is done and that I should mix it before scooping it out). And even to this day, I don't like eating jabgok bap. I know it's healthier but meh, I still prefer white, short-grained rice (baek-mi) mixed with a bit sweet glutinous rice (chapssal) for that extra chewiness.
Priscilla L.
March 20, 2019
Hybridization is not genetic engineering as the phrase is in use today. Pretending so is dishonest and just bad journalism.
Eric K.
March 20, 2019
Correct. The term “GE” has a lot of negative connotations and is often used to refer to more invasive manipulations. But scientifically, hybridization is a form of genetic engineering, and to pretend that it’s not is irresonsible in another way. What it comes down to, at least for me, is that we as humans don't want to admit that we’ve genetically engineered basically all forms of food, historically.
This is a conversation about language, not science.
This is a conversation about language, not science.
Steve S.
March 20, 2019
Hybridization is not engineering, it's plant breeding. It's not just about language; it's about the coordinated effort to desensitize the term by attempting to conflating "hybridization" and "genetic engineering"; they're not the same, peroid.
Eric K.
March 20, 2019
Hi Steve, I appreciate your thoughts. But you realize that this phrase is in reference to language, right?: "coordinated effort to desensitize the term by attempting to [conflate] 'hybridization' and 'genetic engineering' "
I don't mean to diminish yours and Priscilla's claims, which are totally valid. I'm just trying to leave some room for conversation.
I don't mean to diminish yours and Priscilla's claims, which are totally valid. I'm just trying to leave some room for conversation.
CAHL7
March 20, 2019
Such a great article! Thank you for writing this! I am half Korean and half European (German and Icelandic). I grew up on Korean food (I made Bibimbap last night!) and I LOVE rice more than anything. My body craves it! It must be the Korean genes in me!
Nelly
March 20, 2019
This article brought me into tears (as I am eating my white rice). I grew up in Malaysia and never knew or care to understand the story of white rice. When my mother in law moved in with us, she prefers short grain Korean rice. Now I understand why... this is a beautiful story, Irene. Thank you.
Janet
March 20, 2019
Thanks for this insightful article. I appreciate the level of detail and historical richness you've brought to the table (pun intended!)
I also appreciate how you discuss genetic engineering because it reminds us that is it the corporatized adoption of the term that raises questions, not the the history of farmer's practices. So it's important that people educate themselves about this. I don't believe you should censure yourself about this language.
I also appreciate how you discuss genetic engineering because it reminds us that is it the corporatized adoption of the term that raises questions, not the the history of farmer's practices. So it's important that people educate themselves about this. I don't believe you should censure yourself about this language.
chris
March 20, 2019
this article hit home for me. Thank you for this. I remember eating barley & white rice mixed cause white rice cost significantly more than barley in the 80s. I remember the days, when kids in class used to brag about their full white rice in their lunch boxes and now I chuckle about it cause we all know that barely has more nutritional value than white rice. Those suckers. lol
Eric K.
March 20, 2019
Man, I remember when my grandma would tell us, "Every grain of rice you don't eat, you'll have to finish in heaven." Which was really hard to do without pouring water into your bowl b/c Korean rice is so small and sticky.
Thanks for this, Irene.
Thanks for this, Irene.
JAA
March 20, 2019
Great story. I'm from JA and rice is a staple of almost every dish we create/serve. I am a rice lover myself. Thank you for sharing your excellent story.
Steve S.
March 20, 2019
They did not "genetically engineer" the bloody rice; the bred it through traditional means. Not the same thing at all.
Irene Y.
March 20, 2019
Japan hybridized rice via cross-breeding (which is genetic engineering) in 1898, and were farming with twenty varieties developed through hybridization by 1913. Def not the same as the genetic modification / GMO as we know it today though.
Steve S.
March 20, 2019
Please don't call traditional plant breeding "genetic engineering." Traditional plant breeding and genetic engineering are complately different things. The biotech industry is trying to conflate the terms to obfuscate the differences for their own purposes
TheMason
March 20, 2019
Please see my comment above. I’d say the short-attention-span general population is the driving force, not biotech. Right brainers wouldn’t be that smart. LOL. JOKING. Please don’t hack my Internet. LOL. My comment explains.
Join The Conversation