Why You Should Resist the Urge to Tear into Hot Bread

November 22, 2015

In celebration of Le Pain Quotidien's 25th anniversary, and inspired by a seasonal lunch and bread-baking demo with their founder Alain Coumont, we're sharing recipes and all-year-round tips for breaking bread together.

If you're a bread baker, you dread the final direction of the recipe: Control yourself! this step admonishes. Let the bread cool completely before slicing.

Let your loaves cool—like these Le Pain Quotidien lookers—before breaking into them. 

But what's the point? Why does hot bread smell so good—taking butter so perfectly—if it's not meant to be ripped into immediately after it comes out of the oven? 

Shop the Story

It turns out that the mandate to cool bread completely is not just a cruel trick passed down from generation to generation of bakers. Allowing the bread to come to room temperature—which can take anywhere from 30 minutes for small dinner rolls to 8 hours (or more!) for bigger boules—optimizes texture and flavor, and there are several theories as to why.

1) According to The Kitchn, the starch molecules in raw bread dough begin to gelatinize (to swell as they absorb moisture) when the raw dough reaches around 150° F in the oven. After a loaf comes out of the oven and falls below this temperature, starch retrogradation takes place, meaning that the molecules shift as the water that was absorbed during the baking process is expelled and, eventually, evaporates. Starch retrogradation is what gives bread its hard, dry texture (and is the reason why reheating bread in the oven—raising its temperature back above 150° F—temporarily causes it to soften). 

As the bread is cooling, starch retrogradation is still taking place: Water continues to move outward, drying the bread and firming up the crumb. If you cut into the bread while it's still warm (that is, before this process is complete), you risk finding a doughy, gummy, and sticky texture, as the molecules are still dense and water-logged. You'll come away with squished and sticky—rather than firm and airy—slices. If you are going to rip into warm bread despite this advice, use your hands rather than a knife to avoid squashing the starch molecules.

2) When you cut into hot bread, you cause the steam to escape at a much faster rate than if you had left the loaf to emit steam slowly, at its natural pace. By releasing the steam all at once, you set yourself up for drier bread later on. 

3) Many bakers find that flavor develops as the bread cools, which is why some people leave sourdough for 6 to 8 hours before slicing it. For breads with a high percentage of rye four (upwards of 25%), cooling time is even more important for flavor development and moisture distribution. Allow these breads to cool for 24 to 48 hours, if you can.

So yes, it may be hard to resist cutting into a warm loaf of fresh bread—to watch it longingly as it cools (on a rack to avoid a soggy bottom crust!)—but you'll be rewarded with the best possible flavor and texture. 

Photos by James Ransom and Emily Vikre

In celebration of Le Pain Quotidien's 25th anniversary—and their use of fresh ingredients—we're sharing seasonal recipes and all-year-round tips for breaking bread together. 

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Karen Caponi
    Karen Caponi
  • Janet Filips
    Janet Filips
  • Alexa Clark
    Alexa Clark
  • Shelley Matheis
    Shelley Matheis
  • Niknud
I used to work at Food52. I'm probably the person who picked all of the cookie dough out of the cookie dough ice cream.


Karen C. January 2, 2021
No will power. Had to cut off a slice while still barely warm. I will try next time.
Janet F. April 9, 2020
Fascinating article. My first #stayhomestaysafe loaf is rising (my first tangle with yeast since the 1970s), and I was hoping for a warm hunk as a midafternoon work snack. I'll restrain myself for the sake of bread chemistry.
Alexa C. February 27, 2020
Sigh, sometimes I really resent well-researched articles like this.
p.s. I'm tearing it open, slathering a chunk with fresh butter, and taking the hit, this time. But next time, 2 loaves for sure!
Shelley M. November 24, 2015
Maybe bake two loaves at a time- one for cooling and one for ripping into. At least dinner rolls cool pretty fast.
Sarah J. November 24, 2015
Yep! Significantly less waiting time for smaller loaves and rolls!
Niknud November 23, 2015
I hear everything that your saying. The head, it knows but the heart, sigh.....the heart it wants what it wants. I hear you and yet....and yet I CANNOT help myself.
H I. November 22, 2015
I have been told - no more ripping into my loaves as soon as they're cool enough not to burn the roof of my mouth! :-)