From our new podcast network, The Genius Recipe Tapes is lifelong Genius hunter Kristen Miglore’s 10-year-strong column in audio form, featuring all the uncut gems from the weekly column and video series. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts so you don’t miss out.
Listen & SubscribePopular on Food52
17 Comments
Elizabeth W.
May 14, 2018
Made this last night with a few minor modifications. Boyfriend said it was the best corned beef he had ever had. Will now be THE way to make corned beef in this household. Thanks!
dhampt
August 7, 2013
I've had traditional corned beef and cabbage (cooked correctly) my whole life. A friend sent me this recipe. I tried it, and it was layered with flavors! What a wonderful surprise! I'm still a huge fan of the traditional corned beef and cabbage (I think the sandwiches are best on pumpernickel rye), but I'll be adding this one to the rotation, with slightly less mustard. Thanks!
http://davidhamptonoflondon.wordpress.com/
http://davidhamptonoflondon.wordpress.com/
AnitaP
September 19, 2012
Leaving a message only so I can tick the "don't e-mail me" box - receiving too much spam - sorry to trouble you further than you'll already have been!
arcane54
March 24, 2012
This was amazing! I bought a 4-ound corned beef brisket, learned that the secret is PLENTY of water -- definitely 6 inches over the top. The crisping made such a difference and he parsley/mustard sauce made it brighter and added the extra bit of tang to cut the richness of the beef. A keeper -- and not just to for St. Patrick's Day (but hey, if you're Irish, every day is St. Patrick's Day, right?).
JJortega
March 21, 2012
Perfect! It was so good, I'm doing it again this weekend...much to the delight of family and friends! (And thanks to the local health food store that brined local organic beef)
Giulia M.
March 19, 2012
I made this yesterday. It was wonderful and easy. I will use this recipe for all future St. Patrick's Days. Amen.
selena
March 18, 2012
I did this yesterday - new to me was the sear (more for looks than flavor) and the sauce. I cook the veggies separately (personal preference) but I have kale growing in my yard so I harvested some and cooked it in the broth for a slow simmer. The kale had added flavor and no bitterness! It never fails to surprise me how simple and wonderful this meal is - shame we only seem to have it once a year.
AnitaP
March 17, 2012
Yum to the shorter veggie cooking times - but they must have some of that beef broth flavour! The carrots add welcome colour on the plate. I'm not such a huge fan of the "pink salt" and have had huge success with this recipe from Jun Belen's blog: http://blog.junbelen.com/2010/03/15/how-to-make-corned-beef-brisket-nitrate-free-at-home/
Only problem: there are never any leftovers for Reubens! Top of the morning to you all!
Only problem: there are never any leftovers for Reubens! Top of the morning to you all!
sboulton
March 16, 2012
I'm sorry, but the weary epicurean is a snob. I've lived in NY and had the "traditional" which was washed out and devoid of taste and everything tasted like corned beef, and now live in Los Angeles and have had Suzanne Goin's version which is filled with layered flavors and is delicious. The herbed mustard is fantastic and adds a bright note. Yes, the poor Irish made it one way out of necessity, but there is no reason we can't make it better because of what is available to us.
msitter
March 16, 2012
That is about as a St. Patrick's dinner as you can get and very special. Now, what about the rest of the meal. Irish whiskey straight or beer and whatsare the little bits to have with drinks? Is it served with Irish soda bread or no bread. And, by gosh, what do those Irish boys have for \dessert? Irish whiskey follows; we know that.
The W.
March 16, 2012
I'm going to have to demur on this recipe. The cabbage flavored with beef by boiling together with it is delicious. The carrot (not carrots!) is only meant to be in the pot to sweeten the cabbage - it's not even meant to be served, actually, in the traditional New York version of this dish. Putting mustard in your parsley sauce completely over-powers the parsley; if you prefer mustard with your corn beef and cabbage, simply serve it on the side, along with the parsley sauce, rather than mixing them to create basically mild mustard sauce. It's traditional to serve a pot of mustard with this dish by the way, just not traditional to mix them.
Boiling corned beef with cabbage, potatoes and a carrot in a pot as a St. Patrick's day meal is a practice that originated among homesick New York Irish. The purpose was comfort: the dish reminded them of home, where boiled bacon (not easily available on New York's kosher Lower East Side) with cabbage and potatoes was (and is) a common "special occasion" meal. "Spicing it up" undermines the entire purpose of the tradition. It's comparable to the practice of deep frying Thanksgiving turkeys: yes, turkeys are hard to roast without drying them out, but the entire purpose of the ritual is to show that you are a good housekeeper by demonstrating that you are able to do so. Essentially serving fried chicken instead misses the whole point.
Boiling corned beef with cabbage, potatoes and a carrot in a pot as a St. Patrick's day meal is a practice that originated among homesick New York Irish. The purpose was comfort: the dish reminded them of home, where boiled bacon (not easily available on New York's kosher Lower East Side) with cabbage and potatoes was (and is) a common "special occasion" meal. "Spicing it up" undermines the entire purpose of the tradition. It's comparable to the practice of deep frying Thanksgiving turkeys: yes, turkeys are hard to roast without drying them out, but the entire purpose of the ritual is to show that you are a good housekeeper by demonstrating that you are able to do so. Essentially serving fried chicken instead misses the whole point.
The W.
March 16, 2012
I did some googling and found this very traditional New York Irish recipe. You'll notice that the vegetables are kept from overcooking by being added at the correct times, and that the pure flavor of minced parsley is essential to the composition of the dish:
http://www.food.com/recipe/n-y-c-corned-beef-and-cabbage-15846
http://www.food.com/recipe/n-y-c-corned-beef-and-cabbage-15846
mrslarkin
March 16, 2012
I made this corned beef last year for St. Paddy's Day. It really is awesome. Didn't try the sauce, but it sounds very yummy.
Mis4
March 16, 2012
What a lovely sear on the corned beef! I think it was the dill pickle analogy that got me. We're throwing out tradition and trying this Saturday night.
See what other Food52 readers are saying.