Making pies in advance
Every year I make pies for my neighbors for Thanksgiving, this year I am making 8 pies,2 pumpkin,2 sweet potato, 2 apple and 1 pecan. Keeping a schedule is crucial for me because i also have to prepare for my Thanksgiving dinner also and it entails a lot of prep work. My questions is, can I make the pumpkin, sweet potato and apple pies the day before and refrigerate unbaked on Tuesday. I bake them all on Wednesday so they are as fresh as possible for Thursday. If I can refrigerate the unbaked pies should I cover them with plastic wrap while refrigerated? I have never done this before I always do everything on Wednesday and I am trying to keep as much of Wednesday free to make things for my dinner so I don't have to pull an all nighter like I usually do. Thanks so much!
22 Comments
http://www.kingarthurflour.com/blog/2010/12/09/freeze-the-fastest-way-to-fresh-baked-fruit-pie/
If I was not baking the Turkey and only bringing pies, i would line all the pie shells for 8 pies the day before and refrigerate them. You need oven space to make 8 pies, so you have to plan that. My convection oven is pretty good loaded up, and some people have double ovens.
You need to think about the food storage and handling of pies with eggs and cream in them like pumpkin and sweet potato. So, I think I would do this.
Bake the pecan pies the day before or that morning. You handle that in or out of the fridge as you normally would do.
Bake the pumpkin/sweet potato the day before and refrigerate it. That is the one people will notice less that it is not made the same day.
Bake the apple that day, either by the freezing methods above (the apples come out more "poached" when they have been prefrozen) or just get it all set the night before and in the frigde so you can top off the pie and bake it early. I have stirred the sliced apples with lemon juice and the rest of the stuff and kept it over night, and it came out great.
I have an aunt that bakes the pie, apple or blueberry, freezes it whole and cooked, and thaws it out the day before the holiday, and rebakes it before the meal and serves them hot. The crust is pretty good.
I usually like to bake one pie early a.m. If I am ready, I bake the other after the Turkey.
I might make pumpkin pie the night before and refrigerate it, but usually like it at room temperature made the same morning.
I sometimes find that little pecan tassies fit the bill for holidays, instead of a whole pecan pie. Sometimes we do pie tasting in the evening, and not as dessert, a few HOURS after the meal, because us here don't like the feeling of over eating, we are too old for that. We reset the table and put everything out and make a hot pot of tea and put out china cups.
Happy Thanksgiving!