Bread

17 Crusty, Chewy, Buttery Bread Recipes

Start your ovens...

November  8, 2019
Photo by James Ransom

Nothing compares to the heart-fluttering happiness of smelling fresh baked bread. Well, okay, there’s one thing: the scent of fresh-baked, from-scratch bread you’ve made.

There’s a reason baking bread is its own kind of ritual. Because homemade bread is a mix between science and magic, where simple flour, salt, and water transform into crusty-edged, fluffy-centered goodness. It’s empowering, a project that warms your home and satisfies deeply.

Whether you love pillowy focaccia, craggy soda bread, or a tangy sourdough, there’s a bread recipe waiting for you. And to prove it (eh?), we’ve combed through Food52's decade-old recipe box for our favorite bread recipes, ever.

It wasn’t easy—we focused on savory loaves and rolls (so sorry, Cinnamon Sugar Breakfast Puffs! You are still loved!). But we narrowed it down to the upper crust, the breadwinners, if you will. Give them a look, below, then break out the flour and get kneading.


Our Best Bread Recipes

1. Ima's Challah

We promise that with Rivka's instructions, you’re up for the challenge of challah braiding. The first time our test kitchen made it in 2010, it emerged from the oven grand and poofed with an airy crumb, begging to be buttered and devoured.

2. Homemade Naan

This naan is not only simple to bake, but adaptable—make it in the oven, on a pizza stone, in a cast iron skillet, or your stovetop. No matter what, it still cooks up beautifully.

3. Easy Seeded Flatbread

If yeast intimidates you, look no further than this blistered flatbread that's just as good on a weeknight as it is on a holiday. Baking soda and powder provide oomph, while lots of seeds (recipe developer Sarah Jampel likes a mix of toasted sunflower seeds, nigella seeds, sesame seeds, mustard seeds, and coriander seeds) add crunch.

4. Four-Hour Baguette

If you’re looking for a starter bread (sans starter), here’s your loaf. “This recipe is the aggressive, no-more-excuses shove that you need to start baking your own bread,” says Genius Leader Kristen Miglore. “It will only take you 4 hours of intermittent attention, and won't require a starter nor any equipment you don't already own—and it will rival your favorite bakery's.”

5. Kindred's Milk Bread

Lauded as the most addictive bread you’ll ever eat, Kindred’s Milk Bread can do it all. “It can be used as sandwich bread, French toast, burger buns, doughnuts, and more,” writes Catherine Margaret O’Donnell. “This is a bread that merges utility and taste, seamlessly.”

6. Yogurt Bread With Molasses

Hearty, healthful, moist, with just a touch of sweetness, this loaf was inspired by a recipe in Mark Bittman's How to Cook Everything Vegetarian. One very important note from recipe author Marian Bull: “Let the bread cool before you slice it. Yes, I'm serious.”

7. Saltie's Focaccia

If you're a baking novice, let us introduce to your new best friend: focaccia. It’s baking-sheet friendly, needs no kneading, and goes from oven to table like a star. We love tearing it into hunks with our hands instead of using a knife.

8. Potato Peel Focaccia

Another focaccia, this time with a smart, scrappy ingredient: potato peels. These not only add heartiness, but a delightful chewiness we can't get enough of. Plus, if you're already peeling spuds for something like mashed potatoes (hi, hello, Thanksgiving), this is a much better fate than the compost bin.

9. Alexandra Stafford's No-Knead Peasant Bread

So you want a homemade loaf with a deeply golden crust and wide-open interior crumb, but you aren't that familiar with bread recipes. Start here. This loaf uses instant yeast, which means you don't have to wait days for your reward, and once you get a hang of the method, you can adapt it to no end.

10. Life-Changing Loaf of Bread

Did we mention it's gluten-free? It is. This dense, seedy, wholesome loaf is full of good stuff like rolled oats, flax seeds, and hazelnuts (or almonds or walnuts or insert your favorite nut here). We love it with lots of butter and flaky salt, or turned into an open-faced sandwich with cream cheese and smoked fish.

11. Oaty Brown Sugar Soda Bread

This crusty, whole-grain loaf doesn't need yeast to be a showstopper (thanks, baking soda!). A Dutch oven ensures an extra-crusty crust, oats add chewiness, and a smidgen of brown sugar adds just enough sweetness. You could serve it with butter and jam for breakfast, but it's just as great alongside whatever you're serving for dinner tonight.

12. Brown Butter Butternut Rolls

Have you ever seen a more autumnal bread recipe in your life? The answer is: of course not! These butternut rolls won our Best Recipe With Brown Butter recipe contest—and you'll only need to try one to see why. Okay, go on and have another. We will, too.

13. Aunt Mariah's Rolls

These rolls are sugary and milky and buttery, yes, but that won't stop us from serving them with a super-savory spread (think roast chicken, turkey, or beef, and lots of gravy). "The recipe serves a crowd," Emily Nunn writes. "Because that's what Aunt Mariah would do with them." Do as Aunt Mariah would do.

14. Heavenly Oatmeal-Molasses Rolls

Monkeymom's supple, rich rolls have just a hint of sweetness to them—they're chewy and tender and full of deep flavor from the molasses, but versatile enough to complement (rather than overwhelm) a variety of main dishes.

15. Touch-of-Grace Biscuits

Repeat after us: No more dry biscuits. The trick here is to make a biscuit dough that seems waaay too wet. As food scientist Shirley Corriher discovered, that's actually just right. Using a low-protein, self-rising flour like White Lily makes these utterly foolproof. If you're serving them with dinner, you could stir a little black pepper into the dough and sprinkle flaky salt on top before baking.

16. Never-Fail Biscuits

And by never-fail we mean: never fail. These recipe has—wait for it—two ingredients: self-rising flour (leavening agents included) and heavy cream (which both enriches and moistens the dough). Of course, you can off-road this template to no end. Fresh herbs, like chopped dill or chives. Crispy, meaty bits, like bacon or pancetta. Or cheese. Lots of cheese.

17. Best Cornbread

Meet our test kitchen's best cornbread. It's got a crackly brown butter-scented crust and a never dry, cheerfully tangy center (thanks to both buttermilk and melted butter). If you don't have a cast-iron skillet, consider this a convenient excuse to buy one (once you start using it, we have a feeling you won't be able to stop). Like all cornbread, this is best the day it's made. Feel free to re-warm it in the oven before serving and don't skip the butter alongside.

What's your favorite bread recipe of all time? And what's your go-to bread to serve with a holiday feast? Break it out in the comments below!

Join the Conversation

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Maven53
    Maven53
  • Fran E Goudie
    Fran E Goudie
  • swimmeret
    swimmeret
  • HalfPint
    HalfPint
  • Gammy
    Gammy
Comment
Katie is a food writer and editor who loves cheesy puns and cheesy cheese.

5 Comments

Maven53 April 4, 2019
Sitting down and eating a warm slice of Ima’s challah bread. The only thing that would make it more perfect is if my Mother was here to share it with me.
 
Fran E. February 10, 2019
I love making Greek Easter Breads- Tsourekia.
 
swimmeret February 2, 2019
While the site does have English Muffins, it does not have English Muffin Toasting Bread (see King Arthur Flour) and THAT is now my favorite just in sheer terms of how often I eat it. And it's so dead easy, with a stand mixer. Fantastic peanut butter toast, and avocado toast too. Oddly enough, with a fried egg sandwich, I don't like it, I still prefer an English muffin.
 
HalfPint February 1, 2019
Not a fair question. It's like asking which is your favorite child ;)
 
Gammy January 31, 2019
Kindred’s Milk Bread.... BEST...BREAD...RECIPE...EVER!!!