I Didn’t Like Grandma’s Brisket—But Here's Why I’ll Always Love It

July 12, 2018

It was 7:30 on a Sunday morning, and I was just biding my time until the grocery store opened so I could buy a brisket. It’s not unusual for me to wake up thinking about dinner, but Jewish brisket is outside my normal rotation. Then again, that particular week had been anything but normal.

I had spent much of the previous week sitting by grandmother’s bed in hospice, recounting happy memories and craving all the foods I ate at her house—her salad, her fruit salad, cottage cheese, bitter coffee with flavored creamer. I got the call at 2 a.m. on Saturday night that she had passed away at 89, due to complications from Parkinson’s. Unsurprisingly, my sleep was sparse and patchy for the five and a half hours between getting the call and deciding to get up and get a brisket. It made sense, then, that I’d be looking for soothing, hearty comfort food, a meal I had at my grandparents’ house many times.

Except I don’t like Jewish-style brisket. I never have. It’s a hard admission to make! This dish is canon and beloved, in my family and beyond, and my quibbles are my own. I just find it too soft and sweet, the meat buried beneath steamed carrots and onions, with hits of ketchup and, if you’re feeling fancy, wine. I always want it to have the meaty intensity and caramelized fat of other brisket techniques. My grandmother’s brisket was a true midcentury special: rubbed with French onion soup mix, wrapped tightly in foil with slices of carrot, cooked at low heat until it was spoon-tender. One time she overcooked it, and the toothsome result finally resembled something I might enjoy.

Shop the Story

She stopped cooking brisket—or really anything at all—years before her death. Her senior-living apartment was too small to entertain, and it just wasn’t the sort of thing she would cook for herself. As her health deteriorated, she became more reliant on soups and salads from the dining hall. In the Jewish retirement community, brisket was offered frequently, but I don’t remember her eating it. Maybe she wasn’t a fan either, after all. Maybe she had cooked it because it was simply what one did.

Maybe she had cooked it because it was simply what one did.

So when I woke up craving it, in addition to looking for comfort, I wanted to carry on the tradition. I was keenly aware of being the daughter of her daughter, and all the responsibility that might entail. I felt a certain urgency to make something that would channel all of her upbringing. I hoped I could make it taste better than I remembered. I knew I would need to use ketchup, but I also knew I should put a sear on the brisket first, and use more herbs and spices. I made it and it was perfect, the ideal of what I thought an Eastern European Jewish brisket should be—deep, rich, caramelized flavors cozied up with crisped fatty edges. It was still softer and sweeter than anything I want to eat regularly, but I felt overwhelmed by love while I was eating it.

I still didn’t like it. But I still loved it.

When you’re a food writer or a recipe developer, like I am, food becomes a sum of its parts: saltiness, acidity, sweetness, bitterness, tenderness. Is it crisp? Is it caramelized? We strive for balance and subtlety, contrasting textures and sometimes temperatures. We look for ways to make our food habits more ethical and sustainable. It’s a thoughtful and generally delicious way to eat; I’m not knocking it. But it doesn’t have a whole lot to do with the foods of my childhood—the starchy things that came together in a hurry, the vegetables cooked just a couple of minutes too long— that are tied to my happy memories, the ones helped shape me into an adult who cares about food.

My childhood foods were pasta with margarine and parmesan from a can; Morningstar Farms breakfast sausage that bounced off my molars; Edy’s French Silk frozen yogurt, which was light as air and tasted like chocolate-flavored envelope glue in a really delicious way; my mom’s stir-fries; my dad’s endless variations of rice and beans from a stovetop pressure cooker. He made them after my sister and I became vegetarians. When we went out to eat, the fanciest, most divine meal I could imagine was Caesar salad, fettuccine alfredo, and chocolate mousse for dessert. Shrimp cocktail was another special occasion sort of treat, and Whippet cookies were a vacation staple, the chocolate shell cracked with a finger-flick to get to the marshmallow. Not much was gourmet or made from scratch, but these are the foods whose precise being I can recall in any given moment. They’re home base.

Everyone has their own versions of these foods, the things on the table while we formed our childhood memories, whether they’re bowls of frosted flakes or bowls of pho. Whatever critiques we might have about the flavor or texture, these foods overwhelm our senses with comfort and memories. A single bite can bring back the hopes we had, the jokes we told with friends, the happy holidays with family, and memories of times past that we ate them.

When I look at my childhood foods from a critical, technical perspective, the frozen yogurt is too sweet, the pasta is too mushy, the chicken stir-fries just a tad overcooked. There was a level of routine and restraint—one glug of canola, one clove garlic, pressed, chicken breast cut into bite-size pieces, cook until it’s white all the way through—that I don’t practice in my own cooking. My meals are largely driven by what produce looked good at the store, what restaurant dish I’m trying to re-create, or what new jar of pickled-something or chili product I’m using as many ways as I can. I’m an irredeemable tinkerer, endlessly working to achieve dishes that are both exciting and balanced. Constantly surrounded by food content, I’ve developed a madcap refusal to cook the same meal twice—except for when I fall back on the classics.

That's when I reach for the plain pasta, now maybe with olive oil instead of margarine, at least once a week. I love it even though I know that some lemon, a grind of pepper, and some capers—or any other of a million combinations of spices, to say nothing of a pile of roasted vegetables—would make it a lot better. It’s simple and affirming and is the first thing I learned to cook for myself. And when I want to remember my grandparents, and childhood afternoons sitting under the piano reading books, I’ll buy brisket, sear it, wrap it up tight with ketchup, herbs, carrots, onions, and handfuls of herbs, and then cook it until everything’s mush.

What are some food you love—though you may not necessarily like them? Let us know in the comments.

Tastes Like Home

Listen Now

On our new weekly podcast, two friends separated by the Atlantic take questions and compare notes on everything from charcuterie trends to scone etiquette.

Listen Now

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Steve Hanegan
    Steve Hanegan
  • Michelle S.
    Michelle S.
  • Rick Schnabel
    Rick Schnabel
  • Devin K Thomas
    Devin K Thomas
  • Stacyober


Steve H. July 15, 2018
Auntie Ruthie's Brisket! (1) bottle of chili sauce, two sliced onions, a beer and a brisket.. cook into submission... Pretty plain next to my smoked Texas style efforts, but woe be unto me if I mess with the recipe in ANY way for ANY of the traditional gatherings of friends and family where it is served! Thankfully, I have learned to love it.
Michelle S. July 15, 2018
My moms an excellent cook so not really any horrible yet memorable foods to share however she sometimes made things that I just personally don’t like the taste of even if they came out great. Her lemon meringue pie (hate lemon anything) and ambrosia she made for potlucks some times. Oh and my dad’s split pea soup or when he made liver. I don’t know if it was because he was German and those are German things or if it was just my dad but ewww. Otherwise being the foodie I am Im grateful they were both such great cooks. My moms enchiladas OMG no one makes them like her. Or her poundcake or Herman-just the best!! And my dad (sadly passed early 2000s too young) made the most amazing homemade fries and burgers. Ive never found their equal. Id do just about anything to have him again though with or without his awesome food.
Rick S. July 15, 2018
I truly identify 100% with this. My mother’s brisket is probably very, very similar to your grandmothers (Lipton onion soup, red wine, brown sugar, etc.). I too, not a fan, but I make it for every single family holiday dinner without fail and there are rarely leftovers. Thanks for sharing
Layla S. July 15, 2018
Thanks for reading! Glad you’re carrying on the tradition. I suspect there are a lot of us.
Devin K. July 13, 2018
over cooked squash, burnt meat from grill, over cooked spaghetti with watery sauce, awful dad favorites...These are some of my memories of kid food.

But I also remember great fish grilled outside, Watermelon seed spitting contest, U Pik corn with butter straight from the field and homemade ice cream on the porch we all took turns turning.
Love the story, Thank You for sharing
Stacyober July 12, 2018
Thank you for this great article! I opened a tiny sandwich shop in Old Pasadena CA- Uniin Street Sandwich Company. My signature sandwich is brisket served on a french roll.
Privately, I refer to this sandwich as Rosh Hoshana Brisket.
And yes, one bite takes me back to any of my childhood holiday dinners prepared by my Baba, then my mother and then by me. Both my adult son and daughter know how to make this brisket too. A rite of cooking passage in our family.
GeekKnitter July 12, 2018
Saltines crunched up in a mug of cold milk. It was my mom's answer to many childhood troubles, from falling out of a tree to getting snubbed at recess. I learned to make it a bit more palatable by adding the crackers 1-2 at a time, but the last half-inch was always the consistency of salted wallpaper paste. Still and all, I've been known to have it now and again when I'm feeling particularly chin-quivery and bereft. It brings back the feeling of her hand rubbing gentle circles between my shoulder blades, and I begin to think it might all be ok some day.
Nikkitha B. July 13, 2018
This is so sweet! Crushing *anything* up in milk always does it for me.