Community
Life After Layoffs: How Empanadas Gave Me a Sense of Belonging
On finding the perfect empanada dough, fulfillment in work, and acceptance by local Peruvian mamás.
Photo by James Ransom
On our new weekly podcast, two friends separated by the Atlantic take questions and compare notes on everything from charcuterie trends to scone etiquette.
Listen NowPopular on Food52
71 Comments
JasonB
February 17, 2021
Wonderful Carlos thank you. I have been all about these lately, tried making the dough from scratch but then I realized I was more interested in getting creative with the fillings so I started buying the frozen wrappers; this works for my purposes and allows me to explore all the great flavors of Latin food.
TheEmpanadaStud
August 23, 2020
To Readers that Thought this Article Did Not Meet their Mental Orgasmic Expectations:
Get over it! This was a great human interest story related to food. I applaud Carlos Olaechea and Food52. "Que Viva el Peru, Carajo!
Get over it! This was a great human interest story related to food. I applaud Carlos Olaechea and Food52. "Que Viva el Peru, Carajo!
TheEmpanadaStud
August 23, 2020
To All Readers that Thought this Article Did Not Meet their Mental Orgasmic Expectations:
Get over it! This was a great human interest story related to food. I applaud Carlos Olaechea and Food52. "Que Viva el Peru, Carajo!
Get over it! This was a great human interest story related to food. I applaud Carlos Olaechea and Food52. "Que Viva el Peru, Carajo!
Carolyn W.
July 21, 2020
Carlos et al, irrespective of the furor over editorial choices, I'm so glad to hear that you are finding a way through the miserable job loss situations so many people are experiencing.
However, speaking from almost 20 years of HR experience, I can 99% guarantee you that HR was not the decision-maker on which positions would be eliminated. We get to deliver the bad news and take the heat, but the business owners make the call. Obviously that doesn't change the outcome and most HR professionals understand that it's safer to be upset with us than with people you'll need for references, but we do get work down being blamed.
However, speaking from almost 20 years of HR experience, I can 99% guarantee you that HR was not the decision-maker on which positions would be eliminated. We get to deliver the bad news and take the heat, but the business owners make the call. Obviously that doesn't change the outcome and most HR professionals understand that it's safer to be upset with us than with people you'll need for references, but we do get work down being blamed.
Claire R.
July 21, 2020
I can't find the recipe, store bought crust or not! Where is it?
2tattered
July 21, 2020
Guess the author or editors couldn’t take the heat, so they took it off this page. But put ‘empanadas’ or ‘empanadazo’ in the *Recipe* search box, and you’ll see it titled, ‘Empanadazo (Peruvian-Style) Giant Empanada’. The recipe isn’t worth the effort of looking for it, frankly.
Brinda A.
July 21, 2020
Hi Tracey, thank you for weighing in.
I am the Editorial Lead of Food52 and am happy to explain this further. The purpose of us publishing this piece was to share a story about the author's experience starting his own business in the face of the economic fallout of the pandemic. It's a poignant and relatable experience to so many who are experiencing economic uncertainty and hardship in this time. We wanted to provide a recipe to add color to this piece, and I believe that was where we made a mistake, for which I apologize. That is because the recipe we provided—the author's streamlined, at-home version of the empanadas he enjoys, and not the version he related in this piece at hand—was proving confusing for readers, and understandably so. Thus, we removed the recipe from this page to alleviate confusion. That being said, the recipe on its own is a completely worthwhile and tasty cooking endeavor, and we encourage readers to look it up if they are interested.
Sincerely,
Brinda Ayer
I am the Editorial Lead of Food52 and am happy to explain this further. The purpose of us publishing this piece was to share a story about the author's experience starting his own business in the face of the economic fallout of the pandemic. It's a poignant and relatable experience to so many who are experiencing economic uncertainty and hardship in this time. We wanted to provide a recipe to add color to this piece, and I believe that was where we made a mistake, for which I apologize. That is because the recipe we provided—the author's streamlined, at-home version of the empanadas he enjoys, and not the version he related in this piece at hand—was proving confusing for readers, and understandably so. Thus, we removed the recipe from this page to alleviate confusion. That being said, the recipe on its own is a completely worthwhile and tasty cooking endeavor, and we encourage readers to look it up if they are interested.
Sincerely,
Brinda Ayer
2tattered
July 21, 2020
Well, kudos for admitting to a mistake and apologizing. That is rare these days. Yes, it’s kind of a rough crowd here but I, at least, have come to expect more from this site than Mr. Olaechea’s recipe delivered. I don’t think readers were ‘confused’, I think they were let down and disappointed. The subtitle of the article led us to believe we would find a recipe for ‘the perfect empanada dough’, but instead we get frozen pie crust. Many of us are experienced cooks looking for interesting challenges, and don’t necessarily need recipes that are ‘approachable for the home cook’ ...so maybe some of us also felt a bit condescended to. Dan had it right from the start, and kbakich made some excellent points. Thank you for your honesty.
Ann R.
July 19, 2020
I want the buttery pie crust recipe! Wasn’t that the point of what Carlos was trying to achieve with his empanadas?
Rosalind P.
July 19, 2020
BIG fan of Food52 but come on! Crummy article, crummy recipe. Anybody remember Womans Day? Yeah, that bad. Most comments were about the crust bait and filling. But I want to know about that hunk of meat...the boliche...and how to turn that into a great fulling. Oh, well. Everyone's allowed a mistake now and then. Hope the Food52 folks learned from this doozie.
kgw
July 19, 2020
Wow...A lot of gourmet cooks here, I see! But it seems like all they really desire is Another pie dough recipe. How many do you have already?
Lordy me! I must admit it does not surprise me at the amount of whining here, given the current state of the 'union.'
Lordy me! I must admit it does not surprise me at the amount of whining here, given the current state of the 'union.'
2tattered
July 19, 2020
Please elaborate on the relationship between ‘whining’ about a substandard recipe and the ‘current state of the ‘union’ ‘.
SageDawn
July 19, 2020
It's an Empanada crust recipe I was expecting. Have made hundreds of pie crusts, never an Empanada.
kgw
July 19, 2020
Leaving "substandard' out of the picture, a lack of compassion is evident in in many of the current statements...
I refer to the relationship of oneself to oneself: it is immediately apparent. Be nice. To oneself.
I refer to the relationship of oneself to oneself: it is immediately apparent. Be nice. To oneself.
Lindsay S.
July 26, 2020
Everybody is on edge. That’s what isolation and fear of losing your livelihood does to people. Oh and riots.
kbakich
July 19, 2020
Food52, I have been a quiet but appreciative and loyal reader for many years. I’ve tried to overlook your overwhelming trend toward sponsored posts that I think detracts from the initial spirit of this community that was so appealing from the start. I applaud you for the diversity of perspectives you offer, and surely the author’s story of resiliency is one to celebrate and share. But I agree with other posters below that publishing an article extolling the virtues of a traditional Peruvian crust and then offering a recipe with a store bought pie crust doesn’t align with the values of this community. Your defense that it makes the recipe more accessible is a mockery to those of us who come here for meaningful food experiences. Please have a conversation about refocusing your posts in a way that speaks to those readers who helped to make this site what it is today.
Coral L.
July 20, 2020
Hi kbakich, thanks for taking the time to offer your feedback.
We wholly acknowledge that this might have been a confusing experience, and have amended the article to better explain why and when Carlos uses store-bought frozen pie crust.
We wholly acknowledge that this might have been a confusing experience, and have amended the article to better explain why and when Carlos uses store-bought frozen pie crust.
Tricia
July 19, 2020
What? Frozen pie crust? Thought there would be a crust recipe somewhere! Do Peruvians use frozen pie crust??? Too bad.😏
Taevia
July 19, 2020
The article itself was good, it's the email header that got me to look at the article was click bait. Don't promise a buttery empanada recipe in the email then give me one with store bought crust. Make your email titles match the article and it would have been fine.
Also an realization of the mistake and apologizing for it would go a lot further than justifying it. It was click bait, no matter how it's tried to be framed otherwise.
Also an realization of the mistake and apologizing for it would go a lot further than justifying it. It was click bait, no matter how it's tried to be framed otherwise.
Coral L.
July 20, 2020
Hi Taevia, thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts.
We hear you, and acknowledge how this might have been a confusing experience. We've amended the article to better explain why and when Carlos uses store-bought frozen pie crust.
We hear you, and acknowledge how this might have been a confusing experience. We've amended the article to better explain why and when Carlos uses store-bought frozen pie crust.
Mischa_nyc
July 19, 2020
This is disappointing. Your dough recipe is yours to keep, but It would serve in the future be explain from the beginning that the intention is not to share it. There is no need to disparage an entire community in the process.
Coral L.
July 20, 2020
Hi Mischa_nyc; thank you for writing in.
Hi kbakich, thanks for taking the time to offer your feedback. We've edited the article to better explain why and when Carlos prefers store-bought frozen pie crust to homemade.
Hi kbakich, thanks for taking the time to offer your feedback. We've edited the article to better explain why and when Carlos prefers store-bought frozen pie crust to homemade.
Mischa_nyc
July 19, 2020
Though the use of store bought dough in the recipe was a let down, the bigger let down was the indictment of the anglo-American and Peruvian communities in Miami. Your dough recipe is yours to keep, but be explicit from the beginning that the intention is not to share it. There is no need to disparage an entire community as your reason for not sharing it. I expected more from a “feel good” article.
SageDawn
July 19, 2020
Wow! I enjoyed this article as the fantasy of having a little food business has always been a small daydream for me, but then I read the recipe. My first thoughts were (out loud) What! How could this be? Such a lovely, enticing build-up and then: ground beef, no chilies, store bought crust, optional bouillon cube and powdered sugar. For a brief second I was actually a bit angry at this bait & switch let-down. So as I read others comments including the author's responses I actually did become a bit angrier. I too as a member of the 52 community feel this issue presented is in very poor taste. No real pun intended. As a child one of my greatest desires was to learn how to make a real, buttery, flaky, pie crust. Having learned this one well, as an adult I am a bit more adventurous with all things dough. I would have loved the challenge to attempt this author's recipe, but instead we have all been duped.
Dan
July 19, 2020
After having the same disappointment as others, and after reading all of the responses by the author and editors, I encourage you to simply remove the recipe. You sell one thing in the article, and then publish a recipe that can't be close to what is described in the article. I heard a needle scratch (just dated myself) when I got to the recipe.
Without the recipe, this is a feel good post detailing how one person used food to overcome adversity.
Replace the recipe with a paragraph that explains the crust is complex to make, includes ingredients that are difficult to source, and that the author still throws out batches of dough because they just didn't work.
Without the recipe, this is a feel good post detailing how one person used food to overcome adversity.
Replace the recipe with a paragraph that explains the crust is complex to make, includes ingredients that are difficult to source, and that the author still throws out batches of dough because they just didn't work.
Coral L.
July 20, 2020
Hi Dan! Thank you for the feedback. We've amended the article to better explain Carlos's reasoning for store-bought crust over homemade, and have unlinked the recipe from the article.
stacey H.
July 19, 2020
This article was poorly written, poorly edited and the recipe looks like something from food.com. On a positive note, it was refreshing to feel irritated about something trivial! It felt pre-Covid. I did enjoy feeling outraged with the other commenters. So, thank you for that and I guess I'll stick to serious eats for recipes and food writing. I don't think Kenji hides his recipes...
janet G.
July 19, 2020
Frozen pie crust? And he responds by saying make your own? I expected more from this site. Why not just recommend Hamburger Helper?
Susan O.
July 19, 2020
What times we are living in. This is a story. And a recipe. It is an invitation for your viewing. And maybe, your trying. And maybe your own spin on it such as homemade pie crust. Seriously, ask yourself how your mother/father would have responded to a recipe offering from someone else.
Join The Conversation