Once chicken is in oven, should the pot be covered or left uncovered?
Are you channeling your best self with this comment? (If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)
Monita is a Recipe Tester for Food52
Although I've never made this, I would recommend keeping the pot covered which is a typical slow roasting method
The instructions say Jamie keeps it UNcovered but the Food52 testers recommended partially covered. That's how I did it.
Thank you. I was preparing this directly from Jamie Oliver's site, and there was no mention of whether to cover or uncover. I see now that Food52's version - and the associated blog post - addresses this.
I found that I needed to uncover it to allow some of the milk to cook down.
I am thinking about making this for dinner tonight. Besides covering the pot half-way, any recommendations? I'm a little skeptical about combining milk and chicken but Jamie knows best...
I made this for the first time tonight. It was easy and delicious! I loved the flavor and consistency of the sauce…you’d never know it had milk in it.
Susan W is a trusted source on General Cooking.
Has anyone tried this with cut up chicken? Whole Foods recently had a sale on their locally raised chickens so I bought 4 and cut them all up because it was time to make stock.
Yes! I made it the other day with leg quarters only as someone else suggested. We prefer dark meat and I think it lends itself to a braise better than white meat. It worked fine!
Another thought: I think it's much easier to brown chicken pieces than it is to grown a whole chicken. I don't think the cooking method of this dish relies on an intact carcass. It will work either way.
CBC, thank you. I was hoping someone would say exactly what you said. :)
*brown - not grown
amysarah is a trusted home cook.
I did a whole chicken - worked fine, but might be a little less clutzy to brown chicken parts. I kept it mostly covered to encourage braising/sauce, but uncovered the last 20 min. or so, to thicken the sauce a little and increase browning of the un-submerged skin. Very easy, very good - served with the sauce over buttered egg noodles. Everyone was happy.
I made it (very tasty) and liked it with the lid left off. I chose a small Dutch oven that just accommodated the chicken and that left me with plenty of sauce.
I might have to try this, all this talk of chicken cooked in milk. One of my favorites growing up was ham steak topped with powdered mustard, sugar and baked in milk.
I made this last night with dark and white meat pieces. I increased the sauce ingredients by 50% and left the lid off per Jamie's original recipe. It is absolutely delicious. I had my neighbors over and everyone loved it. I served the New England Spider Cake from this site for dessert. Huge hit as well.
Your no-recipe guide.
DIY Fancy (No Recipe!) Crackers
The New Jersey Boardwalk of My Childhood
Go On, Spread Out
Make Store-Bought Hummus Better
Our Favorite Dinner Prep Tools