My recipe for chocolate syrup originates from my dissatisfaction as a chocoholic. As a chocolate-loving child, I was always confused by the recipe for hot chocolate on the back of the cocoa carton. One teaspoon of cocoa powder paired with an equal amount of sugar and one cup of milk never amounted to anything more than a mysteriously tan, slightly sweet beverage. From a very young age I thought, “More chocolate.”
I would triple the cocoa powder and add a small handful of chocolate chips for richness and body. Then, I would pour a bit of boiling water over the cocoa and sugar and stir this into a paste. Once I had the paste, I either made hot chocolate or chocolate milk, depending on the milk’s temperature.
Chocolate syrup is just one step more refined. Instead of dissolving the chocolate paste in milk, I simmer it in water until the mixture reduces into a silky sauce. I like to make the syrup in batches and stir into milk whenever I please.
Even better, the syrup itself is dairy-free, unlike hot fudge, which means that I can mix it with whole milk while my dairy-avoiding husband can mix it into almond milk. (I’ve been thinking a lot about dairy-free stuff recently: my eCookbook is all about butter-less desserts!)
In the end, chocolate syrup is incredibly simple -- it requires just one more step and one more pan than that cocoa paste -- but there are a few important tricks. First, always use at least some brown sugar -- the molasses flavor brings out the chocolate. Second, keep the chocolate-to-sugar proportion in a ration of 3:2. Third, melt in a tiny bit of chocolate (not cocoa) at the end, for richness and body. And finally, no chocolate-friendly flavor is ever unwelcome in chocolate syrup: I like to add a dash mint extract, espresso powder, or cherry liqueur.
1/2 cup water 3 tablespoons evaporated cane or granulated sugar 1 tablespoon brown sugar 6 tablespoons cocoa powder 1 teaspoon finely minced bittersweet or semi-sweet chocolate 1 teaspoon vanilla extract Tiniest pinch of salt Milk (whole or or dairy-free), for serving
Combine the water, sugars, and cocoa powder in a small saucepan over medium-high heat, stirring to dissolve.
When the mixture reaches a simmer, reduce the heat to low and simmer for 5 more minutes, stirring frequently. When the mixture is syrupy, turn off the heat and add the minced chocolate. Let it sit for another minute, then add the vanilla and salt and stir until even.
Let cool to room temperature, then stir into milk in your preferred proportion (I recommend a lot of syrup to a little bit of milk, but that’s just me).
I'm the founder, editor, and head chef at the blog Big Girls, Small Kitchen (www.biggirlssmallkitchen.com), a site dedicated to easy-to-execute recipes and stories from a quarter-life kitchen. I'm also the author of In the Small Kitchen published in 2011.