Could you do this without an ice cream maker? Fold in meringue to lighten and then freeze? Or would you have to do the almost freeze, stir, alm...

...ost freeze stir method

  • Posted by: Annelle
  • June 29, 2011


Kristen M. July 13, 2011
That is great news! And I'm so impressed you tried it so many ways, too -- thank you for reporting back!
Annelle July 13, 2011
Thank you for all your responses. Now I can report my test results! First of all, the recipe just as it is, is delicious, but without an ice cream machine it is a little 'icy'--still delicious. Adding the egg whites, but still no machine was lighter, but still 'icy'.
Finally, I bought the ice cream maker you suggested (love it!). Adding the egg whites AND using an ice cream machine made a beautiful creamy looking and tasting sorbet without adding the calories of cream. Bottom line: it's a fantastic recipe no matter how you make it! I also froze some popsicles which were a big hit.
Morningstar42 July 4, 2011
I tried it and love it! Tasty and used my sorbet pots
Chrissyo29 June 29, 2011
I am going to try this in my vitamix................let ya know the results :)
foodfighter June 29, 2011
I just did a similar sorbet recipe, and want to try this one. I added a splash of vodka, as I don't have an ice cream maker. Was a little more ice-y, but scopped okay. Might help out on this recipe too.
sdebrango June 29, 2011
You could try this if you don't want to invest in an ice cream maker, btw I have the same one Kristin mentioned and it works just fine and is inexpensive. When I made my recipe for lemon lime campari sorbet although I used my ice cream maker initially you could put in the freezer for a few hours until its slushy, then use your hand mixer and whip for a minute, put back in the freezer for another hour and a half or two whip again with the hand mixer and then one more time about an hour and a half later. It helps yield a light sorbet
J July 5, 2021
Are you sharing your recipe for lemon-lime Campari sorbet?? And how large of a container would you recommend?
Kristen M. June 29, 2011
The freeze-stir-freeze method should work well -- all the textured bits in there from the unstrained strawberries & lemon should help keep it from freezing into a solid, icy mass.

I haven't tried the meringue trick, but it sounds promising! Please let me know if you try it.

By the way, I've made this recipe with great success in my inexpensive ice cream maker. It's going for $36.70 on Amazon right now:
ctgal May 2, 2018
I just realized your post is from 7 years ago!! The cheapest I can buy it now is for about $57, if I drive 14 miles to pick it up tomorrow. Amazon doesn't even have a new one sold by them. They are either used or refurbished. The new one they advertise is around $110. Sighhh. I hate to spend a ton of money for something I will probably rarely use.
Recommended by Food52