Popular on Food52
9 Comments
lj
January 8, 2017
What I done in the past with apple pie, and I believe it with work in this case as well, all that "great" juice, take it out put on a pot on middle hot heat add little of scratch mix until gets tick and put it back, this way you don't lose it in the cooking process
Kristina N.
November 26, 2014
My dough turned out quite well and went for its beauty sleep in the fridge just now. To those of you whose dough turned out to be too wet, I'd recommend to chill the flour butter mixture after you've cut the butter into it. That extra step helps ensure the butter hasn't melted during the cutting process.
gwyn
April 6, 2014
my dough was also very wet. too wet to roll. i added probably 1/2 more flour. also, the directions say to cook the apples and sugar mixture 'until all of the liquid has evaporated.' although there appears to be a good amount of liquid with the apples in the photos above. i tried to find a middle ground. my fear was all that liquid would make the crust soggy. apples are cooling now--i'll guess i'll find out!
Heather H.
April 8, 2014
You want to cook the apples until most of the liquid has evaporated. Some apples are much juicier than others, so it may be a challenge to get all of the liquid to evaporate. If you have a small amount that spreads out onto the dough, that is perfectly fine. The crust will still bake up nice, and wont become really soggy. I prefer my apples a bit juicier anyways, I think it adds to a nice texture. As for the dough being a bit wet, that is normal. You can use some flour to roll it out, preventing it from sticking to surfaces. You could also try chilling the dough once it is mixed.
Cathleen
April 5, 2014
This looks to be unbelievably delicious, but so far the dough has come out extremely wet, more of a batter than the dough. It's reminding me of donut batter, is that how it's supposed to look. I added a good 1/4 cup of flour, but it remained fully spreadable. Any feedback would be appreciated.
Heather H.
April 8, 2014
Was the butter chilled when you cut it into the flour? Did you over mix the ingredients? You want to combine the wet and dry ingredients just until wet. Beside that, I really can't think of any other reasons, unless there was a too much liquid added. The dough should be a stickier, wet dough, but not spreadable or batter. Sorry, I wish I had some sort of solution.
Cathleen
April 8, 2014
I probably did over mix the ingredients, I definitely stirred the dry/wet, rather than merely combined them. My butter was definitely chilled when it was cut in, although I'm not sure how that would affect whether the dough became a batter. It looked nothing like the dough square in the picture, it really looked like spread out donut batter, which I just kept drenching with more flour. That said -- I confess that I did not cut to tiny pieces, with pie dough I usually leave a few bigger pieces so I went ahead and did that here. Meanwhile, I haven't actually had time to finish it, so it's chilling nicely. I'll report back tomorrow, hopefully!
Kate
March 28, 2014
Beautiful! And what a fun challenge for a weekend. I love the idea of eating this with cheddar cheese.
See what other Food52 readers are saying.