CocktailsHow to CookEssential ToolsNon-Boozy DrinksTips & Techniques

A Slushie, Boozy Reason to Never Get Rid of Your Ice Cream Machine

15 Save

If you like it, save it!

Save and organize all of the stuff you love in one place.

Got it!

If you like something…

Click the heart, it's called favoriting. Favorite the stuff you like.

Got it!

I have a rule against single-use appliances in my kitchen and avoid tools that can’t perform multiple functions—I would rather improvise than give up precious kitchen real estate—but I make an exception for my ice cream maker. Recently, I discovered another use for my ice cream machine, further justifying its place in my little Brooklyn apartment: making boozy slushies, like frosé or the best ever piña colada.

Best-Ever Piña Colada
Best-Ever Piña Colada

My first ice cream maker, a pastel pink bucket made by Cuisinart, was a graduation gift from my college best friend’s parents. Having known me since high school, they understood my passion for ice cream, for the color pink (which had started ironically and transformed into a full-blown love affair), and for making things from scratch.


That summer, as I worked in a Rhode Island bicycle shop while trying to figure out what to do with my painting degree, I churned pints of ice cream twice a week. And I devoured them too, without adding an inch to my waistline because I was bike racing almost as often as I was plugging in the ice cream machine. There was burnt caramel and spicy chocolate, coffee with chunks of toffee, fresh mint, and a costly failed attempt at Champagne saffron sorbet from one of my fancy cookbooks. Ice cream was a priority (otherwise, I subsisted on rice and beans, discount vegetables, and dumpster-dived loaves of artisan bread).

More: Watch Hannah make her ice cream machine-piña colada on Facebook Live.

As I moved further into adulthood, I worked more (in bakeries and bars) and bicycled less, and no longer had the time or caloric needs to spend on quarts of ice cream. But I still relied on my ice cream maker for special dinner party desserts that I could prepare in advance, or to make flavors that came to me in daydreams (or via David Leibovitz’s blog). When I moved to New York, I pared down the possessions I’d accumulated in five years of post-collegiate adult life, finally letting go of my crates of dried-up oil paints and leaving behind collectible antique furniture, but the ice cream maker traveled with me. It came along again a few years later when my boyfriend and I moved in together, merging our kitchens.


Just two months later Hurricane Sandy flooded our new apartment to the ceiling, knocking down shelves with literal hurricane force and swirling everything we owned in a vortex of toxic muddy water: The ice cream maker didn’t survive. Many of my kitchenwares (pots, pans, metal bowls, and even knives) could be salvaged, but anything mechanical was instantly corroded. Still traumatized (not to mention impoverished) from the storm, I rebuilt my life—and stocked my new kitchen—as minimally as possible.

But it was less than a year before I missed my ice cream maker. That cute pink bucket had been discontinued, so I ordered a tasteful aqua Cuisinart and an extra canister, so I could always keep one frozen and ready for a spontaneous batch of chocolate coconut milk ice cream, melon and mint sorbet, or something brilliant Max Falkowitz tweeted about, like black sesame with a hint of orange zest.

I know the ones with a compressor are better. There’s nothing to freeze ahead of time, and they can produce a smoother ice cream, free of even a hint of ice crystals. But it would take up too much precious kitchen real estate, and my Cuisinart works just fine. And for less than $50, it’s an expense you can justify, even after (well, a while after) a hurricane. (Particularly when you need to recipe-test miso caramel ice cream for the Good Fork Cookbook.)

More cocktails to try it with:

The Negroni

The Negroni by Erika Kotite

Frozen Banana Daiquiri

Frozen Banana Daiquiri by Erik Lombardo

Whiskey Peach Smash

Whiskey Peach Smash by Kenzi Wilbur

Watermelon Campari Granita

Watermelon Campari Granita by Alice Medrich

Anyway, my ice cream maker found a new life this summer: While researching piña coladas, I found deep in the depths of the internet a recipe that called for churning the mixture in an ice cream maker. It turns out an ice cream maker is also a (boozy) slushie machine, spinning batches of cocktails as smooth as a 7-11 Slurpee, but way more sophisticated.

I’m also looking forward to trying Jeffrey Morgenthaler’s frozen Negroni, and perhaps an updated strawberry daiquiri when the late summer berries show up in the market again—not to mention batches of ice cream, like the buttermilk-fresh peach one (adapted from Jeni Britton Bauer’s buttermilk and roasted strawberry) I made last month, and the delicately perfumed lavender ice cream I’ve been contemplating, as well as the sake kasu soft serve I fell in love with in Japan last winter and hope to to replicate. My ice cream maker continues to earn its special place on my shelves and in my heart.

B17e90ab 9382 4303 88b1 8ae6f6981e80  2016 0809 how to make a frozen cocktail in an ice cream machine bobbi lin 2298

Best-Ever Piña Colada

45e1c0e6 615e 44fc b620 254b0540ca6d  screen shot 2015 12 21 at 11.11.42 pm Hannah Kirshner
66 Save
Makes 4 to 6 cups
  • 1 pineapple (3 to 4 cups chunks)
  • 1/4 cup raw sugar, plus more to taste
  • Zest and juice of 1 lime, plus more juice to taste
  • 1 cup (scant) scant cup pure, whole fat coconut milk
  • Pinch said
  • 1/2 cup mild rum, such as Don Q gold
  • 1/2 cup Smith & Cross Jamaican Rum
  • Pineapple leaves or mint sprigs, for garnish
Go to Recipe

Hannah Kirshner is a Brooklyn-based food stylist, recipe developer, and the editor of Sweets & Bitters. Watch for her frequent appearances on the Food52 Facebook Live stream.

Do you use your ice cream machine for recipes other than ice cream? Tell us about it in the comments!

Tags: pina colada, ice cream machine