What's best substitute for grapeseed oil? Is good olive oil an OK option?

  • Posted by: AEC
  • January 19, 2012
  • 38594 views
  • 9 Comments
The Best Breakfast Muffins
Recipe question for: The Best Breakfast Muffins

9 Comments

DailyMeals January 19, 2012
I chose grapeseed oil for a few of the reasons above. I don't really like using canola oil in general, so I keep grapeseed oil on hand because of it's high smoke point, so I chose to use it here, although you could definitely use a light olive oil too.
 
violist January 19, 2012
This link is very clear about the differences of oils and fats in general. Though it's quite technical, it's well worth deciphering, and it may give you new insights to grapeseed oil.

http://www.rense.com/general85/grapeseed.htm
 
ChefJune January 19, 2012
Many people feel that canola oil is not the healthiest choice because it is highly processed and very commercial. Grapeseed oil is also neutral in flavor and can be found as an organic product.
 
susan G. January 19, 2012
Organically grown canola oil is also available. All processed agricultural products have problems, with the probable exception of olive oil that is made by traditional methods (from a source that tells the truth).
 
pierino January 19, 2012
The biggest difference between grapeseed oil and olive oil is that grapeseed has a lower smoke point. Its main value is for frying. And yes it tastes completely different.
 
AEC January 19, 2012
Thanks! Canola oil it is. As a follow-up question, if grapeseed oil is neutral in flavor, I wonder if the reason for opting for it is nutritional? (As you can guess, I've never used it.)
 
nutcakes January 19, 2012
Grapeseed is high in monosaturates, iirc, you can google around and find the info. Although you aren't frying, it is GREAT for frying as it won't smoke at normal temps and smoking oil is extremely unhealthy. Costco sells a large container for a reasonable/affordable price, I've found.
 
hardlikearmour January 19, 2012
I'd go canola or vegetable oil. Light olive oil would probably be okay, but I'd avoid extra virgin.
 
nutcakes January 19, 2012
Grapeseed is neutral in flavor, where olive oil is strong in flavor, so a better sub is vegetable oil or canola oil. However, olive oil will work fine, as long as you don't mind the flavor in a muffin.
 
Recommended by Food52