Books
This Hearty Weeknight Soup Is Genius-Approved—& Darn Simple
It's got a few clever tricks up its sleeve.
From our new podcast network, The Genius Recipe Tapes is lifelong Genius hunter Kristen Miglore’s 10-year-strong column in audio form, featuring all the uncut gems from the weekly column and video series. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts so you don’t miss out.
Listen & SubscribePopular on Food52
9 Comments
Shelly
November 12, 2018
I think the frustrating part of this is that the pictured soup (which looks delicious) is clearly not the soup in the recipe (which sounds delicious). But since there is seared tofu on top, it looks like the article is trying to fake us out!
Brinda A.
November 13, 2018
Thanks for reading, Shelly, and I definitely understand. The pictured dish (Andrea Nguyen's vegan chicken pho) is actually the inspiration for several elements of this soup recipe, which is why I've included it here.
Shelly
November 13, 2018
Thanks for letting me know the recipe associated with the picture! I'm totally going to look that up because it looks (and sounds) delicious!
Sandra
November 11, 2018
Seriously? this is the recipe? One that includes two different recipe links; tells us to add "up to 2 cups of nutritional yeast" (what's that, about $10?), try to figure out her chicken scratch notes . . . I'm totally confused. There's no recipe and although I cook . . . a LOT . . . this is about as far from a something that would be ready in about an hour as I can imagine. And seriously, how much nutritional yeast is there? I was expecting some sort of recipe, not a long monologue with a zillion links. Is a link missing? What's up with this? It's about the worst advertisement for this cook-in-the-blanks idea I ever heard of. It's so much more of a complicated recipe than most complicated recipes, even though the recipe sounds really good. but this is about as confusing as it gets. All I can figure out is that somebody forgot to put an actual link to the recipe in here.
Brinda A.
November 12, 2018
Hi Sandra and Kris, thanks so much for reading, and I’m sorry this story didn’t resonate with you. Correct, the “recipe” here is the template itself (the one you see in the photo), and the idea is you’re free to fill in the blanks with whatever you like best and/or have on hand from the named categories. The suggestions Kristen wrote in here are just that, and add a lot of flavor to the soup in a short time. But feel free to swap or sub in what calls out to you (for example, instead of the nutritional yeast-flavored broth, you can use more water or a stock of your choosing). And if you’re looking for traditional step-by-step recipes, maybe one of these will help: https://food52.com/blog/23093-easy-comforting-noodle-dinners-for-weeknights
Kristen M.
November 19, 2018
Hi Sandra, sorry for the confusion about the nutritional yeast amounts—as Brinda said, this isn't intended to be used as a recipe (the whole Cook in the Blank concept is definitively not-recipe). My intent with that part was to shout out to Andrea Nguyen's genius trick for making a rich vegan "chicken" stock with nutritional yeast by writing "(nutritional yeast + hot water, sludge left behind)"—her recipe is linked in the story above for more details and amounts, and I will paste it here, in case you want to learn more or just use the exact recipe: https://food52.com/recipes/68110-andrea-nguyen-s-vegan-chicken-ph
Sandra
November 19, 2018
Thanks for your kind response to my cranky one. I would be interested in the Cook in the Blank idea, but I was very intrigued about using nutritional yeast for a stock, since I'm going for an about-80% vegan diet, and I love soup. I will check it out; I'm curious about how much nutritional yeast is used, give or take. The Cook in the Blank says "up to 2 cups" which is pretty nonspecific; but the "non-recipe" looks really delicious overall, and I like the idea. I probably do most of that already -- I love making "minestrone," which ends up with such different combinations that I'm not sure it's actually minestrone by the end of the process. I'm really excited about adding a nutritional yeast stock to the mix! Thank you for the interesting article, for clarifying, and for the recipe link.
Sandra
November 19, 2018
P.S. -- I think the article title may be why it felt misleading. The charming notes on the template are pretty much impossible to figure out, because they use such personal style and abbreviations, etc. So it seems that calling it a "Weeknight Soup . . . Darn simple!" it sounds like a recipe. The title would be better as "Hearty Weeknight Soups." Still, in all, I'm glad for the article, since the soup looks so intriguing.
Join The Conversation