What color should scallops be when you buy them?

Question

mainecook61 · Answer

In Maine, they tend to be off white to a light tan, particularly if they are so-called "dry" scallops with no water or additives. I would not waste my money on the sort that's plumped up with water; they don't sear properly, for one thing.

pierino · Answer

Even if you bought the scallops at Whole Foods you should expect them to be white. They've been given some extra water and are frozen and defrosted. Unless you are buying them right off the boat they are never going to be pink. One of my peeves is that many restaurants will label their scallop dishes "diver scallops" which transparently they are not. Depending on where you live you might find really fresh scallops at a pier side fish market. You definitely won't find them in say, Phoenix.

jennymcq · Answer

We bought some at a new Whole Foods today and they are white. My boyfriend thought they should be pink & I read something online that said they should never be white. Thanks for your answer
- I'm reassured!

Greenstuff · Answer

Scallops range in color.  They can be white, pink, a little bit orange.  Are you worried about some?

What color should scallops be when you buy them?

4 Comments

Popular on Food52

The Best Vanilla Extract Substitute Is Probably Hiding in Your Kitchen

11 Easy Dinner Recipes for When It's Been a Loooong Week

The 15 Best Pasta Salad Recipes to Make All Summer Long