In regards to chemical leavening (baking soda, powder), why can cookie doughs be made 24 hours ahead but wet batters must be baked immediatel
Cookie and biscuit dough vs pancake or cake batter. It seems a combination of acid and heat causes baking soda to react fully? Are wet batters more acidic?
Recommended by Food52
14 Comments
Of course we do this with cookie dough as well, which we now mostly leave in third pans in the walk-in, and scoop out to bake. Sometimes we roll logs to slice and bake too, especially if we're going to freeze it.
We do make cake batter in advance so long as it's not an eggwhite based cake (like a white sponge or something) and it works fine, but usually we don't and instead bake off the rest of the batter to freeze or, if we'll use it in a couple days, wrap tightly and stick in the walk-in.
I've heard about resting pancake batter: we actually don't make that ahead if time, but I can't say it would make too much of a difference...
I commonly rest cr?pe batter overnight so that not only are the proteins and starches fully hydrated, but moreover so that the proteins are relaxed, which produces cr?pes which are beautifully tender, never rubbery.
As for cakes, everyone has already pointed out why cake batter needs to be baked immediately. Crepes are rested for 30 minutes or so because it relaxes the gluten and makes for light tender crepes. They aren't supposed to be leavened and fluffy like a cake. I usually don't see an overnight rest for pancakes unless they are the yeasted kind.
Hope this helps.
I also read that baking powder/soda start reacting to liquids almost immediately which could be a reason why they should be baked pronto. That said I agree with nutcakes I have made pancake batter and refrigerated leftover batter overnight and it was fine the next day.