On our new weekly podcast, two friends separated by the Atlantic take questions and compare notes on everything from charcuterie trends to scone etiquette.
Listen NowPopular on Food52
22 Comments
Em
July 29, 2016
I made this. It was very good & very easy to make! Just a question, the next day my frosting became pretty hard, is there anything that can be done to stop that from happening? Thank you. PS I will make this again
Heidi -.
July 30, 2016
Hi Em! Was it stored in the fridge? Unless it's very hot outside I'd store it at room temp. I've never had the frosting go very hard, perhaps try adding a bit more warm water x
foodyjudy
September 29, 2014
And the cake was delicious anyway!! I would say it is a VERY forgiving recipe.
foodyjudy
September 27, 2014
I think I followed the directions very carefully. It puffed up in the middle. I stuck the tester in at 50 min. and it wasn't quite ready. At 60, it was. Now it's sitting on the counter cooling and it has sunken, I mean really sunken, in the middle. No way to hide it, could put a big fat candle in the middle (it's a little birthday cake), or stuff it with frosting, but it would take a LOT. Any hints as to what went wrong?
Oh, we'll eat it, no matter what..
Oh, we'll eat it, no matter what..
Heidi -.
September 27, 2014
Hi Judy, oh what a shame it sunk when it's a special birthday cake! My thoughts go to oven temperature, ensuring it was preheating properly before putting the cake it. You didn't open it too early so doubt that'd be the issue....Is your baking soda within the expiry date? I mean, overbeating CAN cause a cake to sink, & while this recipe beats the hell out of the ingredients it has never really sunken for me, only fallen a little. & I don't believe others have had a drastic sinking issue either. I should like to try this recipe mixing less vigorously & see if that changes the result but as this was the way I was taught it's felt a little sacrilegious to veer off in another direction. I should try it & see the difference, though, & perhaps if you're keen to try it again you might find that helps. Happy birthday to the cake recipient! x
Assonta W.
July 7, 2014
Made this for Sunday dinner dessert...the kids Fell. In. Love. It was just so good! So much easier than the usual one I make. I used a boiled chocolate icing which was like eating a milk/dark chocolate truffle cake! We plan on making this again and again.
Regine
July 1, 2014
Thanks Heidi. It is now in oven with 2 eggs. It is for tomorrow. I will let u know how I like it and whether I would prefer it with one more egg as I usually do with all the 2 egg chocolate cakes. Can't wait to try it. I used an 8 inch springform pan. I did not think the usual 8 inch pan (2 inch height) used for layer cakes would be big enough. Your picture seems to show a springform pan or a deeper 8 inch pan (3 inch height). Right?
Heidi -.
July 2, 2014
Oh rad!! Hope it turns out well. I think it tastes great the next day. Indeed, thanks for that, I updated the recipe to note springform cake tin & yes mine was the deeper kind x
Regine
July 1, 2014
Correction to prior post!
Heidi, I can't wait to try it. But I have one question. I see that many many chocolate cakes have less eggs than other recipes, and many of such recipes that I have tried, while really good, I find the cake a bit "crumbly" (meaning that that the cake tends to break when I hold a piece with a fork). Your recipe only has 2 eggs. Do you have this problem? Probably not, but I am tempted to increase it to 3 eggs, which I have done with other similar recipes. When I do that, cake texture does not change except for it being less "crumbly." Thanks!
Heidi, I can't wait to try it. But I have one question. I see that many many chocolate cakes have less eggs than other recipes, and many of such recipes that I have tried, while really good, I find the cake a bit "crumbly" (meaning that that the cake tends to break when I hold a piece with a fork). Your recipe only has 2 eggs. Do you have this problem? Probably not, but I am tempted to increase it to 3 eggs, which I have done with other similar recipes. When I do that, cake texture does not change except for it being less "crumbly." Thanks!
Heidi -.
July 1, 2014
Hi Regine. I totally know what you mean! I don't have this problem with this cake, though. It yields a lovely moist and light crumb which doesn't break easily. Let me know if you do try it & increase the eggs to 3, though! x
Regine
July 1, 2014
Heidi, I can't wait to try it. But I have one question. I see that many many chocolate eggs have less eggs than other recipes, and many of such recipes that I have tried, while really good, I find the cake a bit "crumbly" (meaning that that the cake tends to break when I hold a piece with a fork). Your recipe only has 2 eggs. Do you have this problem? Probably not, but I am tempted to increase it to 3 eggs, which I have done with other similar recipes. When I do that, cake texture does not change except for it being less "crumbly." Thanks!
See what other Food52 readers are saying.